Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CONTROL
ATTRITION
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We would like to thank Mrs. Netra Ray HR executive at HCL Pvt.Ltd. (BPO) sector 16,
Noida for providing us with information about the reasons for attrition and the steps that
are being followed by them and for bearing with our endless questions.
We are grateful to Professor J.R Sharma for his support and guidance and for giving us
an opportunity to work on this report.
At last we would like to thank our family and friends for their encouragement, motivation
and support.
2
CONTENTS
S.NO PARTICULARS PAGE NO
3). Introduction 6
5). Factors 15
9). Conclusion 28
10). Recommendations 29
11). Bibliography 32
3
OBJECTIVE
To find out the rate of attrition and what are the reasons for the same and how to cope
up with it.
PURPOSE
The purpose of the report is to understand the reasons of attrition in BPO and
pharmaceutical industry and what measures can be taken up by the organization to
bring the rate of attrition up to 25%. And to see as what the other companies are doing
in order to tackle this universal phenomenon.
4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In the current scenario of high economic growth and rapid globalization, the fight for
talent is becoming increasingly intense. Talent or human resource is a major asset for
any company. Company Invest high amount of money for their recruitment, selection &
training and what happens to company if these Talents or Employees leave the
organization in short while seeking new opportunities. Plagued by erratic attrition
trends and cutthroat global competition, organizations are now realizing the need to
understand the supply-demand equation better in order to garner strong mechanisms
to attract and retain top talent.
Employee retention is critical to the long-term health and success of any organization;
however it is becoming increasingly difficult for companies across the globe to attract,
motivate and retain key talent. Attrition rates are still on the rise and as the war for
talent becomes more intense each year it is becoming increasingly important for
companies to ensure they have the right people in place to guide future business
success.
Overall attrition rates are continuing to rise in Asia. The aggregate rate across all
markets reached 18 percent in 2007, marking a two percent increase on 2006.
Meanwhile budgeted attrition, which remained lower than actual attrition, rose slightly
from 10 to 11 percent year on year.
The facts revealed that external inequity of compensation was the main reason for
employees leaving their organization; however other causes include limited growth
opportunities and role stagnation.
Retention also remains a key challenge in BPO and pharmaceutical industry. More than
half of the employees in this sector have a retention bonus plan or are in discussions to
create one. The top three retention measures suggested are: pay above the market;
provide the opportunity to learn new skills; and encourage a favorable work/life
balance. An overwhelming majority of companies said they house an exit-interview
policy to learn more about why employees are leaving.
5
Introduction
In an environment of rapid growth, globalization and expansion, the pressure to attract
and retain outstanding employees has become a scary reality for most organizations.
The new-age economies, with their attendant paradigm shifts in human capital
management, have placed a heavy demand on today’s organizations and Attrition is
emerging as a key business concern for organizations. It is turning into a bigger issue
than attracting talent. The annual attrition rate is 20-30 per cent (reduction in the
number of employees through retirement, resignation or death) across industries in
India. It is as high as 44 per cent in BFSI (banking, financial services and insurance)
vertical and 35 per cent in BPO (business process outsourcing). Attracting and retaining
key talent has become one of the key drivers of overall business performance in
organizations and companies have been utilizing a diverse range of methods to draw in
new hires and ensure they stay as Attrition is an expensive phenomenon, potentially
impacting the bottom line of businesses.
The cost of attrition is not just the loss of that employee but it includes an array of
hidden costs such as recruitment costs, selection costs, training costs, cost of covering
during the period and opportunity costs.
The organizational costs associated with the turnover in terms of hiring, training and
productivity loss costs can add up to more than five per cent of an organization’s
operating costs.
6
BACKGROUND
First of all we need to know what attrition exactly is. Attrition is the rate of shrinkage in
the size or a gradual, natural reduction in membership or personnel, as through
retirement, resignation, or death. It is Normal and uncontrollable reduction of a work
force because of retirement, death, sickness, and relocation. It is one method of
reducing the size of a work force without management taking any overt actions. The
drawback to reduction by attrition is that reductions are often unpredictable and can
leave gaps in an organization.
Attrition Rate% =
Attrition causes huge loss to the company, not only in terms of manpower but also in
monetary terms. The cost of attrition would be explained in details later in this report.
Moreover, this report will also cover the reasons why the employees leave a company.
Attrition is a universal phenomenon and no industry is devoid of it, but the degree
fluctuates from industry to industry and at different levels. Attrition by Employee Group
According to the study, the overall employee turnover rate was highest at the
professional/supervisor/technical staff level, recording total and voluntary attrition at a
very high 39 percent and 33 percent respectively. (See Figure 1)
7
1) Employee attrition by group
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
total attrition
10% voluntaryattrition
5%
0%
t r l t l
en age nica po
r
nua
em an h p a
ag m ec l/s
u m
an la /t
m n ir ca
p io cle
/to ess
or of
ni pr
se
We have examined two important sectors in which the attrition rate is high i.e. BPO/IT
industry and pharmaceutical industry, and we have focused basically at middle level of
employees where the rate is highest. Lastly, this report will explain what can be done to
control the attrition in both these sectors. And what are the measures that are taken up
by other companies.
8
2).
9
BPO Industry in India
It is said that the Indian BPO Industry has come of age. This is very true if we analyze
both the past and present scenarios. Defying all the permutations and combinations, the
Indian outsourcing industry has registered a massive growth over the years. India has
remained one of the most favorite offshore destinations for BPO/ITES activities. One of
the most prominent reasons for the same is cheap labor. Over the past five years, the
Indian BPO/ITES has been growing at a rate of about 50-60%. As per NASSCOM, the
Indian BPO/ITES registered a growth rate of 46% and clocked revenue of UD$ 3.6 billion
in 2003-04 up from UD$ 2.5 billion in 2002-03.This industry has contributed a great deal
to the export revenues of the country and is expected to do that in future too.
This industry is expected to generate one million jobs by 2009. HR management is one
of the most critical areas in this industry, so important that it can be referred to as HR-
enabled services rather than IT-enabled services. The reason for the same is that this
industry is facing a very high rate of attrition of around 30-40%. Though this rate is not
very high as compared to US which faces an attrition rate of around 70% though, our
next main competitor in this area, China, is facing the attrition rate as low as 12-15%.
The consequence of the same is that this results in higher costs to the company and so
the companies may lose its main competitive edge which is lower costs. Later on, we
have explained why the cost of attrition is so high. This means that there is a very high
need to control the attrition rate in the industry.
10
Pharmaceutical industry in India
The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry today is in the front rank of India’s science-based
industries with wide ranging capabilities in the complex field of drug manufacture and
technology. A highly organized sector, the Indian Pharma Industry is estimated to be
worth $ 4.5 billion, growing at about 8 to 9 percent annually. It ranks very high in the
third world, in terms of technology, quality and range of medicines manufactured. From
simple headache pills to sophisticated antibiotics and complex cardiac compounds,
almost every type of medicine is now made indigenously.
From Rs. 50 billion in 1990 it has grown to Rs.550 billion (US$ 12 billion) in 2005-06.
Driven by growing number of pharmaceutical units, increased knowledge skills,
improved quality and increasing national as well as international demand, India is now
recognized as a leading global pharma player.
11
a) Competent workforce: India has a pool of personnel with high managerial
and technical competence as also skilled workforce. It has an educated
work force and English is commonly used. Professional services are easily
available.
c) Legal & Financial Framework: India has a 58 year old democracy and
hence has a solid legal framework and strong financial markets. There is
already an established international industry and business community.
12
COST OF ATTRITION
There are a number of costs which are incurred by a BPO when they hire any new
employee. These costs can be in terms of monetary or can be in terms of time wasted or
any other intangible things. Some of these costs can be as stated below: -
I. Recruitment Costs
1. The cost of orientation in terms of the new person's salary and the cost of the
person who conducts the orientation. Also include the cost of orientation
materials.
2. The cost of departmental training as the actual development and delivery cost
plus the cost of the salary of the new employee. Note that the cost will be
significantly higher for some positions such as sales representatives and call
center agents who require 4 - 6 weeks or more of classroom training.
3. The cost of the person(s) who conduct the training.
4. The cost of various training materials needed including company or product
manuals, computer or other technology equipment used in the delivery of
training.
13
III. Lost Productivity Costs
As the new employee is learning the new job, the company policies and practices,
etc. they are not fully productive. Use the following guidelines to calculate the
cost of this lost productivity:
1. The cost of bring the new person on board including the cost to put the person
on the payroll, establish computer and security passwords and identification
cards, telephone hookups, cost of establishing email accounts, or leasing other
equipment such as cell phones, automobiles.
2. The cost of a manager's time spent developing trust and building confidence in
the new employee's work.
1. Calculate the revenue per employee by dividing total company revenue by the
average number of employees in a given year. Whether an employee contributes
directly or indirectly to the generation of revenue, their purpose is to provide
some defined set of responsibilities that are necessary to the generation of
revenue. Calculate the lost revenue by multiplying the number of weeks the
position is vacant by the average weekly revenue per employee.
Thus we can say that if a person leaves a job company has to suffer losses as it involves
many costs.
14
FACTORS
The main factors of attrition in both sectors are as follows:
External inequity arises when an employee realizes that some other employee from a
different organization puts in much less efforts than he does, but receives a much higher
compensation than him. This could cause an employee to feel that maybe he is not
getting compensated fairly and can cause him to quit the job
2) Work Timings
The work timings in BPO are very odd. This affects the family life of the employee.
Moreover, the male to female ratio in BPO is quiet low. The number of females in BPO
can be as large as 35%. This means that working hour problem is quiet acute in their
case especially after they get married, as after marriage comes social and family
pressure to adjust work timings and take care of families.
3) Career Growth
4) Higher Education
This is a problem as most of the employees in this sector are pretty young and aspiring.
They join the firm because of lucrative salary. But with time, they try to move on to
other sectors or top management and one of the ways to do this is higher education
15
5) Role stagnation
Attrition rate is higher at knowledge level (middle level) in which the employee has to
do the same work again and again, which makes his work monotonous and due to lack
of responsibility and authority his growth is restricted to a particular role, so they move
to other companies where they can play different roles and handle responsibility.
7) Lack of recognition
When an employee feels that he is not getting due recognition for his achievement, a
feeling of demotivation creeps into him, and this can cause him to consider leaving the
organization. Employees have an expectation that when they work well, they will get
some recognition from their managers in the form of a personal appreciation or an
award etc.
8) Under-utilization of skills
9) Performance assessment
An employee may feel disappointed by the performance appraisal report and feel that
he has not been appraised in an unbiased manner. It may happen that he feels that the
appraisal process itself is flawed and the appraisers are biased. This can cause the
employee to put in his papers and leave the organization.
16
10)Internal inequity of compensation
Internal inequity occurs when the employee feels that the amount of efforts he puts in
to do his job are much more than what rewards he gets in return for them. This can
cause him to feel de-motivated and nurture feelings of dissatisfaction and eventually
resign from his post.
11)Business instability
Many a times, when the organization faces some kind of instability or uncertainty with
regards to operations, an employee might quit his job before he is asked to leave. Many
a times when employees get a whim that the organization is going to down-size or is
going to be taken over by another company, they tend to feel safer quitting the job than
worrying about whether the organization will retain them.
17
WAYS TO CONTROL ATTRITION
The road ahead for the BPO and pharmaceutical firms is very important because if they
are not able to control the attrition rate they will lose their competitive edge in the
global market. For these certain, strategies and certain improvements are needed to be
made in the processes followed in order to bring down the rate of attrition to 25%
It’s always about providing something extra to your employees. Good salary is
something which is a standard in the industry. So what needs to be done is to give some
perks to the employees. They need to be given perks like rewards for their good
performances. Owing to the odd working hours, the employees have very tattered
personal lives. So perks like foreign tours or company sponsored vacations are always a
welcome gift.
Performance based incentives is a must in the BPO companies as these are generally the
employees who gets picked up by the placement hunters most often. These employees
are also among the most aspiring ones in the company so there is a need to give them
ample opportunity to rise and progress in the organization.
18
Relationship is something which lasts over time. So, if a company needs to hold on to its
employees, it needs to build a strong bonding with the employees. As we will see in the
case of Office-Tiger discussed below, there is a need to instill pride in the employees.
They need to be shown that the work done by them is important. Also, work needs to
be shown in the form of challenge to the employee rather than just a monotonous
routine work. Provide employee with ESOPs, which would give them a feeling that they
are working for themselves and that they are an inseparable part of the company.
iv. HR Practices
HR is the most critical department in any BPO. While conducting the recruitment, it is in
the hands of HR to bring the right kind of people. HR needs to identify the employees
who would stick with the company and not get the employees solely based on the
qualifications and communication skills. Moreover, more diversity in the kind of
employee hired needs to be brought so there is a diversified culture within the
company. Companies need to look to hire from non metro cities as the employees from
these cities are more likely to stay with the company than those from metros. Also, they
need to keep an eye on good performing employees and have a career plan in mind. Not
only this, they need to discuss it with these employees on a regular basis and take
feedback from them. They also need to give their employees personal space to grow
and adjust with social life. Moreover, in case of employees leaving a good exit-feedback
system should be in place so as to cover the reason for which the employees leave.
It is important to take feedback from employees through different means and work with
the HR department to iron out differences. Feedback can be got in two ways—during
the employee’s tenure, and through exit interviews. Inputs can be secured from existing
employees through various employee relationship management tools. Exit interviews
help management learn the reasons why employees leave the company; based on their
revelations, the organization can address the problems of existing employees, thereby
curb attrition.
The success of any organization depends on how it attracts recruits, motivates, and
retains its workforce. Organizations need to be more flexible so that they develop their
talented workforce and gain their commitment. Thus, organizations are required to
retain employees by addressing their work life issues.
19
The elements that are relevant to an individual’s quality of work life include the task,
the physical work environment, social environment within the organization,
administrative system and relationship between life on and off the job.
The basic objectives of a QWL program are improved working conditions for the
employee and increase organizational effectiveness.
Providing quality work life involves taking care of the following aspects:
a) Occupational health care: The safe work environment provides the basis for the
person to enjoy working. The work should not pose a health hazard for the person.
The employer and employee, aware of their risks and rights, could achieve a lot in
their mutually beneficial dialogue.
b) Suitable working time: Organizations are offering flexible work options to their
employees wherein employees enjoy flexi-timings for dedicating their efforts at
work.
c) Appropriate salary: The appropriate as well as attractive salary has always been
an important factor in retaining employees. Providing employees salary at par with
the other counterparts of above that what competitors are paying motivates them
to stick with the company for long.
Providing quality at work not only reduces attrition but also helps in reduced
absenteeism and improved job satisfaction. Not only does QWL contribute to a
company's ability to recruit quality people, but also it enhances a company's
competitiveness. Common beliefs support the contention that QWL will positively
nurture a more flexible, loyal, and motivated workforce, which are essential in
determining the company's competitiveness.
20
9). Transparent work culture
Employees comprise the most vital assets of the company. In a work place where
employees are not able to use their full potential and not heard and valued, they
are likely to leave because of stress and frustration. In a transparent environment
while employees get a sense of achievement and belongingness from a healthy
work environment, the company is benefited with a stronger, reliable work-force
harboring bright new ideas for its growth.
11) Communication
21
Communication is a process in which a message is conveyed to the receiver by the
sender. The message may be or may not be in a common format or language that
both the sender and receiver understand. So there is a need to encode and
decode the message in the process. Encoding and decoding also helps in the
security of the message. The process of communication is incomplete without the
feedback
.
22
applies to employee retention also.
Straight-from-the-shoulder communication is what the
employees need from their employers. Employees look for organizations where
communication and process are transparent. Nothing is hidden and shared with
the employees.
Communication mediums
23
INITIATIVES TAKEN BY OTHER COMPANIES TO REDUCE ATTRITION
Neil soft, they have crèche facilities within the company premises, and they have
trained teachers to look after young children. Company officials highlight that
women in the age group 28-35 are increasingly selecting the BPO industry as a
preferred career choice and as these employees have young children it becomes
necessary for companies to provide adequate facilities
Wipro's Spectra mind has introduced medical insurance for their employees and
they also provide 24-hour medical facilities for employees.
Tran works Information Services and Zenta Technologies which are already
providing accommodation to their senior staff are contemplating this for lower
level staff. It could also include paying the entire deposit amount for flats or a
certain percentage of the registration fees. Apart from improving long-term work
prospects, HR managers are providing life enhancers in the form of community or
sporting activities in a bid to improve staff morale.
E-Funds International the company is focusing on social and sporting events such
as organizing six-a-side soccer games and cricket matches.
Federal Express in India believes in spotting talent early and investing in it.
Employees with leadership or management potential are identified and training
programmes are held to improve their skills. They are then assigned senior
management positions. Rewarding merit in this way improves the image of the
24
workplace among the employees. Also in place at FedEx are online platforms for
employees to raise issues or complaints. This ensures no issue takes an
unpleasant shape or is blown out of proportion.
IBM executive MBA programmes and Web based learning tools help in training
the employees to be better managers. Also the company sends the senior level
employees to Wharton, Stanford and Harvard. It also has an anonymous
feedback programme (one of the first of its kind in the country), through which
the employees can give feedback freely.
25
INTERPRETATION AND ANALYSIS
Reason 1: Demand is more than supply: there is no dearth of graduates and plus two
pass but the supply of people with English speaking ability in this category is not
adequate.
Strategy: Constantly identify talent, recruit and train either in-house if scale of
operations permit that or through an outsourced training agency in case of smaller
operations.
Reason 2: People are joining with a short-term view and as a stepping stone to
something else.
Strategy: Create a culture and work environment that encourages people to think of a
call center job as a long-term career option. Use counseling by HR and line
management. This has to be backed up by demonstrated and perceived efforts by the
management to move up the value chain so that employees can clearly see that the
management is making efforts to create opportunities for upward mobility among
employees.
Reason 3: A lot of young people are taking up call center jobs just to earn some money
on the side and not as a serious and long-term career option.
Strategy: Create a culture and work environment that encourages people to think of a
call center job as a long-term career option. Use counseling by HR and line
management. Again this has to be backed up management efforts to move up the
knowledge continuum in terms of the processes handled.
Strategy: Redesign the compensation package for call center employees and try to pay
26
as much as possible in hard cash. Work out if necessary a new pay structure highly
skewed towards cash benefits.
Reason 5: Call center employees have an average age profile of 20-24 years, so they are
highly emotional, impulsive and immature when taking career decisions.
Strategy: following steps can be taken up by the HR department in order to satisfy their
employees.
27
Conclusion
With the strong growth expected in the Indian economy going ahead, it is clear that
human resources will be the key competitive advantage if the country has to sustain this
robust growth. Tackling attrition is not an easy task and the strategies suggested in the
report are not exhaustive to retain the human capital of BPOs. These are just the basics
and if implemented in a proper way can give good Results, but it can only become
effective when both employee & employer understand the importance of these
precautionary measures & continuously follow them only then this emerging &
growing sector will give its proper results.
28
Recommendations
After a detailed analysis of both the industries we find that a key step in designing an
effective retention strategy is to ensure you have the right tools to gauge employee
engagement. Investing in the measurement of employee engagement is a key element
of building the type of high-performance culture that drives business. According to the
study, regular or formal employee interaction with managers and interaction with
human resources are the two most common ways of gauging engagement levels in
organizations. We recommend the following points to be followed:
Recognizing the contribution of outstanding achievers also inspires others to try hard
and put in their best. A good organizational behavior also focuses on areas like training,
career development and believe in equipping workforce better on the professional
front. Good organizational behavior is instrumental in extending the tenure of
employees in the organization as it increases their self-esteem, confidence, morale and
motivation. A substantial growth of employee's self-esteem is as important as the
concept of learning in the industry. Otherwise, pharmaceutical organizations will meet a
sorry fate as far as retention policies are concerned.
Salary structure
Basic (54%),
HRA (26%),
PF Contribution (actual),
29
Tiffin Allowance (Rs 25-30 per day of attendance),
Loyalty Bonus (1 months’ salary after completion of each year in the company),
The EEE-Model
Exposure, Experience and Education are three things which are vital to any employee in
any sector or industry. These needs of the employees are needed to be taken care of for
an employee to feel motivated
An employee expects the company to give him good exposure in the kind of work he is
doing. Not only this, he needs to get a good experience working in the company from its
top management and colleagues. Monthly dinner with CEO of bonding programs with
the other employees of the BPO would be a good idea.
Also, some employees aspire for higher education to increase their knowledge base.
Some partnership with management institutes for short courses needs to be provided.
Alternatively, company can bear all the cost of further education for its good
performing employees.
30
EDUCATION
31
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www.citeman.com
www.naukrihub.com
www.pharmainfo.net
www.pharmaceutical-drug-manufacturer.com
www.investopedia.com
The Hindu 14 July 2008, Monday, business (newspaper).
Hewitt’s attrition and retention report 2006...
Stephens Robbins, Organizational behavior, Pearson education ( 2008) ,page 234.
32