You are on page 1of 27

0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!

MERICA¯SUMMARYAIMEDATDECISIONMAKERS
4HE±4RANS-ILENIO²"24SYSTEMIN 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US
"OGOTfHASRECEIVEDSIGNI½CANT
ATTENTIONFROMTHEGENERALPUBLICAND
HASAVERYPOSITIVEIMAGEAMONG
2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA
THEPEOPLE4HISHASGENERATED
CITIZEN LEDACTIVITIES SUCHASTHE
±4RANSMI&OTO² ANEVENTINWHICHMORE
¯SUMMARYAIMEDATDECISIONMAKERS
THANPHOTOGRAPHERS
PROFESSIONALANDAMATEUR GATHERED
TOTAKEPICTURESOFTHESYSTEM

4HISGUIDEPRESENTSTHEMOSTRELEVANTASPECTSTOTAKEINTOACCOUNTWHEN

DEVELOPINGA"US2APID4RANSIT"24 PROJECTINCITIESOFTHE

DEVELOPINGWORLD SPECI½CALLYCONCENTRATINGON,ATIN!MERICA WHILE

PROVIDINGEXAMPLESOFSEVERALOFTHESESYSTEMS4HEDOCUMENTDESCRIBESTHE

DIFFERENTSTEPSONEMUSTTAKEINTOACCOUNTINA"24PROJECTANDTHE

RELEVANTDETAILSOFSUCHAPROCESS3PECIALATTENTIONHASBEENGIVEN

TOTHECHALLENGESTHATDECISIONMAKERSCONFRONTWHENDEVELOPINGA"24

SYSTEMANDTHEELEMENTSANDTOOLSTHATAREAVAILABLETOTHEMINORDER

TOMOVEFORWARDWITHTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFASUCCESSFULSYSTEM
4 5
0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US
2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA
¯SUMMARYAIMEDATDECISIONMAKERS

ˆ

%DITIONBY*ORGE2OGAT

!LLPHOTOSINTHEDOCUMENTARETAKENBY#ARLOS&ELIPE0ARDO UNLESSOTHERWISENOTED

&EBRUARY

).6%34)'!#)/.%3$%%30!#)/
#ONTENTS

0REFACE   
 )NTRODUCTION  
 0UBLICTRANSPORTANDSUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENT 
 0UBLICTRANSPORTOPTIONS
 7HY"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMS 

 &EATURESOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEM 
 )NFRASTRUCTURE 
 $EDICATEDLANES 
 3TATIONS 
 4ERMINALSANDDEPOTS 
 #ONTROLCENTER 
 /PERATIONS
 "USINESS3TRUCTURE¯REARRANGEMENTOFTHEPUBLICTRANSPORTSECTOR 
 4ECHNOLOGY 
 6EHICLES 
 &ARECOLLECTION 
 4RACKINGSYSTEMS 
 5SERSINFORMATION 
 )NTEGRATION 
 )NTEGRATIONWITHPEDESTRIANS 
 )NTEGRATIONWITHBICYCLES 
 )NTEGRATIONWITHOTHERMEANSOFTRANSPORTATION¯BUSES TRAINSYSTEMS 
 )NTEGRATIONWITHTAXISANDBICYCLETAXIS 
 )NTEGRATIONWITHCARS 
 -ARKETINGAND#USTOMER3ERVICE 
 -ARKETINGELEMENTS 
 #USTOMERSERVICE 

 )MPLEMENTATIONOFA"243YSTEM 
 0OLITICAL7ILL 
 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATION 
 0ROJECTTEAMANDTIMELINE 
 3YSTEM½NANCING 
 #ONTRACTING 
 #ONSTRUCTIONANDMAINTENANCE 
 3YSTEMEVALUATIONANDIMPACT 
 !DDITIONAL2ESOURCES 

0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 3
0REFACE

4HEURBANTRANSPORTSECTORHASDEVELOPEDSIGNI½CANTLYINTHEPASTYEARS3INCETHE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFASUSTAINABLETRANSPORTPOLICYIN"OGOTf BETWEENAND
THATINCLUDEDTHEMASSIVE DEVELOPMENT OFINFRASTRUCTURES FORPEDESTRIANS BICYCLES
ANDPUBLICTRANSPORT VARIOUSCITIESINTHEWORLDANDPARTICULARLYIN,ATIN!MERICA
ANDTHE#ARIBBEAN HAVEDEVELOPEDTHEIROWNPOLICIESWITHSIMILARGUIDELINESAND
OBJECTIVES4HISHASSHOWNTHATTHESUBJECTOFTRANSPORTATIONISNOTONLYONEOFTHE
CENTRALCOMPONENTSFORTHEREDUCTIONOFPOLLUTINGGASEMISSIONSINTHEENVIRONMENT
BUTALSOOFGREENHOUSEGASES

/FALLTHESUSTAINABLETRANSPORTPROJECTSIMPLEMENTED THEONETHATHASHADTHEGREA
TESTIMPACTISTHE"US2APID4RANSITSYSTEM"24 (OWEVER ITSIMPLEMENTATIONIN
VOLVESONEOFTHEBIGGESTCHALLENGESFORALOCALADMINISTRATION NOTONLYDUETOTHE
DEDICATIONANDINVESTMENTITENTAILS BUTALSOFORTHELEVELOFDETAILINITSPLANNING
ANDIMPLEMENTATION ANDTHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEPOLITICALWILLOFTHEPEOPLEWHOLEAD
THESEKINDSOFPROJECTS

4HISBRIEFPLANNINGGUIDEHASBEENWRITTENFORTHATREASON4HEPURPOSEISTOPRESENT
THE CHARACTERISTICS COMPONENTS AND STEPS NEEDED TO IMPLEMENT A "24 SYSTEM BY
GIVINGEXAMPLESOFOTHERSYSTEMSOFITSKINDINTHEREGION4HISDOCUMENTISINTENDED
TOINTRODUCETHEMOSTRELEVANTTOPICSINVOLVEDINTHESETYPESOFPROJECTSTOINTERESTED
PEOPLE THEREBYMOTIVATINGTHEMTOCREATEASIMILARSYSTEMINTHEIROWNCITIES

4HISGUIDEISBASEDONTHEEXPERIENCEOFTHE±0ROMOTING3USTAINABLE4RANSPORTIN
,ATIN!MERICAPROJECT FUNDEDBYTHE'LOBAL%NVIRONMENT&ACILITY'%& IMPLE
MENTEDBYTHE5NITED.ATIONS%NVIRONMENT0ROGRAM5.%0 ANDEXECUTEDBYTHE
5.%02ISž#ENTRE)TISORIGINALLYPRODUCEDINTHE3PANISHLANGUAGEANDHASBEEN
TRANSLATEDTOTHE%NGLISHVERSIONWITHTHEAIMOFSHARINGTHE,ATIN!MERICANEXPERI
ENCESANDLESSONSLEARNEDWITHOTHERREGIONS

*ORGE2OGAT

5.%02ISž#ENTRE

&EBRUARY

4 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 5
 )NTRODUCTION


)NANYCITYTHROUGHOUTTHEWORLD TRANSPORTISONE
OF THE MOST DIF½CULT TOPICS TO MANAGE )N CON
TRASTTOALLTHEOTHERCOMPONENTSACITYHAS THESE
COMPLEXITIESCANBESEENBYTHEFACTTHATTRANS
PORTDOESN´TIMPROVEALONGSIDEECONOMICGROWTH
AND DEVELOPMENT ¯ IT GETS WORSE 4HE GROWTH
OF '$0 IN A CITY IS NORMALLY ACCOMPANIED BY A
GREATERLEVELOFTRAF½CANDALLITSEXTERNALITIESPO
LLUTION ACCIDENTS INEQUALITY AND MANY OTHERS 
&URTHERMORE ITISIMPORTANTTOTAKEINTOACCOUNT
THAT,ATIN!MERICANCITIESASWELLASOTHERPARTS
OF THE WORLD HAVE HAD AN INCREASING CONSTRUC
TIONRATEINRECENTDECADES ANDCONSEQUENTLYA
GREATERTRANSPORTDEMANDBYCITIZENS#ITIESHAVE
BECOME A FUNDAMENTAL CORE OF A COUNTRY´S ECO
NOMICDEVELOPMENT ANDTHEIRTRANSPORTSYSTEMS &IGURE  3OME TRANSPORT POLICIES LIKE THOSE IN "OGOTf #OLOM
&IGURE!TYPICALPROBLEMINDEVELOPINGCITIESISTRAF ARE ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT COMPONENTS OF BIA HAVEGIVENGREATERPRIORITYTOTHEHUMANBEINGRATHERTHAN
½CCONGESTION USUALLYCAUSEDBYTHEEXCESSIVEUSEOF THISDEVELOPMENT THEPRIVATEVEHICLE4HE±CICLOVqADOMINICAL²ISANEXAMPLEACLO
PRIVATECARS SURE OF  KM OF STREETS AROUND THE CITY ON EVERY 3UNDAY FOR
.EVERTHELESS THERE IS EXISTING EXPERIENCE IN PEDESTRIANSANDBICYCLERIDERS
TRANSPORT PLANNING WHICH VARIES FROM THE VERY
POSITIVE TO OTHERS WHOSE EFFECTS ARE QUITE NE
GATIVE INTERMSOFPREPARATION IMPLEMENTATION
ANDEVENTUALIMPACTS!SAGENERALRULE PROPOSED HAVE BEEN WELL IMPLEMENTED AND DEVELOPED AS
TRANSPORTPLANSANDPOLICIESWHEREPRIVATETRANS PART OF A COMPREHENSIVE SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORT
PORT CARS AS THE ESSENTIAL MEANS OF TRANSPORT POLICY HAVEHADBOTHPOSITIVEANDLONGTERMIM
AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF WAYS FAVOURING THEM PACTSINCITIESAROUNDTHEWORLD3OMECITIESHAVE
PREVAILS HAVESEEMINGLYHADPOSITIVESHORTTERM DEVELOPEDPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMSTHATHAVEN´T
EFFECTS9ETAFTERAFEWMONTHS SUCHPROJECTSHAVE BEENIMPLEMENTEDWITHALLTHENECESSARYCOMPO
PROVEN TO BE AN INADEQUATE OPTION IN TERMS OF NENTS ORCOMPLEMENTEDBYADEQUATESUSTAINABLE
INVESTMENT EF½CIENCY AS WELL AS ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSPORTPOLICIES HAVEGENERALLYHADMINIMUM
ECONOMICANDSOCIALEXTERNALITIES ORALMOSTNON PERCEIVABLEIMPACTS(OWEVER THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF THESE TYPES OF SYSTEMS HAS
/N THE OTHER HAND THERE HAVE BEEN TRANSPORT CLEARPOSITIVEEFFECTSONACITY ESPECIALLYINCOM
POLICIESFAVOURINGTHEMOVEMENTOFPEOPLENOT PARISON WITH PROJECTS THAT ARE GEARED TOWARDS
VEHICLES WHICHGIVEMOREIMPORTANCETOTHENON SUPPLYING INFRASTRUCTURE EXCLUSIVELY FOR PRIVATE
MOTORIZEDMEANSOFTRANSPORTATIONANDTOPUBLIC AUTOMOBILES
TRANSPORT 4HESE TYPES OF EXPERIENCES WHICH

6 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 7
4HIS DOCUMENT IS MAINLY DIRECTED AT DECISION &IGURE  #ONGESTION IN A CITY
MAKERS WHO ARE LOOKING FOR OPTIONS AND SOLU GENERATES VERY HIGH ECONOMIC
TIONSTOIMPROVETHEPUBLICTRANSPORTSITUATIONIN LOSSESDUETOLACKOFEF½CIENCY
ACERTAINCITY)TISNOTFOCUSEDONGIVINGDETAILED UPTOOF'$0INCITIESLIKE
DESCRIPTIONS OF SPECI½C ASPECTS WITHIN A SYSTEM "ANGKOK 4HAILAND
THEREAREDEVELOPEDDOCUMENTSLIKETHE"US2A
PID4RANSIT3YSTEMS0LANNING'UIDEBY)4$0AND
OTHERS PAGESLONG 4HISISINEFFECTAQUICK
GUIDETOPRESENTTHEMOSTIMPORTANTASPECTSTHAT
SHOULDBETAKENINTOACCOUNTWHENDEVELOPINGA
SYSTEMOFTHISKIND

 0UBLICTRANSPORTAND
&IGURE  0UBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS INCLUDING "24 ARE PROJECTS
SUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENT
THAT IMPROVE URBAN TRANSPORT AND THE SOCIAL ECONOMIC AND EN
VIRONMENTALPROBLEMSOFACITY4HE"24SYSTEMIN-EXICO$&ISA
VERYSUCCESSFULSYSTEMINTHE-EXICANCAPITAL !S MENTIONED BEFORE A CITY´S PUBLIC TRANSPORT
SYSTEM IS A FUNDAMENTAL COMPONENT OF A
SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORT POLICY GEARED TOWARDS
BENE½TING ITS USERS WHILE CONSIDERING THE
$UETOTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHESESYSTEMS ANDTHE LONG TERM BENE½TS FOR A THE CITY 3OME ASPECTS THANANHOURWOULDBEADVANTAGEOUS.EVERTHE %NVIRONMENTALASPECTS4AKINGINTOACCOUNTTHE
GREATIMPORTANCEOFACOMPREHENSIVEPLANTOIM THAT ARE INCREASINGLY TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WHEN LESS THEREAREMANYPEOPLEIN,ATIN!MERICANCI RECENT DISCUSSION ABOUT THE VAST EFFECTS OF CLI
PLEMENT A PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM IT IS IMPOR MAKING DECISIONS ABOUT A TRANSPORT SYSTEM TIESWHOSETRAVELTIMESTOWORKFAREXCEEDANHOUR MATECHANGE DIRECTLYASSOCIATEDTOEMISSIONSOF
TANTTOANALYZEINDETAILALLTHEOPTIONSANDCHA ARE THE IMPLICATIONS IN TERMS OF SUSTAINABLE A DAY )N FACT THESE CAN BE UP TO  HOURS PER CARBONDIOXIDE#/ THEGLOBALENVIRONMENTAL
RACTERISTICSREQUIREDTOSOLVETRANSPORTPROBLEMS DEVELOPMENT AND THE RELATIONSHIP THAT EXISTS TRIP 4HIS IS NOT ONLY RE¾ECTED IN LESS POTENTIAL PROBLEM IS ONE OF THE MOST DISCUSSED THEMES
IN A CITY )N THIS PROCESS THERE ARE TECNICAL EN BETWEEN THIS AND OTHER TRANSPORT PROJECTS HOURSOFWORKBUTALSOINACONSIDERABLEREDUC WHERETRANSPORTHASBECOMEADETERMININGFAC
VIRONMENTAL SOCIAL AND POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS 3USTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IS A CONCEPT THAT HAS TION IN THE QUALITY OF LIFE !DDITIONALLY THE LACK TORINIMPROVINGORWORSENINGTHECURRENTSITU
THATMUSTBETAKENINTOACCOUNT4HEGOALOFTHIS ALREADYBEENDEVELOPEDFORAFEWDECADESNOW)TS OFTRANSPORTOPTIONSORINADEQUATEPUBLICTRANS ATION
DOCUMENTISTOPRESENTABRIEFGUIDEOFTHEKEY MAINCOMPONENTSAREECONOMIC ENVIRONMENTAL PORTSYSTEMCOVERAGE FORACITIZENWHOLIVESFAR
ASPECTSINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFA"24SYSTEMINA AND SOCIAL ISSUES 4HE FOLLOWING IS THE ANALYSIS FROM WORK REDUCES HISHER ACCESS WORK HEALTH 4RANSPORT CONTRIBUTES CONSIDERABLY TO #/
,ATIN !MERICAN CITY 4HE MAIN OBJECTIVE OF THIS OF EACH OF THESE COMPONENTS WITH SPECI½C CARE EDUCATION AND BASIC SERVICES ALL OF WHICH EMISSIONSANDOTHERPOLLUTANTS 4HEREFORE THE
DOCUMENTISTODESCRIBEINDETAILTHEREASONFOR CHARACTERISTICSRELATEDTOPUBLICANDOTHERTYPES WORSENTHEECONOMICSITUATIONOFTHECITIZENAND IMPROVEMENTOFCITIES´TRANSPORTSYSTEMSWILLIM
SELECTING THE "24 SYSTEM RATHER THAN FOCUSING OF TRANSPORT THECITY PROVE THIS EFFECT 4WO PRINCIPAL SOLUTIONS HAVE
ON OTHER PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS 4HIS IS DUE BEENPROPOSEDRECENTLY4HE½RSTISSTRICTLYECO
TOTHEFACTTHAT"US2APID4RANSITHASPROVENTO %CONOMIC!SPECTS4HEEF½CIENCYOFACITYRELIES 4HEREFORE IFACITYDESIGNSAPUBLICTRANSPORTSYS NOMICALIEIMPROVEMENTOFFUELS DEVELOPMENT
PROMOTE GREATER EQUITY HAVE MUCH LOWER COSTS ONTHEEASEOFMOVINGTHROUGHOUTIT4HETRAVEL TEMWITHADEQUATECOVERAGEANDWITHTHEMEANS OFLOWEMISSIONVEHICLES ETC 4HESECONDISTHE
AND HAVE MORE OPERATIONAL EF½CIENCY THAN THE TIME OF A CITIZEN CAN BE RELATED TO WELFARE AND OFGIVINGGREATERACCESSTOCITIZENS THEREISAPOS DEVELOPMENTOFGREATERCOVERAGEOFPUBLICTRANS
MAJORITYOFPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMSTHROUGHOUT PERFORMANCEATWORKIFACITIZENTRAVELSFORONLY SIBILITY THAT THE CITY WILL HAVE GREATER ECONOMIC PORT SYSTEMS AND NON MOTORED VEHICLES 4HE
THEWORLD MINUTESTOGETTOWORK HISHERTRAVELTIMEIN EF½CIENCY DISCUSSIONS SURROUNDING THESE PROBLEMS SEEM
MOSTSITUATIONS ISANHOURADAY4HISWOULDBE TO SHOW THAT THE TECHNOLOGICAL OPTIONS DESPITE
AN ADEQUATE SITUATION AND ANY TRAVEL TIME LESS THEIR EXISTENCE AND POSSIBILITY OF BEING IMPLE

8 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 9
&IGURE  )NADEQUATE STATE POLICIES CONSTRUCTIONOFMOREROADSANDPARKINGAREAS! ELS4HESEMEASURESNOTONLYBALANCEATRANSPORT
ANDENFORCEMENTSONFUELSANDPUB COMMONMISTAKEINTRANSPORTPROJECTSISTHEAS SYSTEM ½NANCIALLY AND ECONOMICALLY BUT THEY
LIC TRANSPORT VEHICLES AFFECT A CITY´S SUMPTIONTHATROADDEVELOPMENTSAUTOMATICALLY ALSOGENERATEMOREADEQUATECONDITIONSFORTHE
ENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS4HEEXCES IMPROVETHEQUALITYOFLIFEOFTHEPOPULATION AS USEOFPUBLICTRANSPORT BICYCLESANDWALKING
SIVEUSEOFPRIVATEVEHICLESISONEOF TRAVELTIMEWOULDBEREDUCEDANDACCESSTOPLAC
THE LARGEST CONTRIBUTORS TO ATMOS ES WOULD IMPROVE (OWEVER IT HAS BEEN PROVEN
PHERICPOLLUTION THATTHESEARESIMPLYSHORT TERMBENE½TSMAXI
 0UBLICTRANSPORTOPTIONS
MUMMONTHS )NTHELONGRUN THESEPROJECTS
ACTUALLYGENERATEURBANSPRAWL ALIENATIONOFTHE
POPULATION ACCIDENTSANDALLSUBSEQUENTEFFECTS 4AKINGINTOACCOUNTTHATPUBLICTRANSPORTISONE
REGARDINGENERGY ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIALANDECO OFTHESUSTAINABLEOPTIONSTOTHATCANBEIMPLE
NOMICANDCONGESTIONISSUES4HEMAINMEASURE MENTED IN A CITY IT IS NECESSARY TO ANSWER THE
TO BE IMPLEMENTED FOR PRIVATE TRANSPORT IS RE FOLLOWING QUESTION ±7HAT TYPE OF PUBLIC TRANS
STRICTING CIRCULATION AND ESTABLISHING ADEQUATE PORTISBETTER²4HISQUESTIONCANNOTBEANSWE
GENERALLYMEANINGHIGHER PRICESFORTHEUSEOF REDIMMEDIATELYBYDIRECTLYCHOOSINGONETYPEOR
INFRASTRUCTUREROADSANDPARKINGAREAS ANDFU ANOTHER NORCANAMOREEXPENSIVEORINEF½CIENT

&IGURE3OCIALASPECTSRELATEDTOTRANSPORTINCLUDEVARIOUSOTH
MENTED MUSTBEACOMPLEMENTTOTHEIMPLEMEN POVERTYBYIMPROVINGACCESSTOWORK EDUCATION ERSFROMCITIZENS´WELLBEING TOHEALTHANDACCIDENTSINAPOPULA
TATIONOFAGOODQUALITYPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEM HEALTHCARE ANDGOODSANDSERVICES THEREDUC TION INCLUDINGIMPORTANTISSUESLIKESOCIALEQUITY
4HATISTOSAY ACITYTHATONLYPROMOTESTHEUSE TION OF ACCIDENTS BY REDUCING HIGH RISK SITUA
OFHYBRIDFUELVEHICLESWON´TGENERATEASGOODOF TIONSFORPEDESTRIANSANDOTHERROADUSERS INTHIS
A LONG TERM SOLUTION AS ONE THAT IMPLEMENTS A CASEBYIMPLEMENTINGASAFEANDEF½CIENTPUBLIC
PUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMWITHLOWEMISSIONVEHI TRANSPORTSYSTEM IMPROVEMENTOFTHEHEALTHOFA
CLES COMPLEMENTED BY THE REINFORCEMENT OF A POPULATIONBOTHTHROUGHINCREASEDPHYSICALAC
LOWEMISSIONPOLICYFORVEHICLES4HEMAINARGU TIVITYANDLESSEXPOSURETOPOLLUTANTSBYREDUC
MENTISTHATASYSTEMOFTHISKINDHASLESSEREMIS INGEMISSIONSINTRANSPORT ANDTHEIMPROVEMENT
SIONS THAN PRIVATE TRANSPORT 4HIS GIVES GREATER OFGENERALQUALITYOFLIFEWITHINACITY4HEIMPLE
IMPORTANCETOTHEDEVELOPMENTOFPUBLICTRANS MENTATIONOFAPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEM ASPARTOF
PORTATION WHICHTRANSPORTSAGREATERNUMBEROF ACOMPREHENSIVESUSTAINABLETRANSPORTPOLICYIN
PEOPLETHANPRIVATEVEHICLES ACITY SATIS½ESTHESECONDITIONSABOVEANYOTHER
MEANSOFMOTORISEDTRANSPORTATION ANDCOMPLE
3OCIAL ASPECTS 4HE SOCIAL ASPECTS CONSTITUTE MENTSOTHERMEANSOFTRANSPORTATIONSUCHASTHE
ONE OF THE COMPONENTS USUALLY LEFT TO LAST IN A BICYCLEANDWALKING
TRANSPORT POLICY 4RANSPORT PROJECTS INCLUDE SO
CIAL ASPECTS IN A VERY RESTRICTED UNDERSTANDING )N GENERAL PROJECTS THAT GIVE MORE IMPORTANCE
.EVERTHELESS THEEQUITY ACCESSIBILITY HEALTHAND TO PUBLIC TRANSPORT BICYCLES AND WALKING WILL
GENERALWELLBEINGOFAPOPULATIONWILLALSOHAVE HAVEMOREPOSITIVEEFFECTSFORAPOPULATION THAN
EFFECTS OVER THE ECONOMY AND ENVIRONMENT OF A THOSEFOCUSINGONTHE±IMPROVEMENT²OFVEHICLE
CITY4HESOCIALASPECTSINCLUDETHEREDUCTIONOF CONGESTION FOR WHICH THE SOLUTION LIES IN THE

10 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 11
PUBLICTRANSPORTOPTIONBENECESSARILYSEENASA PRESENTEDTHEDECISIONABOUTTHETECHNOLOGYTO
BADOPTION!SAGENERALRULE THESELECTIONOFA BEIMPLEMENTEDMETRO LIGHTRAIL "24 ETC MUST
±BETTER²PUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMISNOTMADEBA NOT BE MADE WITHOUT FULL KNOWLEDGE OF THE CIR
SED ON ONE OR TWO ASPECTS IT INVOLVES A VARIETY CUMSTANCESINWHICHITWILLBEIMPLEMENTED!S
OFDIFFERENTCONSIDERATIONS)NGENERALTERMS THE SEENINMANYCITIESAROUNDTHEWORLD DECISIONS
PUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMOPTIONSAVAILABLEINTHE MADEWITHOUTKNOWINGTHECONTEXTHAVEUSUALLY
MARKETCANBECATEGORIZEDASFOLLOWS HADDISASTROUSCONSEQUENCES

4HISDOCUMENTDESCRIBESTHEDEVELOPMENTOF"US
2APID4RANSITSYSTEMINDETAIL HENCETHEPREFE - 7HAT IS THE LEVEL OF DEMAND OF A CITY AND
RENCE FOR THIS TYPE OF SYSTEM UNDER MOST CON WHAT ARE THE GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF ITS
DITIONS .EVERTHELESS A LIST OF FREQUENTLY ASKED JOURNEYS
QUESTIONSTHATCANGUIDETHESELECTIONOFONEPU &IGURE  4HE MONORAIL IN +UALA ,UMPUR IS A &IGURE4HEMETROIN"EIJING#HINA ISASYSTEMWITH
BLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM OVER ANOTHER IS PRESENTED 4HE ½RST FACTOR THAT MUST BE CONSIDERED BEFORE LIGHTRAILSYSTEMOFMEDIUMCAPACITY ELEVATEDANDUNDERGROUNDSECTIONS
INTHEFOLLOWINGDISCUSSION SELECTING ONE TYPE OF PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM
OVERANOTHERISTHENATUREOFTHEJOURNEYWITHIN ,IGHTRAILANELEVATEDORATLEVELRAILSYSTEMWITH (EAVY RAIL SYSTEMS UNDERGROUND OR ELEVATED 
"EFOREPRESENTINGTHELISTOFQUESTIONS THE½RST THECITY4HATISTOSAY THEAMOUNT ANDKINDOF ANELECTRICPROPULSIONSYSTEMWITHAMEDIUMMO A RAIL SYSTEM WHICH INCLUDES MULTIPLE AND HIGH
RECOMMENDATION FOR DECISION MAKING MUST BE BILIZATIONPERFORMANCE CAPACITYLANES WITHELECTRICPROPULSIONSYSTEMS
ANDHIGHPERFORMANCELEVEL

TRIPS TAKEN IN THE CITY THE ORIGINS AND DESTINA TEMSHAVEDEMANDLEVELSFROM TO 
TIONSTHATEXISTINTHECITY ANDHOWTHEYAREDIS PPHPD WHILEHEAVYRAILNORMALLYUNDERGROUND
TRIBUTED-ANYCITIESDEVELOPAGENERALTRANSPORT HAVEANAVERAGEDEMANDLEVELOF PPHPD
STUDY EVERY ½VE TO  YEARS THAT INCLUDE THOSE )N SOME EXCEPTIONAL CASES AS IN (ONG +ONG
CHARACTERISTICS)TWOULDBEGREATLYUSEFULTOUP THELEVELOFDEMANDHASREACHED PPHPD
DATE ANDOR ANALYZE THE LATEST REPORT OF SUCH A -OST ,ATIN !MERICAN CITIES HAVE DEMAND LEVELS
STUDYBEFOREANYDECISIONISMADE4HISISPARTI THAT CAN BE SATIS½ED THROUGH THE MEANS OF ANY
CULARLYIMPORTANTBECAUSEINMANYCASESAMASS ONEOFTHESETECHNOLOGIES.EVERTHELESS THETWO
TRANSPORTSYSTEMOFGREATDEMANDISCHOSENFOR HIGHESTDEMANDLEVELSYSTEMSONTHECONTINENT
CITIESTHATDON´TREALLYMEETTHOSECRITERIA ARETHEHEAVYWEIGHTTRAINSYSTEMSIN-EXICO$&
AND3AO0AULO/NTHEOTHERHAND THE"US2A
-ANYDISCUSSIONSHAVEEMERGEDAROUNDTHEDE PID4RANSITSYSTEM±4RANSMILENIO²IN"OGOTfHAS
&IGURE!NIMPROVEDBUSSYSTEMINTHECITYOF0UNE &IGURE4HE"US2APID4RANSITSYSTEM±-ETROVqA²IN MAND THAT EACH TRANSPORT SYSTEM CAN HANDLE A RECORD DEMAND LEVEL REACHING   PPHPD
)NDIA 'UATEMALACITY MAINLY BECAUSE BASIC AGREEMENTS OVER THE PER
FORMANCEOFEACHTECHNOLOGYHAVENOTBEENREA
)MPROVED BUS SYSTEMS 3YSTEMS IN WHICH A TRADI "US2APID4RANSIT"24 ABUSBASEDSYSTEMSO CHED"ASEDONTHEREALDEMAND½GURESOFEACH - 7HATBUDGETISFREELYAVAILABLEFORTHE
TIONALOPERATIONOFBUSESISUSED WITHIMPROVED METIMES WITH ARTICULATED BUSES WITH RAIL LIKE TECHNOLOGY TRADITIONAL BUS BASED SYSTEMS HAVE DEVELOPMENTOFAPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEM
VEHICLES AND BUSINESS PLAN 4HESE ARE GENERALLY COMPONENTSSUCHASSTATIONS OFF BOARDFARECO APERFORMANCELEVELOFUPTO PASSENGERS
OFLOWCAPACITY LLECTIONANDASOPHISTICATEDOPERATIONALSCHEME HOURDIRECTION PPHPD WHILE ±FULL² "US 2APID /NE OF THE MAIN CONCERNS WHEN MAKING DECI
WHICHPROVIDESHIGHLEVELPERFORMANCEANDSER 4RANSITSYSTEMSHAVEBEENABLETOMEETLEVELSOF SIONSABOUTONEPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMORANO
VICEQUALITY DEMAND OF UP TO   PPHPD ,IGHT RAIL SYS THER IS RELATED TO THE ASSOCIATED EXPENSES FOR

12 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 13
EACH OPTION 4HERE ARE MANY DISCUSSIONS ABOUT DIGGING IN UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS ARE THE MAIN &IGURE  4HE CON
THIS TOPIC WITH NO AGREEMENT ABOUT THE REAL FACTORSASSOCIATEDWITHTHESEVARIATIONS4HESYS STRUCTION OF "24 SYS
COSTS OF THE TECHNOLOGIES INVOLVED 2EGARDLESS TEMS´ COSTS CAN ALSO BE COMPARED WHEN TAKING TEMCANLASTASLITTLEAS
THEREAREVARIOUSASPECTSTHATHELPCLARIFYTHESE INTOACCOUNTTHEIRCAPACITY  MONTHS FRO A SINGLE
KINDSOFDECISIONS&IRST THECOMPARISONOFTHESE TRUNK LINE WHILE THE
EXPENSES SHOULD INCLUDE THE SAME COMPONENTS - (OW MUCH TIME IS NEEDED TO PLAN AN ADE CONSTRUCTIONOFAMORE
IN EVERY CASE "ASICALLY CHANGES IN THE COSTS OF QUATEPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEM COMPLEX SYSTEM SUCH
APUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMLIEINTHEINCLUSIONOF AS A METRO SYSTEM CAN
VEHICLES ROLLING MATERIAL PARALLEL ROUTES ADJA )NALMOSTALLCASES THEIMPLEMENTATIONOFAPU LAST  YEARS COVERING
CENTINFRASTRUCTURE ANDEXPROPRIATIONOFLANDTO BLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM OF CONSIDERABLE IMPACT IS THESAMEDISTANCE
DEVELOPSUCHSYSTEMS!TECHNOLOGYCOMPARISON DIRECTLY RELATED TO THE PROBABILITY OF IT ACTUALLY
METROVS"24OROTHERS MUSTALWAYSINCLUDETHE BEINGIMPLEMENTEDBYTHESAMEMAYORORGOVER
SAMECOMPONENTSINEVERYOPTION THUSAVOIDING NORWHOPROPOSEDIT4HISISDUETOTHEDIFFEREN
ANYCONFUSIONWHENMAKINGDECISIONS CES OF OPINION AMONG POLITICAL PARTIES AND THE
PROGRAM CHANGES AFTER ELECTIONS )N AN IDEAL SI
4HE MOST IMPORTANT TOPIC IN RELATION TO THIS TUATION WHERE THERE IS CONTINUITY IN PROGRAMS
QUESTION ISTHEBUDGETACITYHASAVAILABLEATTHE AND PROJECTS OF ONE GOVERNMENT IT CAN BE EX
TIMETHEDECISIONHASTOBEMADE ANDTHEPOS PECTEDTHATLONG TERMPROJECTSWILLCONTINUEBE
SIBILITYCONVENIENCE OFASSIGNINGFUTURERESOUR INGIMPLEMENTEDWHENAGOVERNORENDSHISHER
CESFORTHEDEVELOPMENTOFAMASSTRANSITSYSTEM TERM
4HIS CAN OVERLAP WITH THE PRIORITY GIVEN TO THE
INVESTMENTINPUBLICTRANSPORTOVEROTHERSECTORS 0UBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMSGENERALLYHAVETWOPHA
IN A CITY EDUCATION HEALTH ETC  !N EXCESSIVE SESTHEDESIGNANDPLANNING ANDTHEIMPLEMEN $ESPITETHEIMPLICATIONSBROUGHTONBYTHELON !PUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMISUSEFULASLONGASIT
DEBTFORTHECONSTRUCTIONFORAPUBLICTRANSPORT TATION ! SHORT DESIGN AND PLANNING PHASE AT GERDURATIONOFAPROJECT RESULTSAREVERYPOSITIVE IS INTEGRATED AND IS PART OF AN EXTENSIVE NETWORK
SYSTEMISNOTRECOMMENDED)NVESTINGINAPUBLIC THESTARTOFAPROJECT WHILECOMMONPRACTICE IS INTERMSOFUSERSATISFACTION WHENDIFFERENTSEC INSTEADOFBEINGBUILTASANISOLATEDSYSTEM SE
TRANSPORTSYSTEMMUSTNOTAFFECTTHEINVESTMENT BOTHUNFORTUNATEANDINEFFECTUAL4HISISLINKED TORSINASOCIETYHAVETHECHANCETOPARTICIPATE GREGATED FROM THE REST OF THE TRANSPORT SYSTEM
OFRESOURCESINOTHERSECTORSPARTICULARLYHEALTH TOWHATWASDESCRIBEDPREVIOUSLYABOUTPOLITICAL 4HE IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS OF A "24 SYSTEM IS
ANDEDUCATION 4HENOTIONOFTRANSPORTASAUNI MANDATES SINCETHEGOVERNORWHO±CUTSTHERIB )NVIEWOFTHESEPROBLEMS THEDISCIPLINEANDDE GENERALLY FASTER THAN THAT OF OTHER MASS TRANSIT
QUE ENGINE OF DEVELOPMENT SHOULD BE CHANGED BON²ISSEENASTHEONEWHODEVELOPSTHEDESIGN DICATIONNEEDEDINANADEQUATEDESIGNANDPLAN SYSTEMS ESPECIALLYWHENTAKINGINTOACCOUNTTHE
TOONEWHERETHETRANSPORTSECTORISOFEQUALIM AND PLANNING OF SUCH PROJECTS 9ET THIS PRACTI NINGPHASEISANASPECTOFGREATRELEVANCE!DE CONSTRUCTIONTIMEOFANEXTENSIVENETWORK WHICH
PORTANCEASOTHERSECTORS ANDTHUSRE¾ECTEDIN CEISOFLITTLEORNOBENE½TTOEITHERTHECITYOR SIGNANDPLANNINGPROCESSINAPUBLICTRANSPORT WOULDCOVERASIGNI½CANTSHAREOFTRIPSWITHINA
THEINVESTMENTS THEGOVERNOR3HORTDESIGNANDPLANNINGPHASES SYSTEMTAKESNOLESSTHANMONTHSORLONGER CITY4HISISDUETOTHERELATIVESIMPLICITYOFCONS
RESULT IN AN IMPLEMENTATION PHASE FULL OF PRO DEPENDINGONTHECITY TRUCTINGASYSTEMBASEDONBUSES COMPAREDTOA
3PECI½CCOSTSASSOCIATEDWITHONETECHNOLOGYOR BLEMS MISCALCULATIONS AND CITIZEN UNREST AND RAILSYSTEM ESPECIALLYUNDERGROUND WHERETHEUN
ANOTHERAREQUITEDIF½CULTTODETERMINE THEMAIN DEMONSTRATIONSWHICHCANBERELATEDTOCERTAIN 4HEIMPLEMENTATIONPROCESSISGENERALLYTHELON CERTAINTYOFTHECONSTRUCTIONTIMEISGREATERDUE
REASONBEINGTHEDIVERSITYOFCOSTSTHATTHESESYS ASPECTS NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WHILE PLANNING GESTONE4HEREARECONSULTANTSWHOAF½RMAPRO TOTHELACKOFINFORMATIONABOUTDIGGINGPROBLEMS
TEMSHAVEHADINCITIESAROUNDTHEWORLD.EVER THEPROJECT 4HE4RAN3ANTIAGOSYSTEM WHERETHE JECTWILLHAVEA±½RSTTRUNKLINE²OR±½RSTPHASE² THATMAYARISEDURINGTHECONSTRUCTIONPROCESS
THELESS THECOSTOFBUILTKILOMETREOFA"US2APID PLANNINGANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHESYSTEMWAS IMPLEMENTED IN A SHORT TIME BUT IT ISN´T REALLY
4RANSITSYSTEMHASRANGEDFROM 53$ INITIALLYDONEASANINTERNALPROCESSOFWITHLIMI CLEARWHATISMEANTBYA½RSTTRUNKLINEORPHA
TOM53$ WHILEAMETROSYSTEMRANGESFROM TEDCITIZENPARTICIPATION CANBECOMPAREDTOTHE SE OR HOW THIS WILL GENERALLY BENE½T THE POPU
 M 53$ TO  M 53$ %XPROPRIATION OF PROCESS DONEFORTHE4RANS-ETRO IN'UATEMALA LATION
LAND CONSTRUCTION DELAYS AND DIF½CULTIES WHEN WHICH INVOLVED MANY PARTICIPATIVE COMPONENTS

14 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 15
 7HY"US2APID
- 7HAT IS THE POLITICAL SOCIAL AND CULTURAL - 7HATARETHEEXISTINGFUELANDELECTRICGENERA GOOD CHOICE REGARDLESS OF THE SPECI½C TYPE OF
4RANSIT3YSTEMS
CONTEXTINWHICHTHEDECISIONFORTHEPUBLIC TORSOURCESINACITYCOUNTRY PUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMTOBEDEVELOPED
TRANSPORTOPTIONISMADE
!NOTHERMATTEROFGREATIMPORTANCEWHENMAKING $IFFERENCESARISEWHENDE½NINGTHESPECI½CTYPE %VENTHOUGHTHE"US2APID4RANSITHASBEENPRE
3OCIAL AND POLITICAL FACTORS IN THE DECISION MA DECISIONS REGARDING PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS IS OF SYSTEM ELEVATED UNDERGROUND AT LEVEL AND SENTEDASAVIABLEOPTIONFORPUBLICTRANSPORTA
KINGPROCESSOFAPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMARENOT TOCONSIDERENERGY2AILSYSTEMSGENERALLYRELYON THE DISTANCE BETWEEN STATIONS %LEVATED SYSTEMS TION ANDHASBEENARGUEDASONE AMONGVARIOUS
FREQUENTLY TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT 4HE TRADITIONAL ELECTRICENERGYTOOPERATE WHILE"US2APID4RANSIT AREUSUALLYUNAESTHETICANDHAVESAFETYISSUESFOR OTHER MASS TRANSIT TECHNOLOGIES IT´S IMPORTANT
PROCESS IS THAT THE PURELY TECHNICAL CRITERIA ARE VEHICLESUSUALLYRUNON$IESELFUELORNATURALGAS THEIR SURROUNDING AREAS DUE TO SHADOWS BEING TO REITERATE THAT THIS DOCUMENT FOCUSES ON THE
CONSIDERED IGNORING THE CONCERNS OF THE DIFFE EVENTHOUGHTHEREAREOTHEROPTIONSLIKEHYBRID GENERATEDANDTHEDIF½CULTYINACCESSINGTHESTA "24SYSTEMBECAUSEITISSEENPREDOMINANTLYAS
RENTPEOPLEINVOLVED BOTHDIRECTLYANDINDIRECTLY ANDELECTRIC 4HEPRO½TABILITYOFONETECHNOLOGY TIONS WHILE UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS HAVING THE AMOREAPPROPRIATEOPTIONFORCITIESAROUNDTHE
INTHETRANSFORMATIONPROCESSOFAPUBLICTRANS OVERANOTHERRELATESDIRECTLYTOTHEAVAILABILITYAND ADVANTAGES OF HIGHER CAPACITY AND FREEDOM OF WORLD)NTHECASEOF,ATIN!MERICA ITISAHIGHLY
PORTSYSTEM4HESEPEOPLEINCLUDEBOTHTHEUSERS CLEANLINESS OF THAT TYPE OF ENERGY WHEN IN LARGE CIRCULATION PRESENT PROBLEMS IN ACCESSING THE RECOMMENDEDOPTION
AND THE OPERATORS OF EXISTING PUBLIC TRANSPOR QUANTITIES )F A GOVERNMENT IS CONSIDERING BUIL STATIONS4HISGENERALLYRELATESANASSOCIATIONOF
TATION WHO COULD BECOME THE FUTURE OPERATORS DINGARAILSYSTEMTHATRUNSONELECTRICENERGY THE PASSENGERSWITH±RODENTS² SINCETHEYMUSTGOUN 7HILEDECISIONMAKERSAREWELCOMETOCARRYOUT
OF SOME COMPONENTS OF THE NEW SYSTEM /THER POSSIBILITYOFUSINGEXISTINGENERGYRESOURCES THE DERGROUNDTOTRANSPORTTHEMSELVESAROUNDACITY ACOMPREHENSIVEANALYSISOFTHEEXISTINGOPTIONS
CONSIDERATIONSARETHOSERELATEDTO±WHATTHECI MEANS FOR PRODUCING THIS ENERGY HYDROELECTRIC WHILECARSAREALLOWEDONTHESTREETS TODEVELOPAPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMFORTHEIRCI
TIZENSWANTINTHEIRCITY² THOUGHTHESEMUSTBE WIND COAL ETC AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSE TIES THEYSHOULDMAKETHEIRDECISIONSBASEDON
STUDIEDCAREFULLY)NMANYCASESTHECITIZENSONLY QUENCESTHATWOULDBEBROUGHTABOUT MUSTALLBE "EYOND TECHNICAL SPECI½CATIONS OF A SYSTEM THECRITERIADESCRIBEDPREVIOUSLY USINGTHOROUGH
WANTMOREROADSANDACARWITHAIRCONDITIONING CAREFULLYANALYZED THE CITY THAT IS DESIRED SHOULD BE CLEAR AS WELL ANDUNBIASEDSTUDIESOFTHECONDITIONSINWHICH
4HIS CONSIDERATION CANNOT BE MADE FOR THE PO AS THE LONG TERM IMPACTS THAT WOULD WANT TO ONESYSTEMISMORECONVENIENTTHANANOTHERIN
PULATION WHENTAKINGINTOACCOUNTTHESUSTAINA /NTHEOTHERHAND IFTHEGOVERNMENTISANALYZING BE GENERATED FOR THE INHABITANTS AND THE WAY THEIRCITIES
BILITYCRITERIAPREVIOUSLYDESCRIBED THE OPTION OF A "US 2APID 4RANSIT SYSTEM THE IN WHICH THE DIFFERENT PUBLIC TRANSPORT TECH
AVAILABILITY OF GOOD QUALITY FUELS $IESEL .ATU NOLOGIES WOULD RELATE TO THIS VISION OF THE CITY
0UBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS SUCH AS THE "US 2A RAL #OMPRESSED 'AS AND OTHERS MUST BE STU
PID 4RANSIT GENERALLY ARE SIMPLER AND CAN USE DIED THOROUGHLY AS WELL THE COUNTRY´S CAPACITY
THE LOCAL WORKFORCE WHICH IS MORE DIF½CULT IN TO PROVIDE SUCH FUELS 4HE POSITIVE ASPECT OF A
RAILSYSTEMS4HISHASTWOIMPLICATIONS&IRST THE "24 IS THE ¾EXIBILITY IN TERMS OF AVAILABLE FUEL
POSSIBILITY OF USING LOCAL TECHNOLOGIES FOR VEHI EVEN THOUGH ELECTRIC ENERGY IS THE CLEANEST
CLECONSTRUCTIONISMUCHMORELIKELYTOHAPPEN OPTION ALTHOUGH ONLY WHEN USED IN VEHICLES
WHENIMPLEMENTINGA"24SYSTEM3ECOND EXIS THAT HAVE A CONSIDERABLE DEGREE OF OCCUPANCY &IGURE  4HE ±4RANSMILENIO²
TING JOBS ARE MORE LIKELY TO CONTINUE IN A "US SYSTEMIN"OGOTf #OLOMBIAWAS
2APID4RANSITSYSTEMTHANINARAILSYSTEM#ONS DEVELOPEDASPARTOFACOMPRE
TRUCTIONISTHEONLYCASEWHEREJOBBENE½TSBE - 7HATISTHEIDEALTYPEOFCITY HENSIVETRANSPORTPOLICY WHICH
TWEENRAILTECHNOLOGIESANDBUSSYSTEMSARECOM EMPHASIZINGTHEIMPORTANCEOF
PARABLE!"24SYSTEMHASAMUCHSHORTERCONS 4HE LAST AND PERHAPS MOST IMPORTANT QUESTION PEOPLEOVERVEHICLES0HOTOBY
TRUCTION TIME THAN THE SYSTEM´S TOTAL OPERATION REFERS TO THE CITY THAT IS ±VISUALIZED² WHEN BUIL $IEGO6ELAZQUEZ
DING A PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEM 4HIS IS GENERALLY
APPLIEDTOTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHECITY ANDSHOULD
ALWAYSRELATETHECHOSENTRANSPORTSYSTEMTOOTHER
URBANCOMPONENTSSUCHASHOUSING LAND DENSI
TY ETC  )N GENERAL CHOOSING PUBLIC TRANSPORT AS
THEMAINMODEOFTRANSPORTATIONISALREADYAVERY

16 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 17
"ASEDONWHATWASDESCRIBEDINTHEPREVIOUSSEC &IGURE  ! DEDICATED LANE ALLOWS
TION "US 2APID 4RANSIT IS PRESENTED AS A HIGHLY EF½CIENT OPERATIONS FOR A PUBLIC
RECOMMENDEDOPTIONOFMASSTRANSITSYSTEMSFOR TRANSPORT SYSTEM WHEN THERE IS AN
CITIESIN,ATIN!MERICAFORTHEFOLLOWINGREASONS ADEQUATESERVICEANDPLANNING

#ONSTRUCTION COSTS  EXPENSES ARE MUCH


LOWER THAN THOSE OF OTHER MASS TRANSPORTS
ANDHAVELOWEROVERHEAD IFANY 

0ERFORMANCE IN TERMS OF TRANSPORTED


PASSENGERS IS COMPARABLE TO THAT OF RAIL
SYSTEMS

$URATIONOFCONSTRUCTIONISMUCHLESSTHAN
THATOFOTHEROPTIONS

'REATER OPERATIONAL ¾EXIBILITY IS POSSIBLE


THAN WITH RAIL SYSTEMS IE A ROAD CAN BE  &EATURESOF"US2APID4RANSIT
ABANDONEDINCASEOFANEMERGENCY 

/PERATIONAL SUBSIDIES ARE NOT REQUIRED


WHEREASTHEYAREFORALLRAILSYSTEMSAROUND )T IS WORTH EXPLAINING THAT WHAT IS UNDERSTOOD COMPLETESYSTEM)TISRATHERINTENDEDTORECOM
THEWORLDEXCLUDING(ONG+ONG  HERE AS A "US 2APID 4RANSIT SYSTEM IS ±A PUBLIC MENDTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFA"24SYSTEMWITH
TRANSPORTSYSTEMBASEDONBUSESWHICHPROVIDE ALL THE CHARACTERISTICS DESCRIBED IN THIS CHAP
"ETTERINTEGRATIONEXISTSASPARTOFANURBAN FAST COMFORTABLEANDCOSTEFFECTIVEURBANMOBI TER4HEFOLLOWINGDESCRIPTIONSPRESENTACLEARER
SUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENTPOLICY LITY² 7RIGHT   !N IMPORTANT ISSUE IS THAT EMPHASISOFITSAPPLICATION)NGENERAL A"24SYS
THEDEVELOPMENTOF"24SYSTEMSHAVEBEEN±INS TEMSHOULDINCLUDETHECREATIONOFINFRASTRUCTURE
PIRED² BY RAIL SYSTEMS AND THEIR HIGH CAPACITY AND THE OPERATIONS BUSINESS AND SERVICE PLANS
%VENTHOUGHTHISBRIEFLISTOFARGUMENTSLOOKSSO THUSADOPTINGTHEMOSTIMPORTANTCHARACTERIS THATCOMPLEMENTIT
MEWHATPRESUMPTUOUSTHERESTOFTHEDOCUMENT TICSSUCHASUSEOFEXCLUSIVESTATIONS OFFBOARD
AND THE CITED DOCUMENTS IN THE RESOURCE SEC FARECOLLECTION ETC TOOPERATIONSINBUSESWHICH )N PREVIOUS DECADES BUS IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS
TION WILLHELPCLARIFYTHESESTATEMENTSINDETAIL ALSOHAVEQUALITIESLIKEOPERATIONAL¾EXIBILITY LOW WEREDEVELOPEDWITHOUTANYSUCCESS4HEREASON
COSTVEHICLESANDTHEADAPTABILITYOFTHEVEHICLES FORTHISISMAINLYBECAUSEITWASTHECREATIONOF
4HISDOCUMENTBRIE¾YPRESENTSTHECHARACTERIS TOVARIOUSSERVICECONDITIONS ETC $IFFERENT±LE ANEXCLUSIVEBUSLANE4HISLANEDIDN´TINCLUDEANY
TICSOFA"US2APID4RANSITSYSTEMANDDESCRIBES VELS² OF "24 HAVE BEEN DESCRIBED IN THE PUBLIC MODI½ED OPERATING CONDITIONS OF THE VEHICLES
THE STEPS TO CARRY OUT A PROJECT OF THIS KIND IN TRANSPORT½ELD FROMTHESIMPLESTONESTOTHESO NORWERETHERECLEARSTAFFHIRINGSCHEMESORSER
A,ATIN!MERICANCITY4HELASTCHAPTERPRESENTS CALLED±FULL"24²OR±COMPLETE"24² WHICHINCLU VICEPROVIDERSINCLUDED4HISRESULTEDINRAPIDLY
DETAILSCONCERNINGOTHERDOCUMENTSTHATCANBE DESALLTHEPROPERCHARACTERISTICSOFTHISTYPEOF DETERIORATINGSYSTEMSANDLOSSOFCON½DENCEAND
CONSULTED IN ORDER TO EXTEND KNOWLEDGE ABOUT SYSTEM TRUST IN BUS BASED SYSTEMS 4HE "24 IS A MUCH
THISTOPIC MOREDEVELOPEDANDCOMPREHENSIVECONCEPT AS
4HIS DOCUMENT WILL NOT PROVIDE AN EXHAUSTIVE CANBESEENINTHEFOLLOWINGSECTIONS
CATEGORIZATION OF WHAT IS A SIMPLER OR MORE

18 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 19
CHARACTER ISTOALLOWTHEVEHICLESTOABANDONTHE &IGURE#OMPLETE"US
 )NFRASTRUCTURE
LANEINCASEOFANEMERGENCYORINANYCASEWHE 2APID 4RANSIT SYSTEMS
RETHENORMALOPERATIONSAREMODI½ED SUCH AS THE ±-EGABUS²
)NFRASTRUCTURE IS A COMPONENT THAT IS COMMON IN 0EREIRA #OLOMBIA
INALL"24SYSTEMS)TREFERSTOSTATIONS DEDICA !NADDITIONALASPECTTOTAKEINTOACCOUNTISTHE HAVESTATIONSTHATDETER
TED LANES DEPOTS AND CONTROL CENTRES )N SHORT MATERIAL TO USE WHEN BUILDING THE DEDICATED MINE THE SPECI½C LOCA
THIS INFRASTRUCTURE ALLOWS A "24 SYSTEM TO HAVE LANE"USESINA"24SYSTEMAREARTICULATED AND TION WHERE PASSENGERS
AN EXCLUSIVE LANE WITH RESPECT TO OTHER MO THE WEIGHT THEY EXERT OVER THE SURFACE IS MUCH CAN ENTER AND LEAVE THE
DES OF TRANSPORT 4HIS HELPS IN COMPLYING WITH GREATERTHANTHEONEOFSMALLERVEHICLES!NADE SYSTEM ANDPROVIDETHE
HIGH CAPACITY OPERATIONS AND MAKES POSSIBLE QUATE MATERIAL MUST BE USED TO MEET THE PER FACILITY OF PAYING TICK
THE EXISTENCE OF STATIONS $EDICATED DEPOTS ARE MANENT TRAF½C NEEDS OF THESE BUSES 'ENERALLY ETS BEFORE BOARDING THE
ESSENTIAL FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF THESE VEHI THEMOSTRECOMMENDEDOPTIONISUSINGCONCRETE BUS
CLES AND FOR OPERATORS TO RUN ADEQUATE MONI AT THE STATIONS AND ASPHALT ON THE LANES 4HEN
TORING OF THE SYSTEM 4HE CONTROL CENTRE IS THE AGAIN IT IS NECESSARY TO MAKE AN ADEQUATE STU
PLACE WHERE THE TRACKING OF SYSTEM OPERATIONS DY OF THE OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS OF THE SYSTEM
IS DONE WITH THE HELP OF ADVANCED COMMU TO BE DESIGNED )N CASES WHERE A "24 SYSTEM IS
NICATIONS SYSTEMS EXPLAINED FURTHER BELOW  CONSTRUCTED ANDEXISTINGLANESAREKEPT ITISAB
SOLUTELYNECESSARYTOREINFORCETHEM4HISISONE
 $EDICATEDLANES OF THE ASPECTS THAT IF NOT TREATED WITH CARE WILL
4HE TYPICAL IMAGE OF A "24 IS A BUS RUNNING IN MOSTLIKELYHAVESIGNI½CANTCONSEQUENCESONTHE !NADDITIONALOPTIONISWHENTHELANESAREFULLY 3TATIONS ARE ELEVATED THIS MEANS THAT
A DEDICATED LANE %VEN THOUGH THIS IS NOT THE PERFORMANCE OF THE SYSTEM THE LIFE OF THE VEHI SEGREGATEDPHYSICALLY 4HISGENERALLYHAPPENSIN THEVEHICLESALSOHAVEELEVATEDPLATFORMS
ONLY COMPONENT MAKING "24 A HIGH CAPACITY CLESANDTHESERVICESPROVIDED)TISHIGHLYRECOM OVERGROUNDORUNDERGROUNDSECTIONS.EVERTHE WHICH IN TURN MAKES THE BUSES LESS
SYSTEM ITISINDEEDONEOFITSMAINREQUIREMENTS MENDEDTORECONSTRUCTALLLANESTOBEUSEDBYTHE LESS THISISUSEDASALASTRESORT USUALLYWHENTHECON EXPENSIVE%LEVATEDSTATIONSAREUSEDTO
3EGREGATING THE "24 VEHICLES FROM THE REST "24VEHICLES TEXTDOESN´TALLOWANADEQUATEOPERATIONAT GRADE ENFORCETHEUSEOFSTATIONSANDNOTOTHER
OF THE TRAF½C IS FUNDAMENTAL FOR ITS SUCCESSFUL PARTSOFTHECORRIDORS FORBOARDINGAND
FUNCTIONING!SOUTLINEDINTHEFOLLOWINGSECTION !COMMONLYUSEDOPTIONINSOMECASESISTHEUSE  3TATIONS EXITING THE BUSES !DDITIONALLY ACCESS
THE "24 SYSTEM HAS A DE½NED DETAILED WEEKLY OFGRASSINBETWEENTHE"24LANEANDTHEOTHER !NOTHER VERY IMPORTANT CHARACTERISTIC OF A "24 TOTHEBUSESISFAREASIERANDBETTERFOR
SCHEDULETHATISCHECKEDONADAILYBASIS WHEREBY LANES7HILETHISHASAPOSITIVEEFFECTONTHERE SYSTEMISITSSTATIONS4HESEAREDIFFERENTFROMTHE THE DISABLED POPULATION WHO USUALLY
ANADEQUATEANDTEMPORARILYAPPROPRIATESERVICE DUCTIONOFVEHICLENOISELEVELS ITMAYHAVEOPE TRADITIONALBUSSTOPS)NMANYASPECTSTHESEARE STRUGGLEWITHPROBLEMSINOTHERTYPESOF
ISPROVIDEDFORUSERS RATIONALPROBLEMSINOVERTAKINGLANES ANDSOME QUITEDIFFERENT ESPECIALLYWHENTHE"24SYSTEMIS STATIONSWHERETHEREARESTAIRCASES STEPS
MAINTENANCEINCONVENIENCES COMPLETE4HESTATIONSINA"24SYSTEMHAVETHE ANDCURBS
)NORDERTOACHIEVETHIS ITISNECESSARYTOGENE FOLLOWINGCHARACTERISTICS
RATESOMEFORMOFPHYSICALDIVISIONBETWEENTHE )NSOMECASES WHEREAHIGHPERFORMANCELEVELOF 3TATIONS HAVE TURNSTILES TO ±CHECK IN²
"24 LANES AND THE REST OF THE TRAF½C HAVING A "24ISREQUIRED PASSINGLANESAREDEVELOPEDAND )NSTEADOFHAVINGTHESTATIONSLOCATEDON AND±CHECKOUT²OFTHESYSTEMTHISALLOWS
COLOUREDLANEISNOTENOUGH#ITIESLIKE,ONDON AGREATPARTOFTHESYSTEMCANHAVETWOLANESIN THESIDESOFTHELANES THESEARELOCATED USERSTOVERIFYTHEIRFAREOFFBOARDWHICH
HAVEBUSLANESPAINTEDINREDPAINTWHICHPEOPLE BOTH DIRECTIONS 4HIS IS CONSTRUCTED TO IMPROVE ATTHEMEDIANSINBETWEENTHETWO"24 INCREASESSPEEDINTHESYSTEM ANDALSO
RESPECT 4HISISONLYPOSSIBLEBECAUSETHECOLO THECOMBINATIONOFROUTESINTHESYSTEM ANDTO LANES  !FTER OBSERVING MANY SYSTEMS OF ALLOWS USERS TO CHANGE ROUTES WITHOUT
UREDLANESARECOMPLEMENTEDBYACOMPLEXVIDEO INCREASETHEPOSSIBILITYOFHAVINGMORE±EXPRESS² THIS KIND IN VARIOUS CITIES THROUGHOUT PAYINGFORADDITIONALTICKETS
CAMERA##46 SYSTEMTHATENFORCESCOMPLIANCE ROUTESTHISWILLBEDISCUSSEDFURTHERINTHEOPE THEWORLD ITCANBECONCLUDEDTHATTHIS
4HE SIMPLEST WAY TO DO THIS IS BY BUILDING PHY RATIONS SECTION  4HE "24 SYSTEM IS NORMALLY OPTION IS FAR MORE EF½CIENT IN TERMS OF 3TATIONS ARE ±CLOSED² THE STATIONS HAVE
SICALBARRIERSBETWEENTHELANES!FUNDAMENTAL CONSTRUCTED WITH PASSING LANES AT THE STATIONS OPERATIONANDUSAGEOFSPACE ±WALLSANDCEILING² WHICHPROVIDESUSERS
ASPECT OF THESE BARRIERS DESPITE THEIR DIVISIVE DEPENDINGONTHEOPERATIONALMODELUSED WITHPROTECTIONFROMCLIMATECONDITIONS

20 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 21
AND MAKES STOPPING EASIER FOR VEHICLES FUTURECOMMERCIALEARNINGS7HENTHETERMSIN
AT SPECI½C PLACES TO PICK UP AND DROP OF THE CONTRACT WERE WELL DE½NED AGREEMENTS
OFFPASSENGERS(OWEVER THISMAKESTHE BETWEEN PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ENTITIES HAVE BEEN
STATIONSMOREEXPENSIVE PRO½TABLE'IVENTHATTERMINALSTATIONSBECOME
PLACESOFLARGE¾OWSOFPEOPLE THEYCANBEUSED
3TATIONSAREPARTICULARLYUSEFULPLACESTOGENERATE AS±ADMINISTRATIVECENTRES²WHEREPEOPLECANRUN
ANIMAGEOFTHESYSTEM ANDFORUSERSTOACQUAINT ERRANDS ANDPAYBILLSRELATED TOPUBLICSERVICES
THEMSELVES WITH THE SYSTEM AND SEE IT AS AN AR 4HISISVERYCONVENIENTFORBOTHTHEPUBLICSECTOR
CHITECTURALCONTRIBUTIONTOTHECITY RATHERTHANA ANDTHESYSTEMUSERS
FUNCTIONALTRANSPORTSTRUCTURE)TISANOPPORTU
NITYTHATMUSTBETAKENINTOACCOUNTINORDERTO $EPOTSAREPLACESUSEDFORPARKINGANDMAINTE
IMPROVETHEPHYSICALAPPEARANCEOFTHECITY4HIS NANCEOFVEHICLES)NMANYCASES THEOF½CESOFTHE
ENABLES THE POSSIBILITY OF HIRING ARCHITECTS TO SYSTEMOPERATORSAREBUILTATTHEDEPOTS4HISCAN
SPECI½CALLYDESIGNTHESYSTEM´SSTATIONS ONCETHE ALSOBEUSEDASANOPPORTUNITYTODEVELOPTHEDE
TECHNICAL CRITERIA ARE WELL DE½NED DIMENSIONS POTINASSOCIATIONWITHTHEOPERATORSTHEPUBLIC
HEIGHTS TURNSTILE PLACEMENT ETC  !DDITIONALLY SECTORPROVIDESTHESPACETODEVELOPTHEDEPOTAND
STATIONS MEAN INCOME OPPORTUNITIES THROUGH OF½CES WHILETHEOPERATORISINCHARGEOFCONS
PUBLICITYADVERTISEMENTS  TRUCTINGTHENECESSARYINFRASTRUCTUREFORMAINTE
NANCE PARKINGANDMANAGEMENTOPERATINGNEEDS &IGURE  /NE OF THE DEPOTS OF THE 4RANSMETRO SYS &IGURE4HECONTROLCENTREOFA"24SYSTEMENABLES
"RIDGESTOACCESSTHESTATIONSAREANADDITIONAL TEMIN'UATEMALA#ITY WHEREMAINTENANCEISDONETO AN EASIER FOLLOW UP ON THE OPERATIONS OF ALL VEHICLES
ELEMENTRELATEDTOTHESTATIONS%VENTHOUGHITIS VEHICLES THROUGHOUTTHE"24NETWORK
PREFERABLETOPROVIDECROSSINGSATTRAF½CLIGHTSFOR
PEDESTRIANS SOMETIMESITISNECESSARYTOCONSTRUCT
SUPPORTING INFRASTRUCTURE SUCH AS PEDESTRIAN
BRIDGES TOEASEACCESSTOSTATIONS4HEIMPORTANT
THINGABOUTTHESEBRIDGESISTHATTHEYMUSTPROVIDE  #ONTROLCENTRE SOFTWARE TO TRACK ALL VEHICLES )T IS ALSO NORMAL
RAMPSANDELEVATORSFORTHEDISABLEDPOPULATION 4HE CONTROL CENTRE IS THE PLACE FROM WHERE TO HAVE A SERIES OF MONITORS THAT PERMANENTLY
PERMANENT MONITORING OF THE COMPLETE SYSTEM RECORD ACTIVITIES AT STATIONS AND ON SOME
 4ERMINALSANDDEPOTS OPERATIONISDONE!NEXCLUSIVEENTITYISUSUALLYIN OCCASIONS WHATISHAPPENINGINSIDETHEVEHICLES
4ERMINAL STATIONS AND DEPOTS ARE AN ADDITIONAL CHARGEOFMANAGINGANDCONTROLLINGTHESYSTEM!
ELEMENTTHATCANBEEXPLOITEDFORTHEDEVELOPMENT FOLLOWUPOFTHEWEEKLYSERVICEPLANNINGISDONE
OF THE SYSTEM´S IMAGE 4HE PRINCIPAL FUNCTION FROMTHISCONTROLCENTRE)NCOMINGANDOUTGOING
 /PERATIONS
OF THE TERMINAL STATION IS TO SUPPORT AS MANY MESSAGESBETWEENBUSDRIVERSANDCONTROLCENTRE
PASSENGERSASPOSSIBLEANDTOGUIDETHEMTOTHEIR STAFFARESENTINREALTIME$ECISIONSAREMADEAND
DESTINATIONS AS EASILY AS POSSIBLE 4HESE ALSO INSTRUCTIONSAREGIVENFROMTHECONTROLCENTREIN !SECONDFUNDAMENTALCOMPONENTRELATEDTOTHE
WORK AS INTERCHANGE CENTRES WITH OTHER MODES CASE OF EMERGENCIES OPERATING PROBLEMS OR IN EF½CIENCYOFACOMPLETE"24SYSTEMISAWELL DE
OF TRANSPORTATION LOCAL REGIONAL ETC  "UILDING CASE AN ADDITIONAL VEHICLE IS NEEDED TO COVER A ½NEDPLANOFOPERATIONS4HISWILLDETERMINETHE
THESE TERMINAL STATIONS TOGETHER WITH A PRIVATE ROUTE (ENCE IT IS CLEAR THAT THE FUNDAMENTAL DAILYFUNCTIONINGOFTHESYSTEM THEWAYTHECO
CONSTRUCTOR IS A GOOD OPTION WHEN DEVELOPING &IGURE4HE"US2APID3YSTEM-ETROVqAIN'UAYAQUIL COMPONENTOFTHISCONTROLCENTREISTHEPERMANENT RRIDORSARECON½GURED ANDTHESTRATEGIESTOCOM
THEM )N THESE CASES THE CONSTRUCTOR PROVIDES BUILTHIGHCAPACITYTERMINALSTATIONSWHERETHEREISTHE COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM WITH THE VEHICLES PLY WITH THE EXPECTED CAPACITY 4HIS IS A HIGHLY
THEINFRASTRUCTUREFORTHETERMINALANDINTEGRATES POSSIBILITY OF INTEGRATING THE SYSTEM WITH OTHER LOCAL GENERALLY BY MEANS OF '03 TECHNOLOGY WITH COMPLEXJOBTHATREQUIRESVERYELABORATEOPERA
IT WITH COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT PROVIDING SERVICES PERSONNELONTHESYSTEMITSELF ANDWITHSPECIALIZED TIONS TO DETERMINE THE AMOUNT OF VEHICLES NEE

22 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 23
DEDONSPECI½CDAYSANDHOURS4HISISANASPECT ARE DETERMINED IN A SYSTEM THAT AIMS AT PROVI MORETHANMETERSTOREACHTHETERMINALSTA
THAT WILL DETERMINE THE QUALITY OF A "24 SYSTEM DING HIGH QUALITY SERVICE TO ITS CLIENTELE AND TION  4HE MAIN DISADVANTAGE OF THE TRUNK FEEDER
AND EVENTUALLY USERSATISFACTION WHERETHEPROVISIONOFSERVICESISDE½NEDINAC SERVICEISTHATITREQUIRESTRANSFERS4HEREAREDI
CORDANCETOTECHNICALCRITERIA ANDTOTHEMERIT FFERENTOPINIONSAMONGEXPERTSOFTHEDIRECTAND
4HE½RSTASPECTTOBETAKENINTOACCOUNTISWHE BASED APPOINTMENT OF OPERATORS /PEN SYSTEMS THETRUNK FEEDERMODELSCONCERNINGTHEEF½CIENCY
THER THE SYSTEM SHOULD BE OPEN OR CLOSED !N GENERALLY HAVE CONGESTION PROBLEMS BECAUSE OF OFONEMODELVERSUSTHEOTHER4HISISBOTHNE
OPENSYSTEMREFERSTOTHATINWHICHANYOPERATOR THE MULTIPLE QUANTITY OF VEHICLES ON THE ROADS CESSARYANDHELPFULINANALYZINGTHESITUATIONIN
CANPARTICIPATEINTHESYSTEM ANDWHERETHEREIS !NOTHERPROBLEMISTHE±CENTWAR ²WHICHWILLBE EVERYCITY ANDMAKINGADECISIONABOUTTHEMOST
AMINIMUMORNULLCONTROLOVERTHESYSTEM!CLO DISCUSSEDINDEPTHINTHEBUSINESSPLANSECTION ADEQUATEFORMOFSERVICE
SEDSYSTEMISONEWHEREVEHICLESANDENTERPRISES
CANOPERATEINTHESYSTEMONCETHEYAREELECTED 4HESERVICESPROVIDEDINACLOSEDSYSTEMCANBE !NOTHER ASPECT OF GREAT IMPORTANCE TO THE EF½
THROUGH A CONTEST GENERALLY THOUGH A BIDDING DIRECTORTRUNK FEEDER)NADIRECTSERVICE THEVEHI CIENCYOFTHESYSTEMISTHETYPEOFSERVICESEXPRESS
PROCESS AND WHERE THERE IS STRICT CONTROL OVER CLESHAVEADE½NEDROUTEWITHINSEGREGATEDLANES ORLOCAL)NLOCALSERVICES VEHICLESMAKESTOPSAT
THE SYSTEM´S OPERATION CONDITIONS WITH REGARDS ANDOFFERASIMILARSERVICETOTHEONEGIVENBYA ALLSTATIONSINTHEROUTE PROVIDINGASIMPLEAND
TOVEHICLESINTHELANESANDOFFEREDSERVICESAND TRADITIONALBUSMANYSTOPSINMIXEDTRAF½C LOW COMPREHENSIVESERVICEATANORMALSPEED%XPRESS
SCHEDULES4HISSHOULDBECENTRALIZEDBYASPECI PLATFORMSTATIONS ETC OUTSIDETHESEGREGATEDLA SERVICES ARE THOSE IN WHICH VEHICLES STOP ONLY &IGURE4HEADEQUATEOCCUPATIONLEVELINSIDEAVEHICLEMUSTBE
½CENTITYTHATMANAGESTHESYSTEM NES)NTHETRUNK FEEDERSERVICE THEREAREVEHICLES AT CERTAIN SPECI½ED STATIONS WHICH RUN SIGNI½ STUDIED CAREFULLY BECAUSE USER SATISFACTION RELIES ON THIS IN THE
EXCLUSIVELYINSIDESEGREGATEDLANESANDALSOVEHI CANTLYFASTERBUTALSOIMPLYMORECOMPLEXOPERA LONGRUN.EVERTHELESS A½NANCIALLYSUSTAINABLEOPERATIONWITHOUT
%VENTHOUGHTHEOPENSYSTEMSEEMSTOBEMORE CLESFORTHEFEEDERSOFTHESYSTEM4HOSEFEEDERS TIONS4HESEALSOIMPLYDEVELOPINGAPASSINGLANE ANYSUBSIDIESIMPLIESAREASONABLELEVELOFAGGLOMERATIONINSIDE
DEMOCRATIC ITISACTUALLYTHE±CLOSED²SYSTEMTHAT ARETHEBUSESTHATHAVEROUTESFROMTHETERMINAL PLUSTWOLANESPERDIRECTIONINSOMEPARTSOFTHE THEBUSES
HASDEMONSTRATEDITSELFTOBETHEFAIREST4HISIS STATIONSTOTHEOUTERAREASOUTSKIRTS WHERETHE SYSTEM INORDERTOMAKETHISOPTIONPOSSIBLE)N
DUE TO THE FACT THAT SPECI½C OPERATION CRITERIA RE MAY BE USERS IN NEED OF LONG DISTANCE TRAVEL GENERAL EXPRESSSERVICESINCREASETHESPEEDAND
THEPERFORMANCEOFTHESYSTEM MAKINGTHE"24
SYSTEMCOMPARABLETORAILSYSTEMS.EVERTHELESS RATIONAL AND ½NANCIAL PLAN 6EHICLE FREQUENCY
EXPRESSSERVICEOPERATIONSMUSTBECOMPLEMEN THEDIMENSIONS ANDQUANTITYOFVEHICLESTHATARE
TEDBYAWELL DESIGNEDSIGNAGESYSTEM PROVIDING REQUIREDATASPECI½CMOMENT MUSTBEDE½NED
&IGURE  4HE ADEQUATE OPERATION CLEAR INFORMATION TO USERS ABOUT WHICH BUS TO INRELATIONTOTHEAMOUNTOFPEOPLETOBETRANS
OF A "24 SYSTEM OF GREAT COVERAGE TAKEINDIFFERENTCASES)T´SWORTHMENTIONINGTHAT PORTEDPERSQUAREMETER4HISASPECTWILLALSODE
AS 4RANS-ILENIO IMPLIES A COMPLEX EXPRESS SERVICES MUST WORK SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH TERMINETHESYSTEM´SREVENUEWITHAGREATEROC
SCHEME THAT TOOK MANY MONTHS ALLOTHERLOCALSERVICES CUPANCYLEVELINSIDETHEVEHICLES THEOPERATIONAL
TO BE DESIGNED 4HIS SCHEME MUST COSTSAREREDUCED FORBOTHOPERATORSANDFORTHE
SPECIFYDETAILSOFBUSFREQUENCYAND /NE OF THE CHARACTERISTICS OF A "24 IS THAT IT´S PUBLIC SECTOR /NE MUST BE VERY CAUTIOUS WHEN
OTHERS0HOTOBY$IEGO6ELAZQUEZ BEEN DE½NED AS A MASS TRANSIT SYSTEM !DDITIO DETERMININGAHIGHLEVELOFOCCUPANCYBECAUSE
NALLY IT´SBEENDE½NEDASASYSTEMTHATMAXIMIZES DESPITE THE APPARENT EFFECTIVENESS IN REDUCING
THEUSEOFSPACEINSIDETHEVEHICLES4OBEMORE COSTS THISCOULDREDUCETHESYSTEM´SDEMANDIN
SPECI½C THEMOVEMENTOFPEOPLEINSIDETHE"24 THELONGTERMBECAUSEUSERSLOOKFORLESSCROW
BUSESSHOULDBESIMILARTOTHATOFONEINAME DEDOPTIONS
TROSYSTEMFOURPEOPLEPERSQUAREMETERINCON
VENTIONAL VEHICLES WHILE IN SOME EXTREME CASES 4HE TYPE OF VEHICLES THAT ARE NEEDED WILL ALSO
THESYSTEMISPLANNEDFORSIXPEOPLEPERSQUARE BEINCLUDEDINTHEDE½NITIONOFTHEOPERATIONAL
METER 4HIS VEHICLE OCCUPANCY INDICATOR WILL BE MODELS TO BE USED IN A SYSTEM 4HE SIZE OF THE
CRUCIALATTHETIMEOFDE½NINGDETAILSOFTHEOPE VEHICLES IS INTIMATELY RELATED TO THE PASSENGER

24 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 25
 "USINESS3TRUCTURE
DEMANDINTHECORRIDORS THEMOSTADEQUATEFRE )NMANYINSTANCES THECENTRALPROBLEMWITHTHIS
¯REORGANIZATIONOF
QUENCIESINASPECI½CCORRIDOR ANDTHEAMOUNT ASPECTISTHATTHEREISASEPARATEAGENCYINCHARGE
THEPUBLICTRANSPORTSECTOR
OFSTOPSINASTATION4HESIZEANDCHARACTERISTICS OFTHETRAF½CLIGHTOPERATIONS SOPROGRAMMINGIS
OF THE VEHICLES TO BE USED IN A SPECI½C SYSTEM NOTSYNCHRONIZEDWITHTHE"24SYSTEM BUTWITH
SHOULDNOTBEDETERMINEDAPRIORI LIKEASYSTEM THE GENERAL TRAF½C )N SOME EXTREME SITUATIONS 4HE±BUSINESS²OFA"24SYSTEMREFERSTOTHEORGA
THATHASARTICULATEDORSTANDARDBUSES BECAUSE TRAF½CPOLICEOF½CERSHAVESTOPPED"24BUS¾OW NIZATIONOFTHEOPERATORSWHOWILLTAKEPARTINIT
THISWILLAFFECTTHERESULTANDADEQUATEOPERATIO IN ORDER TO MAKE WAY FOR PRIVATE CARS AT INTER THEIRRESPONSIBILITIESANDRIGHTS ANDTHEWAYTHEY
NAL SYSTEM )F A SYSTEM IS DESIGNED A PRIORI WITH SECTIONS GIVINGTHEIMPRESSIONTHATPRIVATECARS INTERACTWITHONEANOTHER4RADITIONALCOLLECTIVE
ARTICULATEDVEHICLESANDTHEDEMANDISREALLYLOW WERE OF GREATER IMPORTANCE THAN PUBLIC TRANS TRANSPORTSYSTEMSAREKNOWNFORPROVIDINGASER
THE BUS FREQUENCIES MUST BE REDUCED AND THIS PORT4HUSTHEINTER INSTITUTIONALCOORDINATIONOF VICEWHERETHEDRIVERS±½GHT²WITHEACHOTHERTO
MEANSALSOREDUCINGSERVICEQUALITYANDREVENUE TRAF½CLIGHTSISPARTICULARLYCRITICAL GET MORE PASSENGERS INTO THEIR VEHICLES 4HIS IS
LOSSESDUETOBADPLANNING REFERRED TO AS THE ±THE CENT WAR² PHENOMENON
4HECOORDINATIONANDFOLLOWUPOFALLTHESEOPE $RIVERS ARE PAID ON THE BASIS OF THE NUMBER OF
%VENTHOUGHDE½NINGOPERATIONSFOREXCLUSIVELA RATIONALASPECTSAREDONEFROMTHECONTROLCEN TRANSPORTED PASSENGERS 4HE LACK OF ORGANIZA &IGURE  4HIS IS A TYPICAL SITUATION IN ,IMA 0ER{ AN EXAMPLE
NESSEEMSTOBETHEONLYASPECTFORTHEPROVISION TRE WHICH HAS A MONITORING SYSTEM DESIGNED TO TIONINTHESECTOR ASWELLASVARIOUSEXTERNALITIES OF±THECENTWAR²BETWEENMANYVEHICLEDRIVERS WHO½GHTFORTHE
OFANADEQUATE"24SYSTEM ITISNECESSARYTOTAKE CONTROLPLANNINGANDCOMMUNICATIONSWITHVEHI GENERATE AN URGENT NEED FOR CHANGE WITHIN THE SAMEPASSENGERS
INTOACCOUNTTHEINTERACTIONWITHOTHERMODESOF CLES ANDTOSOLVEPROBLEMSINTHESYSTEM SYSTEM
TRANSPORTATIONATCROSSINGPOINTS ASWELLASTHE
DE½NITIONOFTRAF½CLIGHTPHASINGALONGTHECORRI 4HE ½NAL ASPECT OF THE "24 SYSTEM OPERATIONS 4HEFUNDAMENTALCHANGEOFTHISSCHEMEISFROM
DORSOFTHESYSTEM4HISISANASPECTTHATISRARELY IS CUSTOMER SERVICE &REQUENTLY PUBLIC TRANS COMPETITIONINTHEMARKETTHEWARBETWEENAU OPERATIONSTOCOMPANIESTHROUGHCONTESTSBIDS
TAKENINTOACCOUNTWHENPLANNING YETHASACON PORT SYSTEMS ARE PLANNED WITH GREAT DEDICATION THORIZEDVEHICLESONTHESTREETS TOCOMPETITION ANDSPECIFYINGTHEDURATIONOFCONTRACTSGUARAN
SIDERABLEIMPACTONTHEOPERATIONSOFTHESYSTEM TO THE TECHNICAL ASPECTS OF VEHICLE FREQUENCY FOR THE MARKET THE CONTEST BETWEEN COMPANIES TEETHEGOODQUALITYOFTHESERVICE
THEDE½NITIONANDMONITORINGOFTHEOPERATION THAT WOULD PROVIDE A TRANSPARENT PUBLIC TRANS
.EVERTHELESS THE USERS ARE WHO WILL REALLY KEEP PORTSYSTEMBASEDONTHEIRADEQUATEMANAGERIAL 4HE OPERATORS INCLUDE NOT ONLY PEOPLE IN CHAR
THE SYSTEM RUNNING HENCE WITHOUT THEM THERE ANDOPERATIONALCAPACITIES WITHINTHEPREESTA GE OF VEHICLES GENERALLY MANY INSIDE THE SAME
&IGURE"USFREQUENCYISANOTHERIMPORTANTFACTORTOBEDE ARE NEITHER CLIENTS NOR DEMAND 4HE PROVISION BLISHED FUNCTIONING RULES  (AVING A COMPETITI SYSTEM WORKING UNDER THE SAME OPERATING RU
TERMINEDINTHEOPERATIONALPLANANDTHISWILLAFFECTTHELEVELOF OFSERVICEMUSTALWAYSBEPLANNEDBASEDONTHE VESCHEMEFORTHEMARKETCANCELS±THECENTWAR² LES BUT ALSO AN ADDITIONAL OPERATOR IN CHARGE
SERVICEPROVISIONANDUSERSATISFACTION USERS´ NEEDS 4HIS IS THE REASON FOR DE½NING A 4HEEARNINGSWITHINASYSTEMWILLBEDETERMINED OFCOLLECTINGTHEFAREANDMAINTAININGTHISCOM
CLEAR PLAN FOR THE CLEANING OF THE VEHICLES AND BY THE QUALITY OF THE SERVICE PROVIDED AND BY PONENT OF THE SYSTEM 4HESE ARE ORGANIZATIONS
INFRASTRUCTURE THECOMPREHENSIVESIGNALDESIGN THEWAYTHEYFOLLOWTHERULESCOMPLYINGWITHA SEPARATE FROM THE VEHICLE OPERATORS THAT TRACK
THE CONSTANT SEARCH FOR FEEDBACK FROM USERS OF TIMETABLE AND ESTABLISHED BUS STOPS AT SPECI½C THE AMOUNT OF PASSENGERS TRANSPORTED AND THE
THESYSTEM ANDTHEPROVISIONOFSUPPORTINFRAS STATIONS !NOTHERCHARACTERISTICTHATMAKESTHE COLLECTEDTRANSITFARE!DDITIONALLY THISMONEYIS
TRUCTURE TOILETS RESTING AREAS AESTHETIC FACTORS TRACKING OF RULES EASIER IS PAYING OPERATORS IN GIVENTOATRUSTFUNDTHATCONTROLSANDMONITORS
OF THE SYSTEM ETC  4HIS ALSO RELATES DIRECTLY TO ACCORDANCE WITH WORKED DISTANCES RATHER THAN FARECOLLECTIONONADAILYBASIS
THEEXCESSIVEAGGLOMERATIONOFTHEVEHICLESAND TRANSPORTEDPASSENGERS
TOTHEADEQUATEFREQUENCYOFTHESERVICES5SERS ! HIERARCHICAL RELATIONSHIP WITH OTHER ORGANI
MUSTTAKEPARTINTHESYSTEMANDMUSTBEINCLU $ESIGNINGCLEARANDSPECI½CCONDITIONSINWHICH ZATIONSWITHINTHESYSTEMDE½NESTHECONTROLOF
DED FROMTHESTART INTHEIMPLEMENTATIONPRO THESERVICEWILLBEPROVIDEDISAFUNDAMENTALAS THIS SERVICE PROVISION THE SYSTEM MANAGER AND
CESS OF THE SYSTEM .EGLECTING THIS ASPECT MAY PECT OF ENSURING THIS REGULATION 4HE OPERATORS THE CONTROL ORGANISM SOMETIMES THE SAME MA
RESULTINASYSTEM´SCOMPLETEFAILURE MUST BE CLEAR ABOUT THE RESPONSIBILITIES THEY NAGER 4HESEPEOPLEDE½NEANDTRACKTHEDEVE
HAVE VEHICLE MAINTENANCE WITH SPECI½C PARA LOPMENT OF THE OPERATORS BOTH OF VEHICLES AND
METERS TIMETABLE COMPLIANCE ETC  !PPOINTING OF FARE COLLECTION AND CONTROL AND DETERMINE

26 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 27
THEOPERATIONOFSPECI½CDAYSANDWEEKS BASED SPECI½ED IN ALL CONTRACTS WITH THE OPERATORS )N LESS MAINLY BECAUSE IT IS A HIGH PERFORMANCE
ONPERFORMANCEANDDEMANDINDICATORSTHROUG ASYSTEMDONEINPHASES THEDISTRIBUTIONOFTHE FUEL ANDISTHEMOSTCOMMONANDBESTKNOWNIN
HOUTTIME)NMOSTCASES THISMANAGERIALANDOR FARECANBERE DE½NEDINEACHPHASEANDINTHE THEPUBLICTRANSPORTSECTOR7HEN$IESELFUELHAS
CONTROLBODYTAKESPARTINTHEPUBLICSECTORWHILE CONTRACTSWITHEVERYNEWSERIESOFOPERATORS UN ALOWSULPHURCONCENTRATIONLEVEL GASEMISSIONS
OPERATORSAREPRIVATEANDORPUBLICEVENTHOUGH TIL AN OPTIMUM LEVEL OF RESOURCE DISTRIBUTION IS AREEQUALTOANDINSOMECASESEVENLOWERTHAN
THEYWORKUNDERTHESAMERULESASINTHECASEIN REACHED EMISSIONS BY VEHICLES RUNNING ON #OMPRESSED
-EXICO#ITY´S-ETROBUSSYSTEM  .ATURAL'AS.EVERTHELESS THE#/EMISSIONSARE
FAIRLYSIGNI½CANT BUTNEVERCOMPARABLETOPRIVATE
)NORDERTOCONTROLTHEADEQUATEPROVISIONOFTHE VEHICLEEMISSIONS
 4ECHNOLOGY
SERVICE THERE ARE INCENTIVES AND PENALTIES FOR
OPERATORSTHATAREDETERMINEDACCORDINGTOTHE )NSOMEOCCASIONSLIKEIN1UITO ELECTRICPOWE
ADEQUATE PROVISION OF THE SERVICE AND BY COM )NTHEINTRODUCTIONOFTHISDOCUMENTITWASDES REDVEHICLESHAVEBEENUSED4HESEVEHICLES BE
PLIANCEWITHTHESPECI½EDOBLIGATIONSWITHINTHE CRIBEDHOWVARIOUSMASSTRANSITSYSTEMSAREDE SIDES BEING VERY EXPENSIVE NEED ADDITIONAL IN
CONTRACT 4HERE ARE ECONOMIC PENALTIES FOR FAI ½NEDINITIALLYBYTHETECHNOLOGYTHATAMAYOROR FRASTRUCTUREOFOVERHEADCONTACTLINESFORENERGY
LINGTOMEETTHEGOALSINTHECASEOFVEHICLEOPE TRANSPORT MINISTER WOULD PREFER 9ET THE TECH PROVISION4HISCANHAVEVISUALCONSEQUENCESAND
RATORS ¯ THE DISTANCE COVERED IS REDUCED WHEN NOLOGY THATISTOBECHOSENINTERMSOFVEHICLES NOTORIOUS OPERATIONAL PROBLEMS 4HE EXCESSIVE
CALCULATING PAYMENT  -EETING GOALS ABOVE CER TRACKINGINSTRUMENTSANDFARECOLLECTION ISONE COSTOFTHEVEHICLESTHATRUNONTHISTECHNOLOGY
TAINSTANDARDSISREWARDEDINTHESAMEWAY OF THE LAST STEPS IN THE DESIGN OF A "24 SYSTEM ISTHESTRONGESTFACTORINTHESELECTIONPROCESS
/NCETHEOPERATINGCONDITIONS VEHICLENECESSI
4HE DE½NITION OF THE FARE AND ITS DISTRIBUTION TIES CON½GURATION OF THE STATIONS AND EXCLUSIVE 4HERE ARE OTHER LESS CONTAMINATING FUELS THAT
ALSOMAKESUPPARTOFTHISBUSINESSSTRUCTURE! LANES OF THE SYSTEM ARE CLEAR THE TECHNOLOGICAL HAVEBETTERPERFORMANCEINDICATORSTHANTHEONES
"24SYSTEMDOESNOTNEEDSUBSIDIESBECAUSETHE ASPECTSOFTHESYSTEMCANBEDETERMINED PREVIOUSLYDESCRIBED LIKEFUELCELLSANDHYDROGEN
FAREISDETERMINEDONTHEBASISOFTHEREVENUEGE %VENTHOUGHTHEYWOULDBELOWEMISSION THESE
NERATEDBYTHESYSTEMANDONTHEDEMANDNEEDS VEHICLESAREEXCESSIVELYEXPENSIVE ASTHEREISN´TA
ANDOPERATIONPOSSIBILITIESOFTHESYSTEM4HESE  6EHICLES SIGNI½CANT MARKET TO REDUCE THEIR CONSTRUCTION &IGURE"US2APID4RANSITVEHICLESDON´THAVETOBEARTICULATED
AREGENERALLYDETERMINEDACCORDINGTOACOMPLEX 6EHICLESINA"24SYSTEMCANBEOFVARIOUSTYPES COSTS.EVERTHELESS THEYAREANOPTION )NFACT ONVERYFEWOCCASIONSITISWORTHHAVINGBIARTICULATEDVEHI
MATHEMATICALFORMULAWITHVARIABLESTHATINCLU /NE OF THE INITIAL CONCERNS ABOUT THE VEHICLES CLES LIKETHEONESHOWNINPICTUREABOVEUSEDASTRIALFOR4RANS
DEBUSMAINTENANCEINPUTS ANDADE½NEDFORMU CHOSENFORTHESYSTEMISTHEFUELTOBEUSED)N 7ITH RESPECT TO FUEL SELECTION SOMETIMES IT IS -ILENIO #OURTESYOF4RANS-ILENIO3!
LATHATREADJUSTSTHEFAREINACCORDANCEWITHTHE SOME INSTANCES IT IS ASSUMED THAT #OMPRESSED PREFERABLE TO GIVE GENERALIZED GUIDELINES TO THE
ECONOMICAND½NANCIALCONDITIONSOFTHESYSTEM .ATURAL 'AS IS THE CLEANEST AND MOST ADVANCED OPERATORSSOTHATTHEYSELECTTHETECHNOLOGYTHEY
FUELCOSTS EXISTINGDEMANDSANDOTHERFACTORS! TECHNOLOGY(OWEVER THELOWERAUTONOMYOFTHE PREFERANDWHICHBEST½TSTHEIR½NANCIALMODELS
DECISIONTHATMUSTBEMADEISWHETHERORNOTTHE VEHICLE NEEDING TO BE ±½LLED UP² MORE OFTEN -OREOVER IF THE OPERATORS SELECT DIFFERENT FUEL
FAREWILLBE½XEDTHESAMEFAREFORANYJOURNEY THUS SUBTRACTING EF½CIENCY OF USEFUL KILOMETRES OPTIONS THISCANHAVEOPERATIONALREPERCUSSIONS DINGTHEPROVISIONOFTHESERVICE HAVEMADETHE
ORIFITWILLBEADJUSTEDACCORDINGTOTHEDISTAN IN OPERATION IS OFTEN NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT SOMEVEHICLESMUSTREMAINATDEPOTSTHATBELONG HIGHPLATFORMVEHICLESMOREDESIRABLEIN"24SYS
CETRAVELLEDLONGERJOURNEYSHAVEAHIGHERCOST  .OR ARE THE EXISTING DIF½CULTIES IN VEHICLES IN TODIFFERENTOPERATORSOVERNIGHTINSOMECASES  TEMS(IGHPLATFORMVEHICLESHAVEABETTERLEVEL
4HISMUSTBEANALYZEDANDSHOULDFAVOURALLUSERS  OCCUPANCY OR THOSE OPERATING AT GREAT OFPERFORMANCEANDLOWEROPERATIONCOSTS4HEY
EQUALLY PARTICULARLYTHOSEWITHLOWERINCOMES ALTITUDE OVER SEA LEVEL CONSIDERED 4HIS KIND OF !NADDITIONALCONSIDERATIONWITHRESPECTTOTHE ALSOHAVEEASIERCONTROLOVERTHEBUSTICKETSALES
FUELISCHOSENANDUSEDINMANYCOUNTRIESWHERE VEHICLESISTHESELECTIONOFLOWORHIGHPLATFORM THEUSEOFTHEDESIGNATEDSTATION ANDHAVEMORE
4HEDISTRIBUTIONOFTHEFAREISANOTHERASPECTTO OBTAININGITISFAIRLYEASY VEHICLES,OWPLATFORMVEHICLESHAVEHADQUITEA SEATING CAPACITY THE WHEELS OF THE BUS DO NOT
BE DE½NED IN A TECHNICAL WAY ACCORDING TO THE LOTOFPUBLICITYFORBEINGVERY¾EXIBLEANDHAVING INTERFEREWITHTHESEATARRANGEMENTSLIKELOWPLA
RESOURCECALCULATIONSINVESTEDBYEACHPARTYWI $IESELFUELISFREQUENTLYUSED)THASALOWCON A±BETTER²IMAGE BUTTHEIRCAPITALCOSTS MAINTE TFORMVEHICLESDO 
THIN THE SYSTEM AND MUST BE ALSO DE½NED AND CENTRATION OF SULPHUR PARTICLES  PPM OR NANCE AND THE VAST EF½CIENCY DIFFERENCES REGAR

28 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 29
 &ARECOLLECTION 4HERE IS ALSO THE POSSIBILITY OF OBTAINING INFOR PROGRAMMING SERVICES THAT ARE SIMPLE ENOUGH
&ARECOLLECTIONMETHODSMUSTBEVERSATILEENOUGH MATIONABOUTTRANSPORTSERVICEVIATEXTMESSAGE SOUSERSDON´THAVEPROBLEMSUNDERSTANDINGTHE
TOPROVIDEANADEQUATEANDEF½CIENTSERVICEHAVE 3-3 TOAUSER´SMOBILEPHONE!TTHESTATIONS SYSTEMANDLEARNINGHOWTOUSEIT4HEINFORMA
THE CAPACITY FOR MANY TICKETS HAVE LOW COSTS THISCANBECOMPLEMENTEDWITHSCREENSCONTAI TIONSYSTEMSTOTHEUSERSARETHEMOSTUSEFULTOOL
EASEOFUSEANDRECHARGE ANDTHEPOSSIBILITYOF NINGREALTIMEINFORMATIONABOUTTHEBUSESTHAT TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM AS THEY CAN SIGNI½CANTLY
DISTANCEBASEDFARES4HEEXISTINGFARECOLLECTION ARE ARRIVING AT THE STATION AND THE TIME REMAI SIMPLIFY COMPLEX INFORMATION SYSTEMS 7HEN
OPTIONSFORA"24SYSTEMAREPAPERTICKETS COINS NINGFORTHENEXTBUSTOARRIVEATAPARTICULARSTA THEREISACOMPUTERIZEDINFORMATIONSYSTEMATA
OR TOKENS MAGNETIC BAND CARDS OR SMART CARDS TION4HISIMPROVESTHESERVICESUBSTANTIALLYAND STATION THEUSERONLYHASTOINDICATETHESTATION
4HE ½RST TWO ARE NOT NORMALLY USED BECAUSE HELPS TO REDUCE THE PERCEPTION OF WAITING TIME WHEREHESHEISGOINGTOANDTHESYSTEMWILLPRO
THEY AREN´T VERSATILE ENOUGH NOR DO THEY HAVE FORTHEUSERS VIDE THE SPECI½ED INFORMATION REGARDING WHICH
ADVANCEDTRACKINGFUNCTIONS &IGURE!FREQUENTLYUSEDFARESYSTEMISTHESMART BUSTOTAKE ANDTHEROUTESANDCHANGESIFANY
CARD )T IS ¾EXIBLE VERSATILE AND HAS A LOW COST 4HE 3OMETHINGTHATISDIRECTLYRELATEDTOGOODINFOR TOREACHTHE½NALDESTINATION7ITHOUTTHISKIND
-AGNETICBANDCARDSANDSMARTCARDSAREBETTER CARD OF THE -EGAB{S SYSTEM IN 0EREIRA IS PARTLY PAID MATION FOR A USER IS THE SIMPLICITY OF A SYSTEM OFSYSTEM THEUSERMUSTRELYONMAPS
ANDMOREADEQUATEOPTIONSFORA"24SYSTEM4HE THROUGHPUBLICITY 4HE OPERATIONS SECTION DESCRIBED THE NEED FOR
INTELLIGENTCARDSHAVEBEENTHEMOSTUSEDINTHE
SESYSTEMSDUETOTHEGREATAMOUNTOFDATATHAT
CANBESTOREDINTHEMJOURNEYS MONEYCHARGED WITHTHEDRIVERENABLESTHEMONITORINGANDAD &IGURE!MAPWITHANINTERACTIVEGUIDETOLOCATEASERVICEORROUTEINTHESYSTEMISA
DAY HOURANDPLACEOFTRANSACTIONS CARDIDENTI JUSTING OF THE SERVICE PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE GOODTOOLFORA"24SYSTEM3OURCEWWWSURUMBOCOM
½CATIONNUMBERS ETC !DDITIONALLY THEPRICEOF WITHTHEPREVIOUSLYESTABLISHEDPARAMETERS%ACH
THESECARDSHASDROPPEDCONSIDERABLYINRECENT VEHICLEMUSTTHENHAVEACOMMUNICATIONSDEVI
YEARS RESULTING IN THE DECISION MAKING PROCESS CEINCONNECTIONWITHTHECONTROLCENTRE ASWELL
BECOMINGINDEPENDENTOFPRICECONSIDERATIONS ASASATELLITECOMMUNICATIONELEMENTTOLOCATEIT
WITHTHE'03SYSTEMUSEDATTHECONTROLCENTRE
4HE COMPLETE POTENTIAL OF A "24 SYSTEM IS REA FOR MONITORING ITS LOCATION IN COMPLIANCE WITH
CHEDWHENITISIMPLEMENTEDWITHOFFBOARDVE THEESTABLISHEDTIMETABLE4HISISCOMPLEMENTED
HICLEVERI½CATION INOTHERWORDSWHENTHEUSER WITH SOFTWARE DESIGNED SPECI½CALLY FOR THIS PUR
VALIDATES THE CARD UPON ENTERING THE STATION POSE
RATHER THAN INSIDE THE VEHICLE 4HIS MAKES THE
PERFORMANCEOFTHESYSTEMINCREASESIGNI½CANTLY  5SERINFORMATION
ASMOREPEOPLECANGOINANDOUTOFTHEBUSAT 4HEDEVELOPMENTOFTHE)NTERNETHASSUBSTANTIALLY
THESTOPS WHILEAVOIDINGFAREEVASIONPROBLEMS INCREASED THE POSSIBILITY OF HAVING ACCESS TO
!DDITIONALLY THISALLOWSTHECOMPLETETRACKINGOF A SPECI½C PUBLIC TRANSPORT PLANNING SERVICE
THESYSTEM´SUSERSORIGINSANDDESTINATIONSTOBE -AKING USE OF A WEBPAGE THAT HAS A DATABASE
DETERMINED ACCORDING TO THE STATIONS AND NOT CONTAININGINFORMATIONABOUTTHEPROGRAMMING
VEHICLES  OF THE SYSTEM ALLOWS USERS TO PLAN A JOURNEY
IN ADVANCE WITHOUT THE NEED FOR A DETAILED
 4RACKINGSYSTEMS TIMETABLE OR SPECI½C MAPS 4HE ONLY PROBLEM
!S DESCRIBED PREVIOUSLY THE VEHICLE TRACKING CONCERNINGANEXCLUSIVEINFORMATIONAPPLICATION
SYSTEMS ARE A CRUCIAL COMPONENT IN THE DEVELO VIATHE)NTERNETISTHATMANYUSERSOFTHESYSTEM
PMENT OF A "24 SYSTEM ,OCATING THE EXACT PO ESPECIALLYIN,ATIN!MERICA HAVELIMITEDINTERNET
SITIONOFAVEHICLEINREALTIMETHROUGHAGLOBAL ACCESS IFANY MAKINGTHISSERVICEUSELESS
POSITIONINGSYSTEM¯'03 ANDCOMMUNICATING

30 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 31
&IGURE  4HE CLARITY OF MAPS IN¾UENCES LIKELYTHATTHE"24SYSTEMWON´TREACHTHEDESI ANDROLE!DDITIONALLY PARKINGABICYCLEISSOME
USERS´SATISFACTIONDIRECTLYWHENUSINGTHE REDDEMANDLEVEL,ONGWALKSBETWEENBUSTRANS TIMES IMPOSSIBLE &URTHERMORE PROHIBITING THE
SYSTEM FER PATHS LEVEL CHANGES AN EXCESS OF STAIRCASES PARKING OF BICYCLES AT PUBLIC TRANSPORT STATIONS
TO REACH STATIONS OR CHANGING POINTS MUST BE AND STOPS IS A PARADOX 0ROVIDING CLARITY TO THE
AVOIDEDASMUCHASPOSSIBLE!HIGHSECURITYLEVEL ROLE OF THE BICYCLE AS AN INTEGRATED FACTOR WITH
ALONGTHEROUTELEADINGTOTHESTATIONSMUSTALSO PUBLICTRANSPORT ISVITAL
BEPROVIDED4HISREFERSTOBOTHTHELIGHTINGCON 4HEBICYCLEHASACATCHMENTAREAOFMUCH
DITIONSINTHESTATIONSANDONTHESIDEWALKS AND LARGER PROPORTIONS THAN PEDESTRIANS DO
WIDENSTHEVIEWOFPUBLICTRANSPORTASSOMETHING MAKING A  KM JOURNEY POSSIBLE WITH THE
PURELYFUNCTIONAL ANDTOWARDSTHEPROVISIONOFA SAMEOREVENLESSEFFORTTHANAMETER
CRUCIALSERVICEFORALLCITIZENS JOURNEYBYFOOT
4HEBICYCLETAKESUPVERYLITTLESPACEUPTO
 )NTEGRATIONWITHBICYCLES BICYCLESCANBEPARKEDONASINGLECAR
"ICYCLISTSSUFFERMANYOFTHEPROBLEMSTHATWERE PARKINGSPACE MAKINGPARKINGCOSTSMINI
DESCRIBEDFORPEDESTRIANS BUTINSOMECASESTHEY MUM
ENCOUNTEREVENMOREPROBLEMSWHENMOVINGON 4HEBICYCLECANPARTIALLYREPLACETHEFUNC
THE STREETS AS THERE IS NO CLARITY OF THEIR RIGHTS TIONOFAFEEDERSYSTEM

 )NTEGRATION
 )NTEGRATIONWITHPEDESTRIANS &IGURE4HEEASINESSTOWALKINTOANDTHROUGHTHESTATIONSISONEOFTHE½RSTASPECTSTHATMUSTBE
4HE SITUATION FOR PEDESTRIANS IN MANY CITIES IS TAKENINTOACCOUNTINTHEDESIGNOFTHESYSTEM4HEUSERSARETHECLIENTSOFTHESYSTEMANDTHEYMUST
"24 SYSTEMS ARE PART OF A GREATER URBAN TRANS UNFORTUNATE 4HEY MUST GO THROUGH CONSTANT FEELCOMFORTABLEWHENUSINGIT
PORT SYSTEM 4HIS INCLUDES ALL OTHER MODES OF OBSTACLESWHENWALKINGTOWORK7HENTHEYCOM
TRANSPORTATIONPEDESTRIANS BICYCLES OTHERMASS MUTETOANDFROMWORK THEREISN´TALWAYSTHEPRO
PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS TAXIS AND CARS 4HE PERINFRASTRUCTURETOREACHTHESTATIONS4HISHAS
PROPER WORKING CAPACITY OF A "24 SYSTEM RELIES STARTED TO CHANGE IN SOME CITIES IN ,ATIN !ME
ONHOWEASILYITINTEGRATESWITHOTHERTRANSPORT RICA WHERE THE PLANNING OF PUBLIC TRANSPORT IS
SYSTEMS7HENPLANNINGA"24SYSTEM ONEMUST DONEWITHPEDESTRIANSINMIND
HAVEANOPENMINDINORDERTOCONCEIVEVARIOUS
WAYSTOINTEGRATETHESTATIONSWITHBICYCLES THE 4HESE PEDESTRIANS ARE THE MAIN USERS OF PUBLIC
TERMINALSTATIONSWITHOTHERLONGDISTANCEMODES TRANSPORT !S SUCH THEY SHOULD BE GIVEN ±THE
OF TRANSPORTATION CARS AND TAXIS !N INTELLIGENT RED CARPET² TREATMENT 4HE INFRASTRUCTURE OF A
WAYOFINTEGRATINGTHESYSTEMWITHTHERESTOFTHE "24 SYSTEM MUST INCLUDE NOT ONLY STATIONS AND
URBANTRANSPORTISTOMAKETHE"24ANESSENTIAL EXCLUSIVELANESBUTALSOPROPERSIDEWALKSFORPE
COMPONENTINACITY´SMOBILITYSOTHATITSIMPACT DESTRIANS TO MOVE FREELY AND COMFORTABLY AND
WILLBEMUCHGREATERITSLEVELOFDEMANDWILLALSO TO REACH THE STATIONS SAFELY 4HE CROSSING AREAS
BEMUCHHIGHERTHANASYSTEMTHATISNOTINTEGRA MUSTALSOBEADEQUATEANDHAVETRAF½CLIGHTSAT
TED /THERINTEGRATIONOPTIONSWITHOTHERMODES EVERY POSSIBLE INTERSECTION )N CASES WHERE THIS
AREPRESENTEDINTHEFOLLOWING ISN´T POSSIBLE PEDESTRIAN BRIDGES MUST BE BUILT
WITHACCESSRAMPSFORTHEDISABLED)FTHISISNOT
TAKENINTOACCOUNTASSOMETIMESHAPPENSINTHE
PLANNINGOFPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMS ITISVERY

32 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 33
4HEBICYCLEISAVEHICLETHATDOESNOTEMIT  5SINGRACKSFORBICYCLESATTHEFRONTORBACK FARES -OREOVER ITMUSTBESHELTEREDAND
ANYTOXICGASESINTOTHEATMOSPHEREWHEN OFTHEVEHICLETHISOPTIONIMPLIESTHEUSAGE MUSTPROVIDEAHIGHLEVELOFSURVEILLANCE AS
BEINGUSED MAKINGITACOMPLETELYSUSTAI OFRACKSLOCATEDONTHEOUTERPARTOFTHEVE THEUSERSWOULDLEAVETHEIRBICYCLESATTHE
NABLETRANSPORTOPTION HICLESWHERETHEBICYCLESCANBEATTACHED STATIONSFORMANYHOURSANDWOULDRETURN
4HOUGH THIS SEEMS VERY USEFUL IT HAS A LATERORATNIGHTTOCOLLECTTHEM
BIG DRAWBACK IN TERMS OF THE TIME SPENT
4HE THREE BASIC WAYS OF INTEGRATING THE BICYCLE MOUNTINGANDDISMOUNTINGBICYCLESONTHE )NADDITIONTOUSINGONEORMOREOFTHESEOPTIONS
INTOA"24SYSTEMARE SYSTEM ESPECIALLYINASYSTEMOFHIGHPLAT INA"24SYSTEM INTEGRATINGTHECONSTRUCTIONOF
 0ROVIDINGEASYBICYCLEACCESSONTOVEHICLES FORMSTATIONSANDVEHICLES ANDCOULDRESULT BICYCLE INFRASTRUCTURE CYCLE PATHS SHOULD BE
APOSSIBILITYISDESIGNATINGASPECI½CSPACE INSCHEDULEDELAYSFORA"24SYSTEM OTHER DONESOTHEUSERSNOTONLYHAVEASAFEPLACEINSI
IN VEHICLES FOR BICYCLES OR SCHEDULING A WISEKNOWNFORITSFASTLEVELOFSERVICE DETHESTATIONSBUTALSOUPONTHEIRARRIVALATTHE
SPECI½CSERVICEIEEVERYMINUTES THAT  "UILDING BICYCLE PARKING AREAS AT THE STA STATION.ONETHELESS ITISCLEARTHATTHISCOMPO
TRANSPORTS BICYCLES ONLY THIS COULD BE A TIONSWHERETHEREISAHIGHLEVELOFBICYCLE NENTISNOTEASYTOMEETASPARTOFTHE"24PRO
VEHICLE WITHOUT ANY SEATS  4HIS OPTION USEIDEALLY ALL"24STATIONSSHOULDHAVEA JECT PLAN DESPITE THE FACT THAT IT COULD BE PART
DOESN´T HAVE A VERY HIGH ASSOCIATED COST SAFE INFRASTRUCTURE TO PARK BICYCLES (OW OFTHECONSTRUCTIONOFTHESYSTEM´SINFRASTRUCTURE
IN SOME CASES NO COST AT ALL THOUGH IT EVER INSOMECASESTHISISONLYPOSSIBLEAT DURINGTHECONSTRUCTIONPHASE &IGURE  !N ADEQUATE BICYCLE ACCESS TO A BICYCLE
MAY REPRESENT SOME INCONVENIENCE OR TERMINALSTATIONSANDATCERTAININTERMEDI PARKINGAREAOFA"24SYSTEM
DISCOMFORT FOR THE OTHER PASSENGERS AT ATE STATIONS WITH HIGH DEMAND LEVELS 4HE  )NTEGRATIONWITHOTHERMEANS
PEAK HOURS 4HIS IS SEEN IN MANY .ORDIC MOST IMPORTANT CONSIDERATION FOR A BICY OFTRANSPORT¯BUSES TRAINSYSTEMS
COUNTRIES LIKE $ENMARK AND IN SOME CLEPARKINGAREATOBESUCCESSFULWITHINA -OSTOFTHECITIESIN,ATIN!MERICAANDAROUND
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES LIKE !RGENTINA AND "24SYSTEMISTHATITMUSTBEFREEASSOCI THEWORLD DON´THAVEASINGULARPUBLICTRANSPORT &ARE INTEGRATION 4HIS INTEGRATION REFERS
MORERECENTLY#HILE ATEDCOSTSMUSTBEINTEGRATEDTOTHEFAREOR SYSTEM)NFACT INMANYCITIESTHEREISANEXCESS TO THE FACT THAT ALL PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYS
OFPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMSRUNNINGATTHESAME TEMS HAVE THE SAME TICKETING SYSTEM AND
TIME4HE"24REMEDIESAPARTOFTHISEXCESSIVE IFPOSSIBLE HAVETHEPOSSIBILITYOFUSINGALL
SUPPLYOFPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMS BUTITISNOT THE COMPONENTS OF THE TRANSPORT SYSTEM
LOGICAL FOR IT TO COMPLETELY REPLACE THE REST OF WITH ONE ½XED FARE &OR EXAMPLE A TWO
PUBLIC TRANSPORT SYSTEMS NOT EVEN IN THE SHORT HOURJOURNEYFARECANBE½XED REGARDLESS
&IGURE  4RANS-ILENIO IS OR MEDIUM TERM 4HUS THE "24 SYSTEM MUST BE OF THE SPECI½C SYSTEMS USED DURING THOSE
ONEOFTHEFEW"24SYSTEMS GENERATED AS A SYSTEM THAT IS NOT PARALLEL BUT TWO HOURS /NE OF THE MOST COMPLEX MAT
THATPROVIDEANINTEGRATION COMPLEMENTARY TO THE REST OF THE PUBLIC TRANS TERS OF FARE INTEGRATION IS THE DISTRIBUTION
SERVICE WITH THE BICYCLES PORTSYSTEMS4HEMAKINGOFA"24SYSTEMMUST OFTHEFAREAMONGTHEDIFFERENTSUBSYSTEMS
4HEFAREINCLUDESSHELTERED ALSO BE COMPLEMENTED BY IMPROVEMENTS OF THE 4HEOPERATIONCOSTS THECOVERAGEANDTHE
BICYCLE PARKING AREAS WITH OTHERCOMPONENTSOFTHEPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEM REST OF THE ASPECTS OF EACH SYSTEM VARY
AN ADEQUATE SURVEILLANCE INGENERAL ENORMOUSLY AND THE CRITERIA FOR THE FARE
SYSTEM DISTRIBUTIONARENOTASCLEARASTHEYWOULD
4HISMEANSTHATTHEINTEGRATIONWITHOTHERSYS BEWITHINEACHSYSTEM.EVERTHELESS APUB
TEMSRAILORBUSBASEDSYSTEMS ISAHIGHPRIORITY LICTRANSPORTSYSTEMWITHFAREINTEGRATIONIS
ACTIVITYTHATSHOULDBEMADEPARTOFTHEPLANNING CRUCIAL FOR THE PROVISION OF A REAL PUBLIC
OF THE SYSTEM 4HE TWO MOST IMPORTANT ASPECTS TRANSPORTSERVICEINACITY
CONCERNING THE INTEGRATION OF THE SYSTEMS ARE 0HYSICAL INTEGRATION 4HE PHYSICAL INTE
THEFARE ORFARE INTEGRATION ANDTHEPHYSICALIN GRATIONREFERSTOTHEEASEWITHWHICHUSERS
TEGRATION OFASYSTEMIE"24 CANTRANSFERTOOTHER

34 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 35
SYSTEMS IE A METRO  (OWEVER SIMPLE IT !SECONDINTEGRATIONOPTIONISTHEONEUSEDINSOME 4HEUSERCANPAYAPUBLICTRANSPORTFAREPRIORTO
WOULDSEEMTOBE THISREQUIRESTHEDESIG %UROPEAN SYSTEMS WITH GREAT SUCCESS )T HAS BEEN ENTERINGTHEPARKINGAREAANDHAVESOMEKINDOF
NATIONOFSPECI½CSTATIONSFOREACHSYSTEM IMPLEMENTEDINSOMECITIESIN,ATIN!MERICAINAN DISCOUNTOVERTHETOTALPRICEOFTHEPARKINGSERVI
ANDINSOMEOCCASIONSTHECONSTRUCTIONOF INFORMALMANNERTHE±BICYCLETAXIS²4HEADVANTA CE4HISISMEANTTOREDUCETHEAMOUNTOFCARJO
JOINT STATIONS FOR DIFFERENT SYSTEMS .ONE GESOFTHISKINDOFTRANSPORT LIKETHOSEOFBICYCLES URNEYSTOTHECITYCENTRE WHILEALSOREDUCINGEX
THELESS ANDADEQUATEPHYSICALINTEGRATION ARETHATITDOESNOTGENERATEEMISSIONS ANDTAKES TERNALITIESCONCERNINGTHEUSAGEOFTHISVEHICLE
GENERATES MUTUAL BENE½TS FOR THE SYSTEMS UPVERY LITTLE SPACE)TISALSOAGOODEMPLOYMENT
INVOLVED DUE TO JOURNEY COMBINATIONS OF OPTION)NADDITION THEYSUPPLYTHENEEDSOFUSERS
THEIRUSERS!FEWASPECTSTHATMUSTBESTUD WHO USE TAXIS REGULARLY ANDOR HAVE THEIR ARRIVAL
 -ARKETINGAND
IEDBEFOREIMPLEMENTINGAPUBLICTRANSPORT STATIONATARELATIVELYLONG DISTANCEFROMTHEIR½NAL
CUSTOMERSERVICE
SYSTEMARETHEVERTICALDIFFERENCESBETWEEN DESTINATION4HE±BICYCLETAXIS²HAVEALOWERCATCH
STATIONS )F A "24 SYSTEM IS CONSTRUCTED MENTAREATHANREGULARTAXIS SOTHESERVICEWOULD
AND AN ELEVATED METRO IS PLANNED TO BE BESUPPLIEDTOADIFFERENTTARGETGROUP 4HIS SECTION WILL DESCRIBE TWO COMPONENTS OF
BUILTAND±INTEGRATED²WITHTHEPREVIOUS IT THE "24 THAT CONCERN THE MOST IMPORTANT PAR
WILLBEVERYDIF½CULTFOR"24USERSTOMAKE )NFRASTRUCTUREANDLEGALFACILITIESSHOULDBEGENE TICIPANTSTHEUSERS"OTHTHESYSTEM´SMARKETING
TRANSFERSGIVENTHEFACTTHATITWILLBENECES RALLY PROVIDED FOR THE ALLOWANCE OF JOURNEY INTE UNDERSTOOD AS THE DIFFUSION OF ITS CHARACTERIS
SARYTOLEAVETHESTATION WALKUPASTAIRCASE GRATIONSBETWEEN"24SYSTEMSANDTAXISOR±BICYCLE TICSANDTHEPROMOTIONOFITSUSE ANDCUSTOMER &IGURE4HEINTEGRATIONOFA"24SYSTEMWITHTAXISHASNORMALLY
AND ENTER ANOTHER SYSTEM !N EVEN WORSE TAXIS²4HEMAINPROBLEMCONCERNING±BICYCLETAXIS² SERVICEAREWHATWILLINFORMTHEUSEROFWHATTHE BEENCONCEIVEDBYTHETAXIDRIVERSTHEMSELVES BUTITMAYBEAND
SITUATIONISWHENANUNDERGROUNDSYSTEMIS IS THAT VARIOUS POPULATION GROUPS HAVE DEEMED SYSTEM CONSISTS OF AND HOW IT SHOULD BE USED INTEGRALPARTOFTHESYSTEMFROMTHEIROWNPLANNING
±INTEGRATED²WITHANELEVATEDSYSTEM4HESE THEMASDANGEROUSVEHICLES WHICHISANIMPRECISE WHILEMAKINGHIMHERFEELCOMFORTABLEANDWELL
KINDSOFLEVELPROBLEMSDONOTEXISTIN"24 ASSESSMENT ATTENDEDATTHETIMEOFUSE
SYSTEMS ORINOTHERBUSBASEDSYSTEMS
 )NTEGRATIONWITHCARS  -ARKETINGELEMENTS CONSTRUCTEDINTHEIRCITY0RESENTINGREALISTICMO
 )NTEGRATIONWITHTAXISANDBICYCLETAXIS 4HE LAST FORM OF INTEGRATING THE "24 SYSTEM WITH )TCANBEARGUEDTHATA"24SYSTEMTHATISIMPLE DELS OF WHAT HAS BEEN DESIGNED AND HOW IT WILL
%VENTHOUGHTAXISAPPEARASCOMPETITIONTOMASS OTHERTRANSPORTATIONSISWITHCARS%VENTHOUGHTHIS MENTEDWITHOUTAMARKETINGPLANWILLBEAFAILU BEIMPLEMENTEDISPARTICULARLYUSEFUL/NSOME
TRANSITSYSTEMS THEYAREINFACTIMPORTANTALLIES SYSTEMISNOTSUSTAINABLEORRECOMMENDABLEFORA RE%VENINCASESWHERETHESYSTEMISPERFECTLYDE OCCASIONS VIDEOSSHOWINGTHEROUTECOVERAGEOF
OF A "24 SERVICE PROVISION 4HIS IS DUE TO THE CITY ITISAFACTTHATCITIESWILLCONTINUETOHAVECARS SIGNED INCLUDINGALLTHECOMPONENTSDESCRIBED THE"24SYSTEMAREDEVELOPED$ATACONCERNING
FACTTHATINSOMESITUATIONSTHEARRIVALSTATIONOF IN YEARS TO COME AND IT IS IMPORTANT TO CONSIDER PREVIOUSLY SUCHASYSTEMWON´THAVEANYSUCCESS EXPECTEDSAVINGSFORWELLKNOWNROUTES THEDES
A USER IS LOCATED AT A SIGNI½CANT DISTANCE FROM THEIR EXISTENCE AND NOT EXPECT THEM TO DISAPPEAR IFITISN´TACCOMPANIEDBYACOMPLETEANDSENSI CRIPTIONOFBENE½TSTHATAREASSOCIATEDWITHTHE
THEIR ½NAL DESTINATION 7HEN THE POSSIBILITY OF INTHENEARFUTURE)NSTEAD THESOLUTIONCOULDBETO BLE MARKETING PLAN ABOUT HOW TO APPROACH THE PROJECT ECONOMIC SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL
USINGABICYCLETOCOMPLETETHEJOURNEYDOESN´T GENERATETHEINTEGRATIONOFONECARRIDENORMALLY POPULATION)NFACT THELACKOFAMARKETINGPLAN AND THE PRESENTATION OF SUCCESSFUL EXPERIENCES
EXIST TAXISAREAVALIDOPTION3INCEFAREINTEGRA FROMTHEUSER´SHOME TOTHEORIGINSTATIONOFTHE MAYRESULTINCHAOSINTHESYSTEM´SOPERATION IN OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD ARE VERY USEFUL FOR
TION CANNOT BE APPLIED HERE OR AT LEAST THERE JOURNEY 4HIS IS COMMONLY CALLED ±PARK AND RIDE² INFORMINGANDMOTIVATINGTHEPEOPLETOUSETHE
AREN´T ANY FARE INTEGRATION EXPERIENCES BETWEEN ANDITCONSISTSOFTHEPROVISIONOFPARKINGAREASAT &OR THESE REASONS A THOROUGH MARKETING PLAN SERVICE
TAXISANDMASSTRANSPORTSYSTEMS THEUSERSWHO THETERMINALSTATIONSOFA"24SYSTEM4HEREISONLY MUSTBEDESIGNEDTOGETHERWITHTHEOTHERCOMPO
HAVEAWELL ORGANIZEDTAXISYSTEMWHENARRIVING ONEPROBLEMAGREATDEALOFSPACEISNEEDEDFORTHE NENTSOFTHE"24SYSTEM4HISPLANMUSTINCLUDE )T IS PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT TO GENERATE AN IN
ATTHEDESIREDSTATION HAVEABETTERLEVELOFSERVI CARS AT THE PARKING AREA )T IS RECOMMENDED THAT BOTHINFORMATIVEANDPERSUASIVEELEMENTSABOUT FORMATION STRATEGY ABOUT THE WAY IN WHICH THE
CETHANTHOSEWHODON´THAVETHISOPTION!DDI THISSERVICEBEOFCHARGE2EGARDLESS USINGTHISSORT THESYSTEMINASIMPLEWAYTHATWOULDINVITEUSERS SYSTEM WILL WORK ITS ROUTES THEIR CODING THE
TIONALLY THEEXISTENCEOFANADEQUATE"24 TAXIIN OFINTEGRATIONISPOSSIBLEWHENTHETERMINALSTATION TO TRY THE SYSTEM 4HESE TWO COMPONENTS ARE EXISTINGINFORMATIONSYSTEMS THELOCATIONOFTHE
TEGRATIONCANDISCOURAGETHEUSEOFPRIVATECARS ISALSOACOMMERCIALCENTREORSOMETHINGSIMILARTO PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT DURING THE CONSTRUCTION BUSSTOPS ETC)TISAGOODIDEATOIMPLEMENTA
FORSUCHJOURNEYS MAKETHEMPOPULARDESTINATIONPOINTS OF THE SYSTEM BECAUSE CITIZENS WILL HAVE A GREAT WEBSITE THAT INCLUDES ALL THE RELEVANT INFORMA
LEVELOFUNCERTAINTYWITHRESPECTTOWHATWILLBE TIONABOUTTHESYSTEM)TISUSEFULTOEMPHASIZE

36 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 37
THATTHECREATIONANDDIFFUSIONOFALLTHESETOOLS PORATEIMAGE ITSLOGOANDITSSLOGAN4HISMUST
MUST BE DONE "%&/2% THE IMPLEMENTATION OF BE DEVELOPED DURING THE DESIGN OF THE SYSTEM
THESYSTEM4HISMUSTALSOBECOMPLEMENTEDBY AND MUST INCLUDE A CORPORATE IDENTITY MANUAL
PRESENTING PERSONALIZED INFORMATION TO COMPA THATSPECI½ESTHECOLOURSTOBEUSEDONTHEVE
NIES FACTORIES SCHOOLSANDUNIVERSITIESANDANY HICLES THE DRIVER´S DRESS CODE AS WELL AS OTHERS
TYPEOFINSTITUTION THATARELOCATEDNEARTHESTA WHODELIVERASERVICEWITHINTHESYSTEM ANDTHE
TIONSTHATWILLBEIMPLEMENTED4HISNORMALLYIN GENERALWAYTHESYSTEMMUSTBEPRESENTEDTOTHE
CLUDESMEETINGSWHERETHECOMMUNITYISABLETO CITIZENS4HISISGENERALLYDEVELOPEDWITHTHEFEE
ENQUIREABOUTTHESYSTEMANDMAKESUGGESTIONS DBACKFROMFOCUSGROUPSANDSURVEYSSPECI½CALLY
PROPOSALSTHOUGHTHISISUSUALLYDONEDURINGTHE DESIGNEDFORTHISPURPOSE
DEVELOPMENTOFTHEPROJECT´SINITIALCONCEPT 
 #USTOMERSERVICE
!NACTIVITYTHATHASPARTICULARSUCCESSINPROMO #USTOMERSERVICE BESIDESBEINGANELEMENTFOR
TING THE SYSTEM IS GIVING FREE TRAVEL USE DURING IMPROVINGTHEPERFORMANCEOFTHESYSTEM WILLBE
THE ½RST WEEK OF SERVICE "ESIDES INFORMING THE &IGURE!PARK N RIDESYSTEMINATERMINALSTATION ANOTHERWAYTOPROMOTETHE"24SYSTEMFORTHE &IGURE  "ESIDES DEVELOPING AN EXHAUSTIVE INFORMATION CAM
PEOPLEABOUTTHESYSTEM ITALSOMOTIVATESITSUSE OF THE RAIL SYSTEM IN "ANGKOK #OURTESY OF 4HIRAYOOT LONG TERM 4HIS INCLUDES ASPECTS OF THE SERVICE PAIGN THEPROVISIONOFFREESERVICEFORTHE½RSTCOUPLEOFWEEKS
!DDITIONALLY IFTHEPEOPLETAKETOOLONG½NDING ,IMANOND PROVISION INADDITIONTOTHESERVICEASSUCH!N OFANINITIALOPERATIONISONEOFTHESTRATEGIESTHATHAVEBEENIM
THEIR WAY OR GET LOST ON THE WAY TO WORK IT WILL ASPECT DESCRIBED PREVIOUSLY IS INFORMATION FOR PLEMENTEDTOINTRODUCETHESYSTEMANDTOPROMOTEITASABETTER
HAVEBEENCOSTFREE4HISFREETICKETSTRATEGYMAY THEUSER!USERWHOKNOWSWHEREHESHEIS WHO MOBILITYOPTIONINTHECITY
HAVEANELEVATEDCOSTBUTWILLBEOUTWEIGHEDBY HASEASYACCESSTOREACHHISHERDESTINATION AND
THEBENE½TSOFHAVINGUSERSTHATKNOWHOWTOUSE OUTREACHWITHINCOMMUNITIES RATHERTHANUSING WHOHASSIMPLEINFORMATIONABOUTHOWTOREACH
THESYSTEMINAVERYSHORTPERIODOFTIMEAFTERITS MASSMEDIA4ELEVISIONANDRADIOARENOTPARTICU IT WILLBESATIS½EDWITHTHESERVICE)T´SNOTNECES
LAUNCH LARLYUSEFULFORTHEDIFFUSIONOFATRANSPORTSYSTEM SARYTOREPEATWHATISINCLUDEDINTHEINFORMATION
WHENUSEDASCOMMERCIALMEDIA BUTTHEYCANBE TOTHEUSER BUTRATHERTOSTRESSITSIMPORTANCEAS WHATTHEUSERSCANDODURINGEACHJOURNEY4HIS
4HETARGETGROUPOFTHISMARKETINGPLANISALMOST VERYBENE½CIALWHENTHESYSTEMIS±INTHENEWS² ACUSTOMERSERVICETOOL ISWHYINCLUDINGPUBLICSERVICEPAYMENTCENTRES
ENTIRELYCOMPOSEDOFPOTENTIALUSERSOFTHESYS ASTHISWAYITRAISESTHEPUBLIC´SAWARENESS ANDCITYCOUNCILLOCALOF½CESATTHETERMINALSTA
TEM 4HIS MAY BE WIDENED TO THOSE PEOPLE WHO /THER ASPECTS TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT ARE THE TIONS IS AN APPROPRIATE ELEMENT FOR THE SYSTEM
WILLHAVEANINDIRECTRELATIONWITHTHESYSTEMOR /NCE THE SYSTEM HAS BEEN IMPLEMENTED THERE SERVICES THE SYSTEM PROVIDES SUCH AS THE CLEA 0ROVIDING REST ROOMS IN SOME STATIONS IS ARGUA
TOTHOSEWHOWILLEVENTUALLYENDUPUSINGIT%VEN MUSTBEACONSTANTTRACKINGOFTHESEMARKETING NINGOFTHEVEHICLESANDSTATIONS THEPUNCTUAL BLE BUT RECOMMENDED IN MOST CASES 0ROVIDING
THOUGH CHILDREN WILL NOT USE THE SYSTEM IN THE ACTIVITIES !DDITIONALLY OPINION POLLS MUST BE ITYOFTHESERVICES ANDTHEGENERALCONDITIONSOF ADDITIONALANDUNXEPECTEDSERVICESLIKELENDING
IMMEDIATEFUTURE THEYDOWORKASAPOPULATION DONETOKNOWTHEPOSITIVEANDNEGATIVEASPECTS SERVICEPROVISIONTHATAREDIRECTLYRELATEDTOTHE BOOKS ARTATTHESTATIONS FESTIVALS CONCERTSAND
THATWILLTRANSFERTHEINFORMATIONTOOTHERSWHO THE USERS PERCEIVE REGARDING THE SYSTEM IN OR USERS´SATISFACTION)NORDERTOFUL½LANADEQUATE SUCH WILLALSOADDPOSITIVEPOINTSTOTHESERVICE
COULD THEN USE THE SERVICE THEIR PARENTS RELA DER TO IMPROVE ITS PERFORMANCE AND DISSEMINA SERVICE PROVISION IT IS ALSO NECESSARY TO SPECIFY PROVISION
TIVES FRIENDS ETC  4HEREFORE THE INFORMATION TETHEMOSTADEQUATEINFORMATION#ARRYINGOUT HOWTHISWILLBEACCOMPLISHED ANDHAVEITCLEARLY
MUST BE DESIGNED PREDOMINANTLY FAVOURING THE ADDITIONALMARKETINGACTIVITIESISSOMETHINGTHAT DESCRIBEDINTHEEXISTINGCONTRACTSWITHTHEOP /NE ASPECT THAT WAS BRIE¾Y MENTIONED IN THE
PEOPLEWHOWILLMOSTLIKELYUSETHESYSTEM WHILE MUSTBEDONECONTINUOUSLYINORDERTOKEEPTHE ERATORS &OR INSTANCE THE FREQUENCY OF WASHING OPERATIONAL SECTION WAS THE COMFORT OF THE
NOT DISREGARDING OTHER PARTS OF THE POPULATION SYSTEM´S IMAGE AS POSITIVE EF½CIENT FAST AND ALL THEVEHICLESMUSTBEESTABLISHEDINTHECONTRACT SYSTEM!SITWASEXPLAINED THE"24SYSTEMMUST
/NTHEOTHERHAND ALONG TERMMARKETINGPLAN OTHER CHARACTERISTICS THAT HAVE BEEN PROMOTED ALONGWITHTHEOTHERRELATEDASPECTS BEPLANNEDINAWAYTHATMAKESITBOTHPRO½TABLE
COULDINCLUDETHOSEPEOPLEWHOWOULDEVENTUA SINCETHEBEGINNING AND SELF SUSTAINABLE IN OTHER WORDS SO THAT IT
LLYUSETHESYSTEMLIKECARUSERS !NIMPORTANT $ELIVERING ADDITIONAL SERVICES IS FUNDAMENTAL DOESN´TNEEDOPERATINGSUBSIDIES .EVERTHELESS
ASPECTOFMARKETINGTHESYSTEMISTHATSTRATEGIES 4HESUBJECTOFIMAGEALSORELATESTOTHESPECI½C AND CONVEYS A MORE POSITIVE IMAGE OF THE SYS THE PLANNING OF A VERY PRO½TABLE SYSTEM MAY
TOBEUSEDMUST PREDOMINANTLYBECOMPOSEDOF VISUALCOMPONENTSOFTHESYSTEMTHATISITSCOR TEM )T ALSO CREATES MORE EF½CIENCY IN TERMS OF GENERATE DISCOMFORT FOR THE USERS AS MOST OF

38 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 39
&IGURE4HECUSTOMERSERVICEIS½
NALLYONEOFTHESERVICESTHATGUARAN
TEETHESUSTAINABILITYOFA"24SYSTEM
INTHELONGTERM!FTERALL THEPROVI
SIONOFASERVICEORIENTEDTOWARDSTHE
USERS´SATISFACTIONISWHATENSURESTHE
PERMANENCEOFTHESYSTEM

THATPRO½TABILITYWILLBERE¾ECTEDUPONAMINOR 4HE ELEMENTS DESCRIBED PREVIOUSLY GIVE A GOOD


FREQUENCYOFVEHICLESANDALARGERAGGLOMERATION IDEA OF THE BASIC COMPONENTS OF A "24 SYSTEM
OF PEOPLE AT THE STATIONS AND IN THE BUSES )N !SITWASDESCRIBEDATTHESTARTOFTHISCHAPTER A &IGURE4HEREAREOTHEREXISTINGSERVICESADDITIONAL
MANY CASES THIS DRAWBACK IS OVERLOOKED WITH COMPLETE "24 SYSTEM HAS ALL THESE COMPONENTS TOTHETRANSPORTSERVICESUCHASBOOKLENDINGATTHE
THE ARGUMENT THAT THE SYSTEM IS FAST &OR THIS DEVELOPEDINDETAIL3OMEOTHER"24SYSTEMSHAVE STATIONS 4HIS SERVICE GIVES THE USER AN IMAGE OF THE
REASONTHEUSERS±UNDERSTAND²THESERVICEISNOT ONLYDEDICATEDLANES STATIONS VEHICLES BUSINESS SERVICETHATGOESBEYONDITSMOSTFUNCTIONALASPECT
COMFORTABLEBUTEF½CIENT ANDGIVEGREATERVALUE STRUCTUREANDANADEQUATEOPERATIONALPLANTHEY
TO THIS EF½CIENCY THAN TO COMFORT %VEN THOUGH LACKADDITIONALELEMENTS BUTTHESERVICEISGOOD
THISCANBETRUEFORSOMEUSERSWHOSEJOURNEYSIN ENOUGH TO SUPPLY EXISTING NEEDS 4HE MOST IM
THESYSTEMAREALMOSTMANDATORYIELOWINCOME PORTANTASPECTOFA"24SYSTEMISTHATITPROVIDES
USERSWHOMUSTTRAVELTOWORKINTHE"24 ITISNOT ANADEQUATEPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMTHATATTRACTS
AGOODSERVICESTRATEGYFORTHERESTOFTHEUSERS THE LARGEST NUMBER OF POSSIBLE USERS AND OFFERS
INTHELONGTERM)FASYSTEMPROVIDESAFASTAND THEPOSSIBILITYOFGREATERACCESSTOWORK SCHOOLS
UNCOMFORTABLE SERVICE MANY USERS WILL LOOK AT UNIVERSITIES GOODSANDSERVICES ASWELLASPROPER
ALTERNATIVEOPTIONS SUCHASBUYINGAMOTORCYCLE CONDITIONS AND AFFORDABLE FARES ! "24 SYSTEM
IN ORDER TO HAVE FAST MOBILITY COMFORT AND THATMANAGESTOPROVIDETHISISASUCCESSFUL"24
FREEDOM )N THE LONG TERM THIS ONLY GENERATES SYSTEMANDWILLGUARANTEEITSSUCCESSOVERTIME
GREATERINDIVIDUALANDMOTORIZEDMOBILITY HIGHER
ACCIDENTRATES ANDALOWPRO½TPUBLICTRANSPORT
SYSTEM

40 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 41
 )MPLEMENTATIONOFA"243YSTEM

!SDESCRIBEDPREVIOUSLY THEIMPLEMENTATIONOFA THESEAF½RMATIONS IT´SBEENSEENTHATTHESEDECI "24 SYSTEM WITH A POLITICAL PARTY %VEN THOUGH PONSIBILITYOFTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHESYSTEMAND
"24SYSTEMIMPLIESAMETICULOUSPLANNINGOFALL SIONMAKERSHAVEIMPROVEDTHEPUBLICTRANSPORT THISCOULDSEEMPOSITIVEINTHESHORT TERM ITMAY THE TRACKING OF THE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 4HEY
THE DETAILS THAT WILL COMPRISE IT 4HIS PLANNING SITUATION IN THEIR CITIES 4HEY HAVE ALSO OPENED HAVENEGATIVECONSEQUENCESINTHELONG TERM ES WILLALSOBEINCHARGEOFDE½NINGTHETERMSOFRE
MUSTBEDIRECTEDBYATEAMANDLEDBYADECISION THEDOORSTO IMPROVING THELIVINGCONDITIONSTO PECIALLYFORACITY FERENCEFORTHEDIFFERENTCOMPONENTSINTHESYS
MAKERGENERALLYAMAYORORGOVERNOR ANDMUST THEIRCITIZENS TEM CONTRACTINGDIVERSESTUDIESTOBEMADE AND
THEREFOREHAVEGOALSANDANADEQUATETIMETABLE )N SOME CASES THERE EXISTS A WELL DESIGNED AND INSOMECASESDIRECTINGTHEMANAGEMENTOFTHE
4HE FOLLOWINGIS A SCHEME OF WHAT IS NEEDED TO !NADDITIONALCOMPONENTTHATHASPROVENTOBE CONCEIVED"24PROJECT WITHOUTANYPOLITICALWILL SYSTEM7ITHALLTHESERESPONSIBILITIES ITISCLEAR
MAKEA"24SYSTEMAREALITY USEFULINTHECREATIONOFA"24SYSTEMISTHEVISION 4OCHANGETHEPOINTOFVIEWOFAPOLITICIANAND THAT THIS TEAM CANNOT BE COMPOSED OF PEOPLE
THATTHESEGOVERNORSHAVEHADWHENDEVELOPING DEMONSTRATE THE BENE½TS THAT COME WITH THE WHOAREINCHARGEOFOTHERRESPONSIBILITIESINTHIS
THESESYSTEMS4HE"24HASNOTBEENCONCEIVEDAS DEVELOPMENTOFATRANSPORTSYSTEMLIKETHE"24 PARTICULARPROJECT4HETEAMMUSTBECOMPLETELY
APAIROFLANESTOBEIMPLEMENTEDINASHORTTERM SOME STRATEGIES HAVE BEEN USED SUCH AS TAKING ANDEXCLUSIVELYDEDICATEDTOTHE"24SYSTEM
 0OLITICAL7ILL
2ATHER ITHASBEENCONCEIVEDASASYSTEMTHATIS THEMTOVISITA"24SYSTEMINASIMILARCITY
IMPLEMENTED IN PHASES THAT COMPLEMENT EACH 4HISTEAMNORMALLYPRESENTSPERIODICREPORTSTO
! FUNDAMENTAL ELEMENT FOR THE MAKING OF A OTHERDURINGTHEFOLLOWINGDECADESFORTHECREA /NCETHEREISPOLITICALWILLANDACONCEPTUALDE THEMAYORANDTOOTHERGOVERNMENTENTITIES4HIS
"24SYSTEMISTHATTHEREEXISTSREALPOLITICALWILL TIONOFANEVENTUALMASSTRANSPORTATIONNETWORK SIGN OF THE SYSTEM THE CITY CAN THEN START WITH COMMUNICATIONWITHTHEGOVERNMENTALBODIESIS
TOWARDS SYSTEM IMPLEMENTATION %VEN THOUGH A WHEREMOSTOFTHEPOPULATIONWILLHAVEACCESSTO AN IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AS THE ONE BRIE¾Y DES PARTICULARLYUSEFUL ASTHESEPROJECTSTENDTOHAVE
WELLPLANNEDANDDETAILED"24SYSTEMEXISTS THE THE SYSTEM 4HESE SYSTEMS HAVE BEEN PRESENTED CRIBEDBELOW ELEVATEDCOSTSANDCANCONSTITUTEAFUNDAMENTAL
LACKOFPOLITICALWILLMAYRESULTINPOSTPONINGTHE ASPARTOFAGREATERTRANSFORMATIONOFACITYTHAT COMPONENTINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFACITY&ORTHIS
ACTUALCONSTRUCTIONOFTHESYSTEM INCLUDESPUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMIMPROVEMENTS REASON THEMEDIASHOULDALSOKNOWSOMEASPECTS
THE DEVELOPMENT OF HIGH QUALITY PUBLIC SPACES RELATINGTOTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHEPROJECT
 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATION
4HE MOST SUCCESSFUL "24 SYSTEMS IN THE WORLD AND GENERAL POLICIES OF GREATER HABITABILITY AND
MANYOFWHICHAREIN,ATIN!MERICA HAVEBECO LONG TERMSUSTAINABILITY 4HE PROJECT TEAM MUST ALSO DEVELOP A SPECI½C
MEAREALITYTHANKSTOTHECOMMITMENTOFVISIO 4HE PLANNING OF A "24 SYSTEM IMPLIES VARIOUS TIMEFRAME FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF EACH COMPO
NARYMAYORSWHOHAVESEENTHESYSTEMASAREAL 0OLITICAL WILL IS AN INDISPENSABLE COMPONENT IN ADDITIONAL COMPONENTS TO THOSE THAT WERE DES NENT ANDBASEDONTHISTIMELINE THEYMUSTPRE
SOLUTION TO THE GROWING CONGESTION POLLUTION THECREATIONOFAHIGHCAPACITYPUBLICTRANSPORT CRIBEDINTHESECONDCHAPTEROFTHISDOCUMENT SENTALLPROGRESS%STABLISHINGAREALISTICTIMELINE
ANDINEQUALITYPROBLEMSCAUSEDBYNON EF½CIENT SYSTEM SUCH AS "24 4HIS POLITICAL WILL IMPLIES 4HESEINCLUDE½NANCIAL STAFF MAINTENANCEAND IS VERY IMPORTANT AS ALL MANAGERIAL EVALUATIONS
TRANSPORT SYSTEMS 4HEY HAVE ALSO SEEN THAT A COMMITMENT TO DEVELOPING THE SYSTEM AND A EVALUATIONASPECTSTHATAREDESCRIBEDINTHEFO OFTHEGROUPWILLBEBASEDONTHIS½RSTTIMELINE
AMONGTHEOPTIONSTHEYHAD THE"24SYSTEMWAS LONG TERM VISION 4HIS IS COMPLEMENTED WHEN LLOWINGSECTION !NOPTIMISTICTIMELINEMIGHTLOOKVERYPOSITIVEAT
MOSTSUITABLETOTHEIRNEEDS4HEYHAVEMANAGED THEDEVELOPMENTOFTHEPROJECTISCONTINUEDAND THEBEGINNING BUTASTIMEGOESBYITWILLBEBOTH
TO OVERCOME ALL THE OBSTACLES THAT WERE IN THE COMPLETED BY THE SUCCEEDING GOVERNORS OF THE  0ROJECTTEAMANDTIMELINE ANEGATIVEANDUNBEARABLEBARRIERTHATMUSTBE
WAYWHENTHEYCOMMITTEDTODESIGNINGANDIM CITY)NPUBLICTRANSPORTPROJECTS WHICHNORMA $ESPITE THE VARIOUS TEAMS DEDICATED TO THE DE AVOIDEDFROMTHESTART
PLEMENTINGTHESYSTEM4OSOME THISMAYSEEM LLYHAVEALONG LASTING IMPLEMENTATIONPHASE OF VELOPMENT OF SPECI½C COMPONENTS THE DEVELO
LIKE PART OF THE POLITICAL AGENDA OF A MAYOR IN MORE THAN A MAYOR´S PERIOD OF GOVERNING IT IS PMENT OF A "24 SYSTEM MUST INCLUDE A SPECI½C  3YSTEM½NANCING
OTHER WORDS TO SEEK AN EVENTUAL RE ELECTION OR CRUCIAL TO HAVE THE POLITICAL WILL TO ENABLE THE TEAM OF PROFESSIONALS WITH EXPERIENCE IN BOTH "EFOREDE½NINGTHESPECI½CASPECTSCONCERNING
ELECTIONFORAMOREIMPORTANTPOSITION ORTHAT CONTINUITYOFTHESEKINDSOFPROJECTS&ORTHIS IT PROJECT MANAGEMENT AND IN TECHNICAL TRANSPOR THE SUSTAINABILITY OF THE SYSTEM OPERATIONS WE
IT HAS BEEN DONE TO INCREASE THEIR EGO $ESPITE ISALSONECESSARYTOAVOIDANYASSOCIATIONOFTHE TATIONPLANNING4HISTEAMWILLHAVETHEMAINRES MUST DE½NE THE WAY TO ½NANCE PROJECT IMPLE

42 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 43
MENTATION4HELEASTPROBLEMATICWAYSTO½NANCE 4HEREAREALSOEXTERNALSOURCESFORPUBLIC½NAN  #ONTRACTING MUST BE INCLUDED IN THE CONTRACT ESTABLISHED
THESYSTEMAREWITHEXISTINGLOCALANDSTATEGOVER CINGANDEXTERNALLOANS WHICHNORMALLYINCLUDE 4HESYSTEM´SCONTRACTINGPLANMUSTBEDESIGNED WITH THE CONTRACTORS 4HE USEFUL LIFE OF THE IN
NMENTAL RESOURCES )N SOME INSTANCES THERE ARE ACHARGEFORTHEUSEOFTHEROADSNORMALLYCALLED INTHEMOSTEQUITABLEMANNERPOSSIBLEANDWITH FRASTRUCTUREMUSTBEDETERMINEDHERE ASWELLAS
SPECI½CITEMSFORTHEDEVELOPMENTOFMASSORPU CONGESTIONCHARGING ORFUELSURCHARGE PRIMARILY THE GREATEST NUMBER OF EXISTING GUARANTEES )N THE GUARANTEE OF THE CONDITIONS AND DURABILITY
BLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMS ALTHOUGHTHISISNOTALWAYS DIRECTEDATPRIVATECARS$ESPITETHELACKOFPOPU GENERAL IT IS MORE USEFUL TO PRACTICE A COMPE OF THE CORRIDORS STATIONS DEPOTS AND OTHER IN
THECASEFOREVERYCITY INWHICHCASEFUNDSMUST LARITYFORTHESEMEASURES THEYAREVERYEFFECTIVE TITIVE BIDDING EXERCISE TO AWARD THE OPERATION FRASTRUCTURETHATARETOBECONSTRUCTED/NSOME
BEREQUESTED4HEARGUMENTSPRESENTEDINTHE½RST FORREDUCINGCONGESTIONANDINCREASINGTHEUSE OF DIFFERENT COMPONENTS OF THE SYSTEM 4HIS IS OCCASIONS CONTRACT CLAUSES ARE INCLUDED WHERE
CHAPTEROFTHISDOCUMENTCANWORKASAGUIDEFOR OF PUBLIC MODES OF TRANSPORTATION WHILE GENE MORE TRANSPARENT AND HAS BETTER RESULTS THAN THE DRIVER COMMITS TO REPAIRING INFRASTRUCTURE
THISPROCESS/NEISSUECONCERNINGTHETRADITIONAL RATINGRESOURCESFORPUBLICTRANSPORT4HESEARE THETRADITIONALCONTRACTASSIGNINGPROCEDUREFOR DAMAGES DURING THE USEFUL LIFE THAT THEY HAVE
TRANSPORTBUDGETSISTHATEXCESSIVEAMOUNTSOFTHE ALSOMEASURESTHATGENERATEEQUITYBETWEENUSERS SPECI½CORGANIZATIONS!DDITIONALLY THISENABLES COMMITTEDTO
BUDGET ARE POSTED FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF ROADS OF PUBLIC AND PRIVATE TRANSPORT /THER INSTRU REAL COMPETITION IN THE MARKET AND EVENTUALLY
FORAUTOMOBILEUSE/NCETHEBENE½TFROMTHESE MENTSTHATRESIDEOUTOFTHETRANSPORTSECTORARE REDUCES THE SYSTEMS OPERATION COSTS BY GENERA 4HE ISSUE OF MAINTENANCE MUST ALSO BE STUDIED
PROJECTSHASBEENCALCULATEDINTERMSOFJOURNEYS THE PUBLICITY IN STATIONS AND VEHICLES AND THE TINGCOMPETITION3OMEBIDDERSMAYOBTAINMORE THOROUGHLY)NSOMECASESTHECONSTRUCTIONCON
AND COMPARED TO THE BENE½TS OF A PUBLIC TRANS INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT OF STATIONS SOMETHING POINTSTOADDTOTHEIRRECORDSFORHAVINGAPUBLIC TRACT MAY INCLUDE THE INFRASTRUCTURE MAINTE
PORTSYSTEMWITHASMALLINVESTMENT THEREDIREC DESCRIBEDINDETAILPREVIOUSLY 4HESEADDITIONAL TRANSPORT OPERATION HISTORY OR FOR BEING LOCAL NANCEFORTHE½RSTYEARAFTERTHELIFECYCLEOFTHE
TINGOFFUNDSFORTHECREATIONOFTHESESYSTEMSMAY MEASURESCANSUBSTANTIALLYREDUCETHECOSTSOFA OPERATORSRATHERTHANINTERNATIONALONES4HISIS INFRASTRUCTURE IS COMPLETED 4HIS CAN BE LESS OF
BEGIN SYSTEMINBOTHITSIMPLEMENTATIONANDINITSPER INTHEINTERESTOFGIVINGMOREJUSTICEINTHEPRO A PROBLEM IN TERMS OF CONTRACTS 4HE MOST IM
MANENTOPERATION CESSOFTRANSFORMINGTHETRANSPORTSYSTEM PORTANTTOPICINRELATIONTOTHEMAINTENANCEOF
3TATERESOURCESOFTHENATIONALGOVERNMENT WILL THISINFRASTRUCTUREISTHEPERMANENTASSIGNMENT
BEANIMPORTANTPARTOFTHESYSTEM´S½NANCE BUT ! SERIOUS ½NANCIAL PLAN FOR THE SYSTEM MUST BE 4HE CONTRACTS ARE GENERALLY VERY DETAILED WITH OF RESOURCES FOR THIS ACTIVITY SOMETHING THAT IS
THE INTERNAL SOURCES OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS DONE TO ESTIMATE THE COSTS AND POSSIBLE OVER RESPECT TO THE ACTIVITIES AND OPERATION CONDI OFTENFORGOTTEN
WILLALSOPLAYANIMPORTANTROLEINALLOFTHIS/NE HEADS OF THE "24 "ASED ON INTERNATIONAL EX TIONSEXPECTED ANDTHEYHAVEASIMILARDURATION
ARGUMENTTHATCANBEUSEDISTHEPOINTTHATLAND PERIENCESOFOTHER"24SYSTEMS ITISPOSSIBLETO TO THAT OF THE VEHICLES ON AVERAGE  YEARS OR 4HISALSOIMPLIESTHEISSUEOFAPOSSIBLERECONS
VALUESOFPLACESADJACENTTOTHESYSTEMWILLINCREA ESTIMATESOMEREALISTICCOSTSFORTHEPROJECT4HE  KILOMETRES 4HISENABLESTHEPOSSIBILITY TRUCTIONOFTHEINFRASTRUCTUREANDMUSTTHEREFORE
SE WHICHCANBESEENASANOPPORTUNITYTORECOVER CONSULTANTS WHO DEVELOP THE SYSTEM´S CONCEPT OFPROVIDINGAHIGHLYPROFESSIONALSERVICE GIVEN BEPLANNEDFROMTHESTARTOFTHE"24SYSTEM
THE INVESTMENT THROUGH ADDED VALUE LEGISLATIONS MUSTPRESENTAREALISTICESTIMATIONOFTHECOSTS THEDURATIONOFTHECONTRACTS ANDAVOIDSTHERISK
ORSIMILARECONOMICINSTRUMENTS4HISBENE½TMAY )TISRECOMMENDABLETOCOMPARETHESECOSTSWITH OFCONTRACTSWITHLONGERDURATIONTHATHAVEFEWER  3YSTEMEVALUATIONANDIMPACT
ALSOBEUSEDTOGETTHEAPPROVALOFABUDGETFORA THOSEOFOTHERSYSTEMSALREADYIMPLEMENTED QUALITYGUARANTEES 4HE"24SYSTEMWILLHAVESIGNI½CANTIMPACTSON
PUBLICTRANSPORTSYSTEMSUCHASTHE"24 THEPOPULATION4HISWILLBECLEARLYEVIDENTTOTHE
4HIS½NANCIALPLANTYPICALLYINCLUDESTHEDEVELO  #ONSTRUCTIONANDMAINTENANCE USERS ANDTOACERTAINPOINT THEGENERALPUBLIC
2EGARDLESS IFLOCALANDNATIONAL½NANCINGSOURCES PMENTOFDETAILEDSTUDIESFORTHEIMPLEMENTATION 4HECONSTRUCTIONOFTHESYSTEM´SINFRASTRUCTUREIS #ONSEQUENTLY ITISESSENTIALTOSETUPANEVALUA
ARENOTSUF½CIENTTOCOVERTHECAPITALCOSTSOFTHE OFTHESYSTEMANDTHECONSTRUCTIONANDMAINTE THEMOSTVISIBLEPARTOFTHE"24BEFOREITSIMPLE TIONPLANTOMONITORTHESYSTEMANDDEMONSTRATE
PROJECT THENITISNECESSARYTOSEEKEXTERNAL½NAN NANCE COSTS OF THE SYSTEM´S INFRASTRUCTURE )N A MENTATION4HEREFORE MUCHATTENTIONISNEEDED ITSPERFORMANCEWITHSPECI½C½GURESINORDERTO
CINGSOURCES FEWCASESTHEPROCUREMENTOFVEHICLESORTHEFARE INITSPLANNING4HECONSTRUCTIONCONTRACTSMUST CORRECTANYPROBLEMS
COLLECTIONEQUIPMENTAREINCLUDED)TISPREFERA BEEQUALLYSPECI½CTOTHEONESESTABLISHEDWITH
4HESEINCLUDECOOPERATIONAGENCIESSUCHASDEVE BLEWHENTHEOPERATORSARERESPONSIBLEFORTHOSE THEOPERATORS ANDTHECONTRACTINGPROCESSWITH 4ODOTHIS ITISNECESSARYTOTAKEMEASURESFROM
LOPMENT BANKS INCLUDING INTERNATIONAL BANKING PURCHASES AND THE MANAGERIAL BODY DETERMINES THEINFRASTRUCTURECONTRACTORSMUSTBEANEQUALLY THE BEGINNING )N OTHER WORDS MEASURES MUST
4HECONDITIONSUNDERWHICHTHESELOANSAREMADE THE SPECI½C CHARACTERISTICS OF THE VEHICLES 4HIS TRANSPARENTPROCESSDONETHROUGHACOMPETITIVE BE TAKEN BEFORE THE START OF ANY CONSTRUCTION
IS AN ASPECT THAT MUST BE WELL STUDIED AS THESE WAY THEOPERATORSCANNEGOTIATEBETTERPRICESFOR BIDDINGSYSTEM ACTIVITY OR DETOURS IN THE LOCATIONS WHERE THE
DEBTSAREREGULARLYEXTENDEDINTOTHEFUTURE AND THEVEHICLES ANDTHISWILLPREVENTANYMISUNDERS SYSTEM WILL BE IMPLEMENTED 4HIS WILL MAKE THE
AVOIDINGLONGTERMDEBTSISSOMETHINGTHATMUST TANDINGSCONCERNINGTHEMAINTENANCEOFTHEVE 4OBEABLETOGUARANTEEHIGHQUALITYINTHECONS DEMONSTRATIONOFSPECI½CBENE½TSASACAUSEOF
BEDONE HICLESOROFSUPPORTEQUIPMENT TRUCTION OF THE INFRASTRUCTURE QUALITY CLAUSES THEIMPLEMENTATIONOFA"24SYSTEMEASIER3OME

44 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 45
OF THESE INDICATORS INCLUDE TRAVEL TIME OF USERS  !DDITIONAL2ESOURCES
PERCEIVED AND REAL POLLUTION LEVELS INSIDE THE
SYSTEM´SCORRIDORS ACCIDENTSTHROUGHOUTTHESYS
TEMBOTHFATALANDNON FATAL THEAVERAGESPEED
OFTHEVEHICLESONTHESYSTEM´SLANESFORPUBLIC
ANDPRIVATE TRANSPORT THENUMBEROFJOURNEYS !S EXPLAINED AT THE BEGINNING THIS GUIDE DOES (IDALGO $ #USTODIO 0 'RAFTIEAUX 0 !
THEPOPULATION´SPERCEPTIONOFTHEPUBLICTRANS NOTHAVEANEXHAUSTIVEDESCRIPTIONOFEACHCOM #RITICAL ,OOK AT -AJOR "US )MPROVEMENTS
PORT ANDMANYOTHERINDICATORSTHATCANGIVEA PONENT IN A "24 SYSTEM FOR TWO MAIN REASONS IN ,ATIN !MERICA AND !SIA #ASE 3TUD
GENERALVISIONOFACITY´SPUBLICTRANSPORTSITUA ½RST THATISNOTTHEINTENTIONOFTHISDOCUMENT IES OF (ITCHES (IC 5PS AND !REAS FOR )M
TIONBEFORETHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFA"24SYSTEM ANDSECOND BECAUSETHEREAREALREADYMANYEXIS PROVEMENT 3YNTHESIS OF ,ESSONS ,EARNED
)TISALSOINTERESTINGTOMEASURETHESEDURINGTHE TINGDOCUMENTSTHATHAVEDESCRIBEDINDETAILTHE !VAILABLE AT WWWEMBARQWRIORGDOCU
CONSTRUCTIONPHASEOFTHESYSTEM IMPLEMENTATIONOFA"24SYSTEM MENTUPLOAD(IDALGO?44"24
IN#ITIESPDF
/NCE THE SYSTEM HAS BEEN IMPLEMENTED AND IS 4HEMOSTRELEVANTONESARETHEFOLLOWING
INUSE ITISNECESSARYTOMAINTAINSYSTEMPERFOR $ATABASEABOUTTHE"US2APID4RANSIT3YS
MANCE-EASURESMAYBEUSEDFORCOMPARINGTHE TEMS "REAKTHROUGH4ECHNOLOGIES)NSTITUTE
SYSTEMWITHVALUESPRIORTOTHEIMPLEMENTATION "US 2APID 4RANSIT 0LANNING 'UIDE WRIT "4) 4HEWEBPAGEISWWWGOBRTORG
AND FOR TRACKING THE QUALITY OF THE SERVICE PRO TENBY,LOYD7RIGHTAND7ALTER(OOK4HIS
VIDED !S THE "24 SYSTEM WILL BE MORE COMPLEX DOCUMENTISPAGESLONG)TISAVAILABLE
ANDCOMPLETETHANTHEPREVIOUSONES ITWILLBE ATWWWSUTPORG WWWITDPORGFOR%NGLISH
POSSIBLE TO COMPILE MUCH MORE DATA ABOUT THE VERSION DOWNLOADSTHOUGHA3PANISHVER
DYNAMICS OF JOURNEYS AND THE OPERATION OF THE SIONWILLBEPUBLISHEDINMID 
SYSTEM
4#20¯2EPORT"US2APID4RANSIT 6OL
UME#ASESTUDIESIN"US2APID4RANSIT
!VAILABLEATHTTPWWWTRBORG

4#20¯2EPORT"US2APID4RANSIT 6OL
UME  )MPLEMENTATION 'UIDELINES !VAIL
ABLEATHTTPWWWTRBORG

4#20¯2EPORT"US2APID4RANSIT0RAC
TITIONER´S'UIDE!VAILABLEATHTTP
WWWTRBORG

*OURNALOF0UBLIC4RANSPORTATION6OLUME
./3PECIAL%DITION"24

46 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA 47
48 0LANNINGAND)MPLEMENTATIONOFA"US2APID4RANSIT3YSTEMIN,ATIN!MERICA

You might also like