Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The eect of the oil content on the corrosion of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel in oil-in-
water emulsions under controlled hydrodynamic conditions was studied by means of
potentiodynamic polarization and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The
systems that were studied included brine (0.2 wt% NaCl), surfactant solution (Dioctyl
sodium sulfosuccinate, 1 wt%, +NaCl, 0.2 wt%), and oil-in-water emulsions, in which the
aqueous phase was the surfactant solution and the oil phase was a mineral oil. Corrosion
studies employed various controlled hydrodynamic systems, which included a rotating disk
electrode (RDE) and a jet impingement electrochemical cell (JIEC), with the working
electrode located in the stagnant region on the jet axis or on the wall jet region (displaced
from the axis). This study found that the eect of the oil content on the electrochemical
activity of carbon steel (as indicated by the current density in the active state) varies with
the `internal phase relationship', IPR. For emulsion with low IPR (oil contents up to 20
wt%), the electrochemical activity was slightly higher than that of the base surfactant
solution. The electrochemical activity of emulsions with medium IPR (oil contents between
20 and 45 wt%) showed no major variation with oil content, while for emulsions with high
IPR (oil contents between 45 and 70 wt%) the activity was diminished. The data are
* Corresponding author. Present address: Pure and Applied Physical Sciences Division, SRI
International, 333 Ravenswood Ave., Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA. Tel.: +1-650-859-3195; fax: 1-605-
859-3250.
E-mail address: digby@unix.sri.com (D.D. Macdonald).
0010-938X/00/$ - see front matter # 2000 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 1 0 - 9 3 8 X ( 9 9 ) 0 0 0 6 8 - 2
562 H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575
explained in terms of a model that postulates the formation of an `oily phase' on the steel
surface, the stability of which depends on the magnitude of the hydrodynamically induced
shear stress at the interface. However, the coverage of the oil phase on the surface is
postulated to depend on the normalized IPR, such that as the IPR increases the coverage
also increases. Furthermore, the oil phase is envisioned to facilitate the cathodic partial
process (reduction of oxygen) due to the enhanced solubility of oxygen compared with
water, while inhibiting the dissolution of the metal (anodic partial process). Because the two
partial processes are strongly coupled, the corrosion rate is predicted to pass through a
maximum with increasing oil content of the emulsion, as observed. # 2000 Published by
Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
t1=2 t1=2
c D
1=2 1=2
m
1
where t is the shear stress (Pa), tc is the minimal value of shear stress at which the
material suers plastic deformation (Pa), D is the shear rate (sÿ1), and m is the
viscosity of the emulsion (cp). The change in the rheological behavior of the
emulsions with oil content around 40% could explain various phenomena that are
observed when electrochemical experiments are made with emulsions [14,15]. The
average emulsion viscosity is logarithmically related to IPR, with m increasing with
increasing IPR.
Studies of the electrochemical behavior of metallic surfaces in contact with
emulsions under controlled hydrodynamic conditions can help to develop an
understanding of the eect of the oily phase on corrosion processes. Previous
studies [18,19] have employed rotating disk electrodes (RDEs) to study mass
transfer under laminar and turbulent ¯ow conditions as well as to investigate the
kinetics of corrosion reactions. However, in order to more accurately stimulate
®eld and/or plant conditions, a jet impingement electrochemical cell (JIEC) was
employed in the present work. A JIEC allows one to control the hydrodynamics
of the system over a wide range of conditions (e.g., shear rate) and to obtain
turbulent ¯ow with a high shear stress on the surface. Several patterns of ¯ow can
be obtained, depending on the location of the working electrode. Thus, the
electrode can be placed directly in front of the nozzle, where the mass transfer
rate is independent of the radial position and the ¯ow regime is considered to be
mainly laminar (stagnant region, r < Rnozzle). Alternatively, the electrode may be
located at some radial distance from the central point (wall jet region, r > 2.5
Rnozzle), where fully developed turbulent ¯ow exists, but where the turbulent
intensity and mean ¯ow rate decays with distance from the central stagnant point.
In this latter region, momentum is transferred away from the surface and the ¯ow
is known as `self preserving', but it eventually becomes laminar [20] at suciently
large radial distances.
In this paper, the electrochemical behavior of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel in
contact with oil-in-water emulsions under controlled hydrodynamic and
electrochemical conditions is analysed. Our principal objective was to ascertain the
relationship between the corrosion rate, as determined by electrochemical
methods, and the oil content of the emulsion and the hydrodynamic conditions.
Data from these studies is considered to be essential for developing an
understanding of the role of the oil in modifying the corrosion rate and
mechanism.
564 H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575
2. Experimental
The most stable emulsions were found to have the following aqueous phase
composition: distilled and deionized water, anionic surfactant agent TRITON
GR-7 M (Dioctyl sodium sulfusuccianate, 1 wt%), and sodium chloride, 0.2 wt%.
The oily phase was a light mineral oil with a viscosity of 2 cp and a density of
0.89 g/cm3.
Optimization of the emulsion composition and preparation process, as well as
characterization of the emulsion in terms of particle size, viscosity, wettability,
electrical conductivity, and pH was carried out as the Colombian Petroleum
Institute, in consultation with the Rheology and Interfacial Phenomena Group.
Pseudo-ternary phase diagrams were used to determine the emulsion composition
with the highest degree of stability, as described elsewhere [21,22].
Average drop size was determined using a particle size analyzer manufactured
by Malvern Instruments, MASTER PARTICLE SIZER MG-02. The distribution
of drop size obtained in all cases was unimodal with an average of 11 mm.
Rheological properties were measured using a Haake Rotovisco RV-20
Rheometer. Table 1 shows the experimentally measured viscosity for emulsions
with dierent oil content as determined at a shear rate of 10 sÿ1.
AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel, with the composition shown in Table 2, was used
as the test material. Before each experiment, the samples were polished to 1200
grit using SiC paper and were ®nally polished to a mirror ®nish using 0.05 mm
Al2O3 powder.
The diameter of the rotating disk electrode (RDE) was 0.5 cm. The reference
electrode was a standard saturated calomel electrode (SCE) coupled to a Luggin
probe, whose tip was located between the working and the counter electrodes. The
counter electrode was a platinum wire in serpentine form and protected by a
porous membrane. Both the reference electrode and the counter electrode were
located in a manner that they did not perturb the ¯ow lines of the emulsion
toward and from the working electrode. The rotation rate of the RDE was
Table 1
Viscosity values for dierent oil contents
Oil percentage 0 2 5 10 20 50 70
Average viscosity, cp [g/ms] 1 1.3 1.5 1.75 2 10 17
H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575 565
Table 2
AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel composition
C 0.106 0.08±0.13
Mn 0.509 0.30±0.60
P 0.013 0.040 max.
S 0.010 0.050 max.
Si 0.058
Cu 0.007
Ni 0.028
Cr 0.005
V 0.003
Mo 0.008
Ti 0.001
As 0.002
Al 0.029
Nb 0.007
Co 0.007
Sn 0.004
Fe Balance
between 0 and 2500 rpm; however, most of the experiments were carried out at
800 rpm. At rotation rates higher than 800 rpm, no major eects of rotation rate
were observed in the electrochemical activity.
The jet impingement electrochemical cell, shown schematically in Fig. 1, was
fabricated after the design of E®rd [23]. The main geometric parameters were:
Fig. 2. In¯uence of oil content on the polarization of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel in contact with o/w
emulsions using the Rotating Disk Electrode at 800 rpm: (a) 0±45 wt% oil; (b) 45±70 wt% oil.
H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575 567
Polarization curves for carbon steel in o/w emulsions of dierent oil content,
obtained using the rotating disk electrode and the jet impingement cell, are shown
in Figs. 2 and 3, respectively. In Fig. 2, the polarization curves obtained from the
rotating disk electrode at 800 rpm in the surfactant solution (aqueous
solution+1% GR-7 M+0.2% NaCl) and in emulsions with oil contents of 20, 40,
Fig. 3. In¯uence of oil content on the polarization curves for AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel in contact
with o/w emulsions as determined using the JIEC. The specimen was located in the stagnant region.
Fluid velocity at the nozzle is 3.58 m/s.
568 H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575
45, 50, 60, and 70%, are presented. Under the laminar ¯ow conditions provided
by the rotating disk electrode (Re was calculated to be between 48 and 817
compared with 2 105 for transition to turbulent ¯ow), a decrease in cathodic
current with increasing oil content is observed. An anodic peak is observed for all
oil contents; however, the peak current density decreases with increasing oil
content in the emulsion up to 45%. For all contents over 45%, the peak current
density increases. The observed relationship between the anodic peak and the oil
content in the emulsion under laminar ¯ow conditions indicated the existence of
an oil-surfactant ®lm on the metallic surface.
At 800 rpm, the cathodic current density for an o/w emulsion with an IPR of
20% was slightly higher than that of the surfactant solution (IPR=0%).
However, experiments performed at a rotation rate of 400 rpm indicate that for o/
w emulsions with low IPR (2, 5, 10% oil) the cathodic current density showed a
tendency to be slightly higher than that for the surfactant solution, but the
dierences are very small. Therefore, an increase in the oil content of the o/w
emulsions with low IPR seems to favor the cathodic processes, but when the oil
content exceeds 20% the cathodic activity of the metal diminishes.
Polarization curves that were obtained using the jet impingement cell, when the
working electrode was located in the stagnant region and when the ¯uid velocity
at the nozzle was 3.58 m/s, are presented in Fig. 3. The polarization curves
obtained for the stagnant region at a ¯uid velocity at the nozzle of 7.17 m/s, and
Fig. 4. In¯uence of oil content on the electrochemical impedance of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel in
contact with o/w emulsions. Rotating Disk Electrode at 800 rpm.
H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575 569
those for the wall jet region at ¯uid velocities at the nozzle of 3.58 and 7.17 m/s,
were very similar to those shown in Fig. 3. Those data have been presented in
previous publications [30±33].
Under the drastic ¯ow conditions existing in the JIEC (high ¯uid speeds at the
nozzle and low emulsion viscosity), the characteristic anodic peak in the
polarization curves obtained with the rotating disk electrode is not observed
(compare Figs. 2 and 3). Furthermore the current at high anodic potential
observed with the JIEC is considerably higher than that observed with the RDE
Fig. 5. Eect of oil content on the electrochemical impedance behavior of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel
in contact with oil/water emulsions as determined using the JIEC. The specimen was located in the
stagnant region. Fluid velocity at the nozzle 7.17 m/s (a) and 3.58 m/s (b).
570 H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575
at equivalent oil contents, indicating that the electrochemical processes that occur
in this region of potential are highly sensitive to ¯ow-induced shear.
Nyquist diagrams obtained for the rotating disk electrode and the jet
impingement cell with the working electrode located in the stagnant region for
two ¯uid velocities at the nozzle (3.58 m/s and 7.17 m/s) are shown in Figs. 4 and
5. The Nyquist diagrams for the jet impingement cellÐwall jet region and for
both ¯uid velocities at the nozzleÐare similar to those shown in Fig. 5 for the
stagnant region. A marked increase in the polarization and ohmic resistances is
observed for oil contents in the emulsion between 45 and 50 wt%. This is
common for both of the hydrodynamic systems employed, but the impedances at
both ends of the frequency range observed under laminar ¯ow conditions using
the RDE is considerably higher than those observed in the JIEC in either the
stagnant and wall jet regions. These data, again, indicate the presence of a shear-
sensitive phenomenon at the steel/emulsion interface.
In the speci®c case of the polarization resistance, derived from the Nyquist
diagrams shown in Fig. 4, for the rotating disk electrode, three dierent behaviors
become evident. For low IPR (o/w emulsions with 0, 5, 10, 20 wt% oil) the
polarization resistance seems to increase with oil content; for medium IPR (20, 40,
45%) this parameter does not change strongly with the oil content, and for high
IPR (45, 50, 60%) it markedly increases with oil content once again. In the case
of the impinging jet cell, we observed that the solution resistance varied
signi®cantly with the oil content in the emulsion, is independent of the ¯uid
Fig. 6. Change in the corrosion rate of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel vs oil content in the emulsion.
RDE at 800 rpm.
H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575 571
velocity at the nozzle, and is independent of the working electrode location. The
polarization resistance (diameter of the locus at the real axis) seemed to display a
sinusoidal behavior with the percentage of oil in the emulsion, and is dependent
on the ¯uid velocity at the nozzle and on the region where the working electrode
is located.
The variation of the corrosion rate, calculated from the potentiodynamic
polarization curves (by Tafel extrapolation) and impedance measurements (using
the polarization resistance, obtained from the Nyquist diagrams, and Tafel slopes)
[12], is shown in Fig. 6 with respect to oil content of the emulsion for the rotating
disk electrode. The corrosion rate remains relatively constant for oil contents in
the emulsion up to 20%. Further additions of oil reduce the corrosion rate
sharply. This behavior is quite similar to that of the cathodic current density, as
was noted earlier.
The in¯uence of oil content on the corrosion rate, when measured in the JIEC,
in which the hydrodynamic conditions are characterized by higher Reynolds
numbers and shear stresses than those of the RDE, and with the electrodes
located in the stagnant region and for the two ¯uid velocities at the nozzle, is
shown in Fig. 7. The corrosion rate is observed to increase with oil content for
emulsions with low IPR (5, 10, 20%), whereas for oil contents over 40% (40, 50,
Fig. 7. Change in the corrosion rate of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel vs oil content in the emulsion.
JIEC, stagnant region.
572 H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575
65%) the corrosion rate decreased. Again the behavior of the corrosion rate is
very similar to that of the cathodic limiting current density.
For the JIEC assembly with the working electrode in the wall jet region,
corresponding to the most drastic hydrodynamic conditions used in this work, the
corrosion rate is not strongly aected by the oil content in the emulsion, provided
that it is less than 40% (Fig. 8). Oil contents higher than 40% reduce the
corrosion rate, independent of the ¯uid velocity.
The ®ndings reported in this paper are consistent with the formation of a thin
layer of an `oily phase' on the metal surface, the stability of which depends on the
oil content of the emulsion and the magnitude of the hydrodynamically-induced
shear at the interface. Thus, in all cases, increasing the oil content (to r20% in
the case of the RDE and r40% in the JIEC in the stagnant region) results in a
shift in the high frequency intercept of the impedance locus on the real axis to
higher values, indicating an increase in the resistance of the phase(s) between the
metal surface and the tip of the reference electrode. However, the formation of
this layer is not abrupt, as indicated by the continuous nature of the corrosion
rate vs oil content data shown in Figs. 6±8. Thus, the bell-shaped nature of the
corrosion rate vs oil content curves indicates that the rate of attack on the metal
is determined by a competition between oil adsorption, which decreases the
Fig. 8. Change in the corrosion rate of AISI-SAE 1010 carbon steel vs to the oil content in the
emulsion. JIEC, wall jet region.
H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575 573
corrosion rate with increasing oil content, and some process by which the
formation of the oily phase on the surface enhances the corrosion rate (see below).
The principal eect of increasing shear is to increase the corrosion rate, with the
eect possibly being greatest at low oil contents (compare Figs. 7 and 8). In the
case of RDE, oil adsorption appears to be the dominant process, whereas for the
jet impingement system the process that facilitates attack at low oil contents
appears to play a major role in determining the corrosion behavior.
It is important to note that, in the latter case, in both the stagnant and all jet
regions, the corrosion rate increases with oil content for low oil contents. This
behavior is mathematically described by a function of the form, Corrosion Rate
(CR) A y(1ÿy ), where y is the coverage of the surface by the oily phase.
Assuming that y is proportional to the normalized oil content of the emulsion
(IPR '), we obtain CR A IPR ' (1ÿIPR ') where 0 < IPR ' < 1.0. The corrosion rate
vs IPR behavior therefore is determined by the product of two linearly varying
sub-functions, IPR ' and (1ÿIPR '). The ®rst subfunction appears to correspond to
the oily phase facilitating the transport of oxygen to the metal surface, which is
supported by the higher solubility of oxygen in light mineral oil than in water
[34,35]. Thus, the role of the adsorbed oily phase is to facilitate the cathodic
(oxygen reduction) partial reaction. However, the immediate product from the
corrosion of iron is an ionic species, Fe2+ or (Fe3+), whose solubility in the oily
phase is expected to be very low. Thus, the oily phase on the surface is expected
to inhibit the anodic partial reaction, such that the rate decreases with (1ÿIPR '),
with the eect becoming dominant at high IPR '. Because the anodic and cathodic
partial reactions are coupled, the net eect is the competition of two opposing
eects and hence the observed bell-shaped dependence of corrosion rate on oil
content of the emulsion.
the oil content of the emulsion and the magnitude of the hydrodynamically
induced shear stress at the interface. The adsorbed oily phase is considered to
facilitate the cathodic partial reaction (O2 reduction), because of the higher
solubility of oxygen in oil than in water, whereas it inhibits the anodic partial
reaction (iron dissolution) due to the low solubility of ionic species (Fe2+ or
Fe3+) in the oil.
Acknowledgements
References
[1] P. Becher (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology, Applications, Marcel Dekker Inc, New
York and Basel, 1985.
[2] R.E. Meredith, ChW Tobias, J. Electrochem. Soc. 108 (3) (1961).
[3] Ortega B. Artalejo, Trillo C. Fauli, Carrascosa A. del Pozo, Pre-formulation of emulsions, con-
ductimetric study (PreformulacioÂn de emulsiones, estudio conductimeÂtrico), Industria
FarmaceuÂtica, 1987.
[4] R.A. Mac Kay, Advances in Coll. Interf. Sci. 15 (1981).
[5] R.A. Mac Kay, N.S. Dixit, J. Phys. Chem. 86 (1982) 4593.
[6] R.A. Mac Kay, J. Phys. Chem. 86 (1982) 4756.
[7] C.A. Jones, L.E. Weaner, R.A. Mac Kay, J. Phys. Chem. 84 (1980) 1495.
[8] F. Beck, H. Guder, J. Electrochem. Soc. 134 (1987) 2416.
[9] E. Sudol, E.A. Mohamed, Ind. Eng. Chem., Prod. Res. Dev. 24 (1985) 550.
[10] C.C. Ho, A. Humayun, E.A. Mohamed, J. Vanderho, Some aspects of cathodic electrodeposi-
tion of epoxi latexes as corrosion resistant coatings, in: Corrosion Control by Organic Coatings,
NACE, 1981, pp. 111±121.
[11] M. Uebner, M. Ng Ka, J. Appl. Polymer Sci. 36 (1988) 1525.
[12] M.G. Fontana, in: Corrosion Engineering, 3rd ed., McGraw Hill, 1986, pp. 15±17.
[13] C. Retamoso et al., Electrochemical processes in emulsions (Procesos ElectroquõÂ micos en
Emulsiones), Final Report, UIS-Colciencias-ICP Project, Bucaramanga, Colombia, 1993.
[14] D.Y. PenÄa, MSc. thesis, Industrial University of Santander, Bucaramanga, Colombia, 1994.
[15] F. Echeverria, MSc. thesis, Industrial University of Santander, Bucaramanga, Colombia, 1995.
[16] L.L. Schramm, Emulsions, fundamentals and applications in the petroleum industry, Advances in
Chemistry Series 231, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1992, Chapter 4, 139.
[17] A.H.P. Skelland, Non Newtonian Flow and Heat Transfer, John Wiley and Sons, 1967.
[18] Yu V. Pleskov, V. Yu Filinovskii, The Rotating Disk Electrode, Consultants Bureau, New York,
1976.
[19] V.G. Levich, Physicochemical Hydrodynamics, Prentice Hall Inc, 1962.
H.Q. Becerra et al. / Corrosion Science 42 (2000) 561±575 575
[20] J.L. Dawson, C.C. Shih, D.G. John, D.A. Eden Electrochemical testing of dierential ¯ow
induced corrosion using jet impingement rigs. In: Proceedings of Corrosion 1987, Paper number
453, NACE, USA.
[21] D.Y. PenÄa, C. Vasquez, C. Retamoso, J. Grosso, J. Villarreal, Oil in water emulsions corrosivity
under stagnant conditions, in: Proceedings of First Corrosion Congress, NACE Latin America
Region and First Venezuelan Corrosion Congress, 6±11 November, 1994.
[22] H. Quiroga, J.H. Panqueva, J.L. Grosso, C. Retamoso, Pseudo-ternary phase diagram used as a
guide for obtaining stable emulsions, in: Proceedings of International Symposium about Micelles,
Microemulsions and monolayers, University of Florida, Gainesville, FA, USA, 1995.
[23] D. E®rd, E.J. Wright, J.A. Boros, T.G. Hailey, Correlation of steel corrosion in pipe ¯ow with jet
impingement and rotating cylinder tests, in: Corrosion, NACE, 1993.
[24] D.D. Macdonald, M. Urquidi-Macdonald, J. Electrochem. Soc. 137 (1990) 515.
[25] D.D. Macdonald, M. Urquidi-Macdonald, J. Electrochem. Soc. 132 (1985) 2316.
[26] M. Urquidi-Macdonald, S. Real, D.D. Macdonald, J. Electrochem. Soc. 133 (1986) 2018.
[27] M. Urquidi-Macdonald, S. Real, D.D. Macdonald, Electrochimica Acta 35 (1990) 1559.
[28] H.A. Kramers, Physiol. Zool. 30 (1929) 522.
[29] R.I. Kronig de, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 12 (1926) 547.
[30] H. Quiroga, D.D. Macdonald, C. Retamoso, J. Panqueva, J.L. Grosso, Corrosiveness of o/w
emulsions under controlled hydrodynamic conditions. DC and AC measurements, in: Proceedings
of 190th Meeting. The Electrochemical Society, San Antonio, Texas, 6±11 October 1996.
[31] H. Quiroga, D.D. Macdonald, C. Retamoso, J. Panqueva, J.L. Grosso, Corrosiveness of o/w
emulsions under controlled hydrodynamic conditions (Corrosividad de emulsiones aceite en agua,
o/w, bajo condiciones hidrodinaÂmicas controladas), in: Proceedings of National Corrosion
Congress (Memorias Congreso Nacional de CorrosioÂn), Paipa, Colombia, 4±6 August 1997.
[32] H. Quiroga, D.D. Macdonald, C. Retamoso, J. Panqueva, J.L. Grosso, Corrosiveness of o/w
emulsions under controlled hydrodynamic conditions (Corrosividad de emulsiones aceite en agua,
o/w, bajo condiciones hidrodinaÂmicas controladas), in: Proceedings of National Congress of
Chemical Engineering (Congreso Nacional de IngenierõÂ a QuõÂ mica). MedellõÂ n, Colombia, 6±8
August 1997.
[33] H. Quiroga, Corrosiveness of oil in water emulsions under hydrodynamic conditions, PhD thesis,
Chemical Engineering School, Industrial University of Santander, Colombia, 1998.
[34] The National Research Council of the United States of America, International Critical Tables of
Numerical Data, Physics, Chemistry and Technology, III, 255±263, 1933.
[35] Atherton Seidell, Solubilities of Inorganic and Metal Organic Compounds, 3rd ed., I, 1940.