You are on page 1of 7

Global Journal of Environmental Research 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

ISSN 1990-925X
© IDOSI Publications, 2008

Effect of Temperature on Mortality and Behavioural Responses in


Freshwater Catfish, Heteropneustes fossilis (Bloch) Exposed to Dimethoate

Rakesh Kumar Pandey, Ram Nayan Singh and Vijai Krishna Das

Department of Zoology, Kamla Nehru Institute of Physical and Social Sciences,


Sultanpur, U.P.- 228118, India

Abstract: Temperature has significant influence on physio-chemical responses of all living organisms including
fish. The present study was conducted to evaluate the effect of temperature on dimethoate toxicity (96 h static
bioassay) to freshwater catfish Heteropneustes fossilis. Fish mortality data were recorded at 24, 48, 72 and
96 h and analysed using EPA Probit analysis, Version 1.5, software based on Finney's Probit Analysis method
to calculate LC50 values. The 96 h LC50 values at temperatures, 17.16±0.78°C (January) and 27.50±1.50°C
(August) were found to be 14.39 mg lG1 and 2.98 mg lG1 respectively. Alterations in behavioural responses,
especially the schooling, surfacing, mucus secretion, skin colour, eyelid condition and opercular movement
were also studied. The increase in fish mortality at higher temperature indicated in the present study may be
helpful to determine season specific toxicant concentration for field applications to avoid adverse effect on non
target organisms.

Key words: Organophosphate % Dimethoate % LC50. Behaviour % OCM. Heteropneustes fossilis

INTRODUCTION brain and peripheral nervous system [3, 4]. Dimethoate


(CAS 60-51-5, O,O-dimethyl s- methyl- carbamoylmethyl
Pesticides of various categories viz., phosphorodithioate), a wide spectrum systemic and
organophosphates, organochlorines, pyrethroids and contact insecticide is used against a broad range of
carbamates are used against a number of pests, to insects and mites. USNTP has classified it as moderately
increase the crop production. Besides their use against to highly toxic chemical pesticide and PAN Bad
agricultural pests, the pesticides are generously used to Actors considered it a chemical of special concern
control the population of mosquitoes, houseflies, termites, (http://www.pesticideinfo.org/Docs/ref_toxicity7.html#
other household and stored grain pests. The short- BadActors). USEPA has released an Interim Re-
sighted approach to eradicate harmful insects has led to registration Eligibility Decision (IRED) in June 2006 and
indiscriminate use of pesticides, unmindful of their concluded that the FQPA (Food Quality Protection
consequences to the environment. The remains of Act-1996) safety factor for dimethoate should be removed
pesticides either enter into the atmosphere as aerosol (http://www.epa.gov/oppsrrd1/REDs/dimethoate_ired.p
or into the aquatic system through runoff water, df). In rats and human, dimethoate is rapidly eliminated
inadvertently exposing the non-target organisms and trough urinary route; 76-90% is reported to appear in urine
finally finding their way to the food chain threatening the within 24 h [5]. Dimethoate is hydrolysed by enzymes
ecological balance and the biodiversity of the nature. esterases and amidases found in mammals. Insects,
Aquatic contamination of pesticides causes acute and deficient in these enzymes, however, can not hydrolyze
chronic poisoning of fish and cause severe damage to dimethoate and become susceptible to it [6].
vital organs [1, 2]. In present scenario of global warming, the increasing
The toxicity of OP is due to their ability to inhibit atmospheric temperature is matter of great concern for
cholinesterase enzyme which results in the accumulation the environmentalists to obtain relevant knowledge on
of acetylcholine in nerve tissues and the effecter tolerance of organisms to the temperature. The sensitivity
organs with the principal site of action being the of fishes exposed to the toxicants depends on biological

Corresponding Author: Rakesh Kumar Pandey, Department of Zoology, Kamla Nehru Institute of Physical and Social Sciences,
Sultanpur, U.P.- 228118, India
126
Global J. Environ. Res., 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

factors (age, sex and size) as well as physico-chemical with similar number of fish. The experiment was
factors viz., temperature, pH and hardness of test conducted for 96 h and the fish mortality at each
water [7-9]. This study was conducted to determine concentration was recorded at an interval of 24, 48, 72 and
the toxicity level of dimethoate at two different 96 h. Fish were not given any food during the test [11].
temperatures, 17.16±0.78°C (January) and 27.50±1.50°C Dead fish were immediately removed from the trough.
(August), on the fresh water catfish Heteropneustes During experiment, temperature, pH and dissolved oxygen
fossilis. Alterations in behavioural activities are important (DO) were routinely measured. Behavioural parameters
indicator of stress in fishes exposed to toxicants, such as schooling behaviour, excitability and reflex
therefore, changes in behaviour was studied and responses, swimming pattern, surfacing and gulping air,
compared at these temperatures. mucus secretion, changes in body colour, eyelids
condition, fins and barbels position (Table 3) and also the
MATERIALS AND METHODS opercular movement per minute (OCM) were constantly
monitored and recorded for 96 h (Fig. 2). The change in
The fish, Heteropneustes fossilis (av. length OCM with respect to dimethoate concentration and
17.40±1.14 cm and av. weight 27.14±1.95 g) of both sexes exposure time was analyzed using two-way ANOVA,
were collected from local ponds and carefully brought to for the statistical significance (Table 4). The bioassay
the laboratory avoiding any injury to the fish during experiment was carried out following the standard
transport. The fish were disinfected with 0.05% solution methods of APHA [12]. The fish mortality data
of KmnO4 for two minutes and then transferred to a recorded for 24, 48, 72 and 96 h were subjected to
500 l capacity plastic tank to acclimatize for 14 days in EPA Probit Analysis, Version 1.5 statistical software
laboratory conditions. They were regularly fed with a (http://www.epa.gov/nerleerd/stat2.htm#tsk), based on
mixture of wheat flour, mustard cake, Soya and dried Finney's method [13].
prawn powder in ratio of 3:1:1:1 [10]. Fish were given food
in the evening. The leftover was thoroughly cleaned and RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
water of the tank was changed in the subsequent
morning. The physico-chemical properties viz. temperature,
The static bioassay test was conducted under natural DO, free CO2 and total alkalinity as CaCO3 of test water
photoperiod for 96 h in the months of January and were measured during the bioassay in both seasons
August at water temperatures 17.16±0.78°C and (Table 1). The LC50 values for dimethoate for 24, 48, 72 and
27.50±1.50°C respectively. Water quality characteristics 96 h of both seasons are summarized in Table 2. At low
for both the months are given in Table 1. The experiment temperature fish appear more tolerant towards toxicant in
was conducted in glass trough of 15 l capacity. Technical comparison to high temperature, as it is evident by the
grade dimethoate (30% EC) popularly known as Rogor, considerable difference in LC50 values of dimethoate
was procured from Rallis India Ltd., Mumbai (India). The (Table 2). LC50 values have been found to vary in
stock solution was prepared by diluting the dimethoate in different fish species and even in the same species at
absolute alcohol. Solutions for dose were prepared from different conditions. Verma et al. [14] recorded,
the stock by further dilution with alcohol to get dosing 5.14 mg lG1, 4.8 mg lG1, 4.67 mg lG1 and 4.57 mg lG1 LC50
concentrations. The range finding tests showed no value for 24, 48, 72 and 96 h respectively in
mortality at concentration 2.50 mg lG1, 70% mortality at Heteropneustes fossilis exposed to dimethoate. A 96 h
3.25 mg lG1 and 100% mortality at 4.00 mg lG1 in August. LC50 value for dimethoate, on Clarias batrachus was
The range finding results in January were as follows; reported as 65 mg lG1 by Begum and Vijayraghvan [15]. In
no mortality at 12 mg lG1, 70% at 16 mg lG1 and 100% Channa punctatus, Dikshith and Raizada [16] measured
mortality at 19 mg lG1. All determined concentrations were 68 mg lG1 LC50 (96 h) for dimethoate which is very high
repeated four times. A control was simultaneously run in comparison to 17.9 mg lG1 LC50 value (24 h) in the same

Table 1: Physico-chemical parameters of test water


Month Water temp. (°C) pH DO (mg lG1) Free CO2 (mg lG1) Total hardness (mg lG1)
January 17.16±0.78 7.39±0.23 7.20±0.16 4.05±0.13 115.50±1.29
August 27.50±1.50 7.30±0.17 7.80±0.34 3.25±0.12 112.34±0.25

127
Global J. Environ. Res., 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

Probit Probit

10+ o 10+ o o
- -
- -
- -
- -
9+ 9+
- -
- -
- -
- -
8+ 8+
- -
- -
- . - .
- -
7+ . 7+ .
- .. - ..
- o .. - ..
- ... - .o.
- .... - ....
6+ ...o 6+ ....
- .... - ....
- ..o - ...o
- .... - ....
- ...o - ....
5+ ... 5+ ..o
- .... - ....
- ....o - ....
- o.. - o...
- .... - ....
4+ o.... 4+ ....
- .... - ....
- ... - o...
- .. - ..
- .. - ..
3+ . 3+ .
- -
-. -.
- -
- -
2+ 2+
- -
- -
- -
- -
1+ 1+
- -
- -
- -
- -
0+ -+--------------+--------+---------+---------+--------+--------------+- 0+ -+--------------+--------+---------+---------+--------+--------------+-
EC01 EC10 EC25 EC50 EC75 EC90 EC99 EC01 EC10 EC25 EC50 EC75 EC90 EC99

96 h LC50 (Jan) 96 h LC50 (Aug)

96 h LC50 (January)
Parameter Estimate Std. Err. 95% Confidence Limits
Intercept-12.514366 1.745850 (-15.936233, -9.092500)
Slope 15.123926 1.486897 (12.209608, 18.038244)
Theoretical Spontaneous Response Rate = 0.0000

96 h LC50 (August)
Parameter Estimate Std. Err. 95% Confidence Limits
Intercept -4.838916 1.012849 (-6.824100,-2.853732)
Slope 20.736319 2.085917 (16.647921, 24.824717)
Theoretical Spontaneous Response Rate = 0.0000

Fig. 1: Plot of adjusted Probits and predicted regression line for dimethoate to Heteropneustes fossilis

128
Global J. Environ. Res., 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

January (17.16 ± 0.78 o C)


70

60
OCM per Minute

50
24 h
40
48 h
30
72 h
20
96 h
10

0
C 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Concentration (mgl-1)

o
August (27.50 ± 1.50 C)
70

60
OCM per Minute

50 24 h
40
48 h
30
72 h
20
96 h
10

0
C 2.5 2.75 3 3.25 3.5 3.75 4
Concentration (mgl-1)

Fig. 2: Opercular Movement (OCM) of Heteropneustes fossilis exposed to Dimethoate in the month of January
and August (C= Control)

129
Global J. Environ. Res., 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

Table 2: LC50 values of dimethoate on Heteropneustes fossilis


August January
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LC50 Lower Upper LC50 Lower Upper
Duration (h) (mg lG1 ) confidence limit confidence limit (mg lG1 ) confidence limit confidence limit
24 3.41 3.34 3.49 16.71 16.44 17.00
48 3.13 3.05 3.20 15.95 15.63 16.26
72 3.08 2.99 3.15 15.38 15.06 15.70
96 2.98 2.91 3.05 14.39 13.99 14.76

Table 3: Comparison between behavioural parameters at two different temperatures


January August
Behaviour (17.16±0.78°C) (27.50±1.50°C)
Schooling Disrupted Disrupted
Excitability and reflex responses Reduced with increase in toxicant conc. And time Similar changes
Swimming pattern Abrupt and Jerky, shows gradual improvement with time similar observations
Surfacing and gulping No surfacing at low conc. Frequent at higher conc. Frequent surfacing at all conc. Within 24 h of
exposure
Opercular movement Declines with respect to concentration Declines with respect to time and concentration
Mucus secretion Huge amount of mucus secretion Moderate secretion at almost all conc.

Skin colour Drastic changes in colour associated with appearance of Loss of pigmentation
rashes and patches on the skin Rashes and patches on skin do not appear
Eye condition Turned white and opaque Remained bright and transparent
Fin posture Drooped at higher conc. Show similar changes
Barbels condition Dropped at tips with increase in conc. and time No such effects were observed

Table 4: Result of Two Way ANOVA on OCM with respect to Concentration and Time on Heteropneustes fossilis exposed to Dimethoate
Source Sum of Degree of Mean Level of
Month Parameters of Variance Squares freedom Square F-ratio Significance
January Concentration Between Column 7620.14 8 953.00 2.75 p<0.05
Duration Between Rows 486.84 3 162.00 0.47 NS
Residual Error 8330.51 24 347.00
August Concentration Between Column 9977.81 7 1425.41 7.01 p<0.05)
Duration Between Rows 2924.31 3 974.80 4.80 p<0.05)
Residual Error 4268.22 21 203.25

fish reported by Srivastava and Singh [17]. In this study, Rajbanshi [21]. The mortality of fishes exposed to mercury
96 h LC50 values in the month of August and January increases with rise in temperature but reduces when the
were recorded as 2.98 mg lG1 and 14.39 mg lG1 respectively hardness of test water is increased [8], similarly, pH and
(Fig. 1). This huge difference in LC50 shows that the fish water hardness also affect mortality of Cirrhinus mrigala,
Heteropneustes fossilis becomes more sensitive to after nickel exposure [9].
dimethoate at higher temperature. This is in agreement A comparative study of behavioural responses
with Patra et al. [18] who reported that fish exposed to (Table 3) demonstrates that schooling behaviour,
chlorpyrifos and endosulfan exhibited increased mortality excitability and reflex responses, swimming pattern and
with increase in temperature. Variation in LC50 depends on the condition of fins of the exposed fishes were more or
a number of biological and physico-chemical factors less similar at two different temperatures. However,
which have been reported by many earlier workers. The parameters such as surfacing and gulping, mucus
results of acute toxicity may vary even in same species, secretion, body colour, condition of eyes and barbels and
for the same toxicant, depending on the size, age, sex and the opercular movement were remarkably different. At low
condition of the test species together with experimental temperature the surfacing and gulping exhibit an increase
factors [7]. The toxicity of cypermethrin to H. fossilis in comparison to control fish. At higher temperature
linearly increases with increase in temperature [19]. The very high frequency of it was observed [10]. Increased
seasonal variations and pH also has direct effect on fish frequency of surfacing and gulping may be due to
mortality in brook trout [20]. Increased mortality at higher deficiency in respiratory exchange, as a result of severe
temperature, due to Copper and Cadmium exposure in disruption of gill membranes and deposition of mucus
Heteropneustes fossilis has been observed by Gupta and on gills [2]. When toxicant concentration is very high

130
Global J. Environ. Res., 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

(at low temperature), the fish secretes copious mucus from could be minimized. EPA also considered the effect of
all over the body in order to neutralize the adverse effect changing application timing of dimethoate to the fall or
of large amount of the toxicant, whereas mucus secretion spring or modeling application in different areas
remains moderate in proportion to the small quantity of (http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/cumulative).
insecticide at higher temperature. The erratic and abrupt
swimming in fish results due to obstruction in acetyl ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
cholinesterase activity [3, 22]. The skin colour of exposed
fish during January shows drastic changes associated The financial assistance of University Grant
with appearance of haemorrhagic rashes and loss of Commission to one of the authors, R.K.P. (F.5.1.3 (71)/
pigmentation at low temperature, this feature was less 2004 (MRP / NRCB) to carry out the project is gratefully
apparent in fishes exposed to high temperature (in acknowledged. We are thankful to Dr. Gunraj Prasad,
August). It could probably be due to the higher toxicant Principal, KNIPSS, Sultanpur, for providing required
concentration (in January), to which fishes are exposed. research facilities.
Severe degenerative changes like necrosis and rupture of
blood vessels leading to hemorrhage have also been REFERENCES
reported [1] at higher concentration. The loss of skin
pigment occurs possibly as a result of impairment of 1. Omitoyin, B.O., E.K. Ajani, B.T. Adesina and
pituitary functions, causing reduction in number and size C.N.F. Okuagu, 2006. Toxicity of Lindane (Gamma
of chromatophores and their pigment content [22, 24]. The Hexachloro-CycloHexane) to Clarias gariepinus
eyes become opaque when fish are exposed to higher (Burchell 1822). World J. Zool., 1(1): 57-63.
dimethoate concentration at low temperature. Drooping of 2. Velmurugan, B.M. Selvanayagam, E.I. Cengiz and
fins and loss of extensile nature of the barbels in exposed E. Unlu, 2007. The effects of Monocrotophos to
fish may be a result of atrophy of muscle proteins [25] and different tissues of freshwater fish Cirrhinus
change in electrolytes balance and decrease in serum mrigala. Bullet. Environ. Contamination Toxicol.,
calcium after insecticide exposure [26]. The OCM of 78(6): 450-454.
Heteropneustes fossilis falls sharply within 24 h of 3. Rao, J.V., G. Begum, R. Pallela, P.K. Usman and
dimethoate exposure, thereafter, shows a steady decline R.N. Rao, 2005. Changes in behaviour and brain
with increase in exposure time and toxicant concentration acetyl cholinesterase activity in mosquito fish
(Fig. 2). Two way ANOVA of OCM (Table 4) exhibits a Gambusia affinis in reference to the sub lethal
significant change (P<0.05), when analyzed with respect exposure of chlorpyrifos. Intl. J. Environ. Res. Public
to toxicant concentration during January (17.16±0.78°C) Health, 2(3-4): 478-483.
and August (27.50±1.50°C). The decline in OCM with 4. Chawanrat Somnuek, Voravit Cheevaporn,
respect to time was significant during August (P<0.05), Chutarat Saengkula and F.William H. Beamish, 2007.
however, it is not significant during January Variability in Acetylcholinesterase upon Exposure to
(P>0.05). The OCM in another teleost Tilapia guineensis, Chlorpyrifos and Carbaryl in Hybrid Catfish. Science
however, has been reported to declines after an initial Asia, 33: 301-305.
increase on chlorpyrifos exposure [27]. Contrary to it, 5. Sanderson, D.M. and E.F. Edson, 1964. Toxicological
the opercular movement in fish has been reported properties of the organophosphorus insecticide
to increase following the exposure of toxicants dimethoate. British J. Industrial Med., 21: 52-64.
[1, 23, 28, 29]. In present study, decline in the opercular 6. Rose, R.L. and E. Hodgson, 2004. Chemical and
movement may be due to adaptive response of the Physiological Influences on Xenobiotic Metabolism,
fish to minimize the intake of toxicant by reducing the In A T.B. of Modern Toxicology (Third Edn.) John
frequency of opercular beating and resorting to aerial Wiley and Sons Inc., New Jersey, USA, pp: 163-202.
respiration with the help of accessory respiratory 7. Sprague, J.B., 1969. Measurement of pollutant toxicity
organ. to fish: I. Bioassay methods for acute toxicity. Water
From this study, it may be concluded that the Res., 3: 793-821.
temperature is an important determinant of toxicity. 8. Kumar, A. and A.K. Gupta, 2006. Acute toxicity of
Therefore, the application of toxicants should be mercury to the fingerlings of Indian major carps
synchronized with the seasonal variation in temperature (catla, rohu and mrigal) in relation to water hardness
so that their adverse effects on non-target organisms and temperature. J. Environ. Biol., 27(1): 89-92.

131
Global J. Environ. Res., 2 (3): 126-132, 2008

9. Karthikeyan, S., P.L.R.M. Palaniappam and 20. Falk, D.L. and W.A. Dunson, 1977. The effect of
S. Sabhanayakam, 2007. Influence of pH and water season and acute sub lethal exposure on survival
hardness upon nickel accumulation in edible fish time of book trout at low pH. Water Res., 11: 13-15.
Cirrhinus mrigala. J. Environ. Biol., 28(2): 489-492. 21. Gupta, A.K. and V.K. Rajbanshi, 2006. Toxicity of
10. Pandey, R.K., R.N. Singh, S. Singh, N.N. Singh and copper and cadmium to Heteropneustes fossilis
V.K. Das, 2009. Acute toxicity bioassay of dimethoate (Bloch). Acta Hydrochimica et Hydrobiologica,
on freshwater air breathing catfish, Heteropneustes 19(3): 331-340.
fossilis (Bloch). J. Environ. Biol., 30: 2-3. 22. Kristen, M. Gaworecki, Aaron P. Roberts, Norman
11. Reish, D.L. and P.S. Oshida, 1987. Short term Ellis, Anthony D. Sowers and Stephen J. Klaine, 2009.
bioassay In: Manual of Methods in Aquatic Biochemical and behavioral effects of diazinon
Environment Research Part 6. FAO. FAO Fisheries exposure in Hybrid striped bass. Environ. Toxicol.
Technical Paper (FAO) No. 247: 1-62. Chem., 28(1): 105-112.
12. APHA, AWWA, WPCF, 1998. Standard methods for 23. Ram, R.N., I.J. Singh and D.V. Singh, 2001.
the Examination of Water and Wastewater, 20th Edn. Carbofuran induced impairment in the hypothalamo-
American Public Health Association, Washington. neurohypophyseal - gonadal complex in the
13. Finney, D.J., 1971. Probit Analysis. University Press, teleost, Channa punctatus (Bloch). J. Environ. Biol.,
Cambridge. 22(3): 193-200.
14. Verma, S.R., S.K. Bansal, A.K. Gupta, N. Pal, 24. Pandey, S., R. Kumar, S. Sharma, N.S. Nagpure,
A.K. Tyagi, M.C. Bhatnagar, V. Kumar and S.K. Srivastava and M.S. Verma, 2005. Acute toxicity
R.C. Dalela, 1982. Bioassay trials with twenty three bioassay of mercuric chloride and malathion on
pesticides to a freshwater teleost Saccobranchus air-breathing fish Channa punctatus (Bloch).
fossilis. Water Res., 16: 525-529. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Safety, 61: 114-120.
15. Begum, G. and S. Vijayaraghavan, 1995. In vivo 25. Singh, N.N., V.K. Das and S. Singh, 1996. Effect
toxicity of dimethoate on protein and transaminases of aldrin on carbohydrate, protein and ionic
in the liver tissue of fresh water fish Clarias metabolism of a freshwater catfish Heteropneustes
batrachus (Linn.). Bullet. Environ. Contamination fossilis. Bulletin of Environ. Contamination and
Toxicol., 54: 370-375. Toxicol., 57(2): 204-210.
16. Dikshith, T.S.S. and R.B. Raizada, 1981. Toxicity 26. Singh, N.N., V.K. Das and A.K. Srivastava, 2002.
evaluation of dimethoate technical in fish. Report to Insecticides and ionic regulation in teleosts: A
Shaw Wallace and Co. India Ltd. review. Zoologica Poloniae, 47(3-4): 49-64.
17. Srivastava, V.K. and A. Singh, 2001. Studies of 27. Chindah, A.C., F.D. Sikoki, I. Vincent-Akpu,
seasonal variation in toxicity of frequently used 2004. Toxicity of an organophosphate pesticide
commercial organophosphate, carbamate and (chlorpyrifos) on a common Niger Delta wetland
synthetic pyrethroids pesticides against freshwater fish- Tilapia guineensis (Blecker 1862). J. Appl. Sci.
fish Channa punctatus and behavioural responses to Environ. Manage., 8(2): 11-17.
treated fish. Malaysian Appl. Biol., 30: 17-23. 28. Yadav, A., S. Neraliya and A.Gopesh, 2007. Acute
18. Patra, R.W., J.C. Chapman, R.P. Lim and P.C. Gehrke, toxicity levels and ethological responses of
2007. The effects of three organic chemicals on Channa striatus to fertilizer industrial wastewater.
the upper thermal tolerances of four freshwater J. Environ. Biol., 28(2): 159-162.
fishes. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 26(7): 1454-1459. 29. Srivastava, S.K., R. Jaiswal and A.K. Srivastav, 1995.
19. Saha, S. and A. Kaviraj, 2008. Effect of ambient Acute toxicity of chlorpyrifos to a fresh water
temperature and daylight on the survival of catfish Heteropneustes fossilis. J. Adv. Zool.,
freshwater catfish Heteropneustes fossilis (Bloch, 16(2): 92-95.
1794) exposed to Cypermethrin. Environ. Engineering
Sci., 26(4): 1-4.

132

You might also like