You are on page 1of 6

Monetary Policy Monitor TD Economics

www.td.com/economics

April 8, 2011

HIGHLIGHTS BANK OF CANADA TO BIDE ITS TIME


• The Bank of Canada will keep its TILL SUMMERTIME
policy interest rate unchanged
Many central banks the world over are torn between the need to nurture still-
at 1.00% next week and will
strike a cautiously optimistic
fragile economic recoveries and the fear of falling behind the curve to contain grow-
tone in the accompanying com- ing inflationary pressure. Not so for the Bank of Canada who is facing the enviable
muniqué. combination of robust economic growth and remarkably benign inflation. While
the steady absorption of spare capacity will eventually necessitate the withdrawal of
• The release of the April MPR will
monetary stimulus, there is no urgency to act next week. As a result, the overnight
contrast a more robust outlook
rate will almost certainly be left unchanged at 1.00% on Tuesday. Meanwhile,
for economic growth with a be-
both the communiqué accompanying the decision and the Monetary Policy Report
nign backdrop for inflation. We
expect the steady absorption of (MPR) released the following day are expected to balance cautious optimism with
spare capacity will prompt the a laundry list of pre-
Bank to move next in July and dominantly downside The Bank of Canada: How We See It
take the overnight rate to 2.00% risks littering the road Inflation
by the end of 2011. ahead. Current Outlook
In contrast to the Hike Now

recent behaviour of
the market—which Event Risk USDCAD
had priced out hikes
until well into the sec-
ond half of the year April

following the tragedy May


in Japan and the rise July
of geopolitical ten- September US Economic
Financial Stability
sions in the Middle Growth
East and North Af- Each web corresponds to a Fixed Announcement Date where each variable
implies how many meeting dates away the variable is from a tightening in
rica—the tone taken policy. A move towards the origin corresponds to an earlier hike.
by the Bank next week
will likely solidify ex-
pectations for an earlier move. However, the Bank is not expected to be sufficiently
hawkish to set the stage for an increase in the overnight rate in May. Instead, we
reiterate our long-standing call for the next rate hike to occur in July and for a
year-end target of 2.00%.
Growth Outlook Premised on Putting America to Work
In the communiqué accompanying the March Fixed Announcement Date (FAD),
the Bank acknowledged that the recovery in Canada was proceeding faster than
they had forecast in the January MPR. The Bank also cited more evidence of a
rebalancing in the drivers of economic growth away from domestic demand and
David Tulk towards net exports. These are encouraging developments, and they confirm our
Chief Canada Macro Strategist suspicion that the forecast presented in the January MPR was too conservative in
TD Securities its estimation of the impact that the fiscal stimulus in the United States announced
416-983-0445 last December would have on the Canadian economy. Real GDP growth in 2010Q4
outstripped the Bank’s forecast by a full percentage point and the first quarter of
2011 is shaping up to do the same. Renewed strength in exports is a major con-
tributor to both quarters.
Monetary Policy Monitor TD Economics
April 8, 2011 2
www.td.com/economics

provided by rising commodity prices, domestic demand may


Canadian Real GDP Forecast (Annualized Percent Change)
not moderate as quickly as the Bank had initially thought.
Q1-11 Q2-11 Q3-11 Q4-11 2011 2012 Weaving together these various threads reveals a stron-
ger outlook for Canadian growth than what the Bank had
TD 3.8 3.2 2.8 2.6 3.0 2.5 presented in the January MPR. While we expect a sizable
upwards revision to the near-term outlook for real GDP
BoC 2.5 2.8 3.0 3.0 2.4 2.8
growth, it remains an open question of how much activity
Consensus 3.3 3.1 3.0 2.9 3.0 2.9
will be pulled forward from the future. If forecasted growth
in 2012 remains in the ballpark of the 2.8% forecast in Janu-
Source: Bloomberg, Bank of Canada, TD Economics
ary, the Bank is far more likely to embark on a sustained
Looking out over the balance of the year, the key to a sequence of rate hikes, which in our view, will begin in July.
sustainable contribution from Canada’s export sector is a Caveats to Growth are Both Transient and Persistent
recovery in the US labour market. Recall that at the March There are two important caveats to the growth outlook.
FAD (where US activity was described as “solidifying” but The first is the disruption to the global supply chain caused
still supported by stimulus) the labour market had recently by the earthquake in Japan. The trading relationship between
disappointed the market by creating just 36K jobs in Janu- the two countries is relatively small (Canadian exports and
ary while revealing a depressing set of benchmark revi- imports to and from Japan represent 2.3% and 2.5% of their
sions. Since that time, the labour market appears to have respective totals) and firms will have the ability to meet
finally turned a corner, stringing together several months of demand over the very short run by drawing down existing
respectable job gains. With corporate profits auguring for inventories. It is very difficult to predict exactly how long
an accelerated pace of hiring, the Bank is likely to have a the supply disruption will last and already a shortage of
greater confidence that the wider economic recovery will parts primarily in the auto industry have caused factories in
be sustained in 2012. Canada to scale back production. It is expected that once
The rebalancing in the drivers of Canadian economic the electricity and transportation infrastructure in Japan is
growth also implies a slower pace of domestic demand, restored, exports will rebound and the net impact will be a
which will also support net exports through weaker imports. redistribution of activity between quarters. From the per-
Although the Bank conceded that consumer spending re- spective of the Bank, these developments will contribute
mains quite robust, they expect a deceleration to a pace more additional volatility to the quarterly profile for real GDP
in line with income growth. While bank lending has begun growth, but is unlikely to impact the timing and magnitude
to moderate, the renewed strength observed in the labour of rate hikes.
market will drive wage gains that in turn will support spend- The second and far more persistent caveat to the growth
ing. When combined with the positive terms of trade shock outlook is the currency. Since the Bank lifted its policy
rate off of the 25 basis point floor last June, the Canadian
U.S. CORPORATE PROFITS AND EMPLOYMENT
dollar has consistently run ahead of what was incorporated
into each MPR by several cents. By providing an implicit
Y/Y % Chg. Y/Y % Chg. degree of tightening, the Canadian dollar takes some of the
6 50
pressure off of the Bank to aggressively normalize interest
40
4 rates. However, the relative stability in the currency reduces
30
the uncertainty facing exporters and makes it comparatively
2 20
easier to adapt to its strength when set against a cyclically
10
0 stronger US economy.
0
While the currency is forecast to remain well supported
-2 -10
over the next two years, the risks are stacking up to the
-20
Corporate Profit (Led 4 Quarters, RHS)
-4 downside. In recent weeks, the Canadian dollar has mirrored
-30
Employment (LHS) the performance of equities and equity market volatility both
-6 -40
1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010 of which are susceptible to global event risk and the targeted
end of QE2 looming at the end of June. At a minimum it
Source: Statistics Canada
is expected that the Bank will cite the persistent strength
Monetary Policy Monitor TD Economics
April 8, 2011 3
www.td.com/economics

reading on core inflation observed in February will prove to


CANADIAN DOLLAR VERSUS BANK OF CANADA be the cyclical trough and that price pressures will gradu-
FORECAST
US$/C$
ally build in tandem with a dwindling overhang of excess
1.05
capacity.
1.03 Against a backdrop of a smaller cushion of disinflation-
ary slack, the prospect of higher inflation expectations will
1.01
present a challenge to the Bank. It is telling that in the
0.99 Jan MPR communiqué accompanying the last FAD, the reference that
inflation expectations were well anchored was dropped. At
0.97
Oct MPR that time, 10 year breakeven inflation had jumped by almost
0.95 July MPR
10 basis points and has since moved higher by almost 25
basis points. In level terms, breakevens are currently in
0.93 the neighbourhood last observed in April 2010 when the
Jul-10 Aug-10 Sep-10 Nov-10 Dec-10 Jan-11 Mar-11
Bank abandoned its conditional commitment as a precursor
Source: Bank of Canada, TD Securities to lifting the overnight rate off of the 25 basis point floor.
This move was corroborated by the quarterly release of the
in the currency as a factor impeding growth next week but Business Outlook Survey (BOS) which noted that the pro-
when facing a terms of trade shock, the positive contribu- portion of respondents expecting inflation rose to the upper
tion to economic growth and income will dominate. But end of the 1-3% target range. The increase in commodity
as a warning to the market, any move to push the currency prices largely drove this expectation higher, however, with
higher in anticipation of hikes will prove to be self-defeating rapidly diminishing economic slack, we expect the Bank to
as the Bank is just as likely to stand to the side and let the assume a less benign stance on the risk to future inflation.
currency slow economic growth and tame inflation. The importance the Bank places on inflation expecta-
tions is well-known. In a recent speech, Governor Carney
Playing With Potential Growth to Cure Capacity
linked the theme of what he described as a secular rise in
Constraints and Anchor Inflation
commodity prices to the conduct of monetary policy. In
With the outlook for economic growth stronger than the particular Carney reiterated the view that “it is paramount
Bank had previously forecast, there is a risk that the output that monetary policy everywhere acts to ensure that infla-
gap could close a full year earlier than the end of 2012 cur- tion expectations remain in line with medium-term policy
rently expected. However, in the April MPR the Bank will objectives”. In the context of the Canadian outlook, evi-
revisit its forecast for potential output and there is a definite dence of rising inflation expectations will require that the
possibility that it could be revised higher (we outlined the Bank remain vigilant and be prepared to act decisively in
case in a recent research note available here). The net impact the second half of the year.
of an upwards revision to both actual and potential output
will correspond to the closing of the output gap anywhere
10-YEAR CANADIAN BREAKEVEN INFLATION
from the middle to the end of 2012.
Although the output gap may close somewhat faster than Percent
2.6
the Bank had initially previously forecast, the outlook for
inflation continues to unfold largely as outlined in the Janu- 2.5

ary MPR. Headline inflation does remain subject to higher 2.4

commodity prices (note the price of crude oil is nearly $20 2.3

higher today than in January) but for the moment wider 2.2
April 2010
price pressures remain subdued. If anything, the weakness 2.1 FAD
March FAD
observed in core inflation in February could introduce a very 2.0
modest downside risk to the Q1 forecast of 1.4%. It is this 1.9
overarching theme of a very benign backdrop for inflation
1.8
that provides the most compelling piece of evidence keep- Jan-10 Mar-10 May-10 Aug-10 Oct-10 Dec-10 Mar-11
ing the Bank on the sidelines next week. Looking further
Source: Bloomberg
into the future, we expect that the downright anaemic 0.9%
Monetary Policy Monitor TD Economics
April 8, 2011 4
www.td.com/economics

INFLATION MEASURES

CANADIAN CONSUMER PRICE INDEX (CPI) CANADIAN GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT (GDP)
Y/Y % Chg. AND PERSONAL CONSUMPTION DEFLATORS
4 4
CPI: All Items Y/Y % Chg.
6 6
3 3 Personal Consumption
4 Deflator 4
2 2
2 2
1 1
0 0
0 0
Midpoint of
Bank of Canada's -2 -2
-1 Bank of Canada -1
Target Band
Core CPI ex. 8 most volatile GDP Deflator
-2 items & indirect taxes -2
-4 -4
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010

Source: Statistics Canada/Haver Analytics Source: Statistics Canada/Haver Analytics

PRODUCT MARKET

CANADA'S OUTPUT GAP CANADIAN CAPACITY UTILIZATION RATE AND


Actual Real GDP Less Potential Real GDP UNFILLED ORDERS-TO-SHIPMENTS RATIO*
% % Ratio
3 88 1.0
2 Full Capacity Excess Demand
84 0.9
1
80 0.8
0 Capacity Utilization Rate (lhs)
-1 76 0.7
-2
72 0.6
-3
68 Unfilled Orders-to-Shipments 0.5
-4 Excess
Forecast Ratio (rhs)
-5 Supply 64 0.4
1992 1996 2000 2004 2008 2012 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009
Forecast by TD Economics as at March 2011 * Total industry excluding aerospace products and parts
Source: TD Economics, Statistics Canada, Bank of Canada Source: Statistics Canada/Haver Analytics

LABOUR MARKET

CANADIAN EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT RATES SKILLED LABOUR SHORTAGE IN CANADA


Y/Y % Chg. % % of firms
5 13 70
Employment
4 (lhs) 12 60
3 11 50
2 10 40
1 9 30
0 8 20
-1 7 10
-2 Unemployment Rate 6 0
(rhs)
-3 5 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 Source: Bank of Canada/Haver Analytics
Source: Statistics Canada/Haver Analytics
Monetary Policy Monitor TD Economics
April 8, 2011 5
www.td.com/economics

WAGES, COSTS AND REAL ESTATE

AVERAGE HOURLY EARNINGS OF PERMANENT EMPLOYEES CANADIAN UNIT LABOUR COSTS


Y/Y % Chg.
Y/Y % Chg.
5 8

6
4
4
3 2

0
2
-2
1 -4

-6
0
1990 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010
1998 2001 2004 2007 2010
Source: Statistics Canada/Haver Analytics
Source: Statistics Canada/Haver Analytics

BANK OF CANADA COMMODITY PRICE INDICES HOUSING PRICE INDICES


Y/Y % Chg. Y/Y % Chg.
60 60 25 25
Total
40 40 20 20
Resale
15 15
20 20
10 10
0 0 5 5
0 0
-20 -20
-5 -5
-40 Total excl. energy -40 New
-10 -10
-60 -60 -15 -15
1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009

Source: Bank of Canada/Haver Analytics Source: CREA, Statistics Canada

INFLATION EXPECTATIONS

INFLATION EXPECTATIONS - CANADIAN FIRMS CANADIAN LONG-TERM GOVERNMENT BOND YIELD -


% CONVENTIONAL MINUS REAL RETURN
90
%
80 5
70
4
60
50 3
40
2
30
20 Per cent of firms expecting inflation to be above 3%
1
10 Per cent of firms expecting inflation to be 2-3%
0
0
1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Source: Bank of Canada Source: Bank of Canada
Monetary Policy Monitor TD Economics
April 8, 2011 6
www.td.com/economics

This report is provided by TD Economics for customers of TD Bank Group. It is for information purposes only and may not be appropriate
for other purposes. The report does not provide material information about the business and affairs of TD Bank Group and the members of
TD Economics are not spokespersons for TD Bank Group with respect to its business and affairs. The information contained in this report
has been drawn from sources believed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate or complete. The report contains economic
analysis and views, including about future economic and financial markets performance. These are based on certain assumptions and other
factors, and are subject to inherent risks and uncertainties. The actual outcome may be materially different. The Toronto-Dominion Bank
and its affiliates and related entities that comprise TD Bank Group are not liable for any errors or omissions in the information, analysis or
views contained in this report, or for any loss or damage suffered.

You might also like