You are on page 1of 538

MILTONOTES

An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Volume One

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Sound, Music & Technology

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/0eOohrVSkPXRUb4URBxa

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/35NLay3D8FdSFU45xYYjcv

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music Dawn of Music Notation Iraq:1800BC Cuneiform (melody in 3rds)

Ancient Greece: c.600BC Pitch and rhythm


The representation of music

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music c. 500BC Acousmatic

Pythagorus, Ionian philosopher, mathematician and musician (c.570-c.495BC)

Teaching behind the veil-readopted by Schaeffer as the veil of speakers The concept of sound as divorced from source The appreciation of sound for its own sake regardless of origin A numerical basis of sound

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music Development of Music Notation Byzantine Empire : c. 390AD differential pitch

Middle Ages Europe: c.850AD Grid system


The grid

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music Randomness in Music

Mozarts Dice Game (1787)


http://sunsite.univie.ac.at/Mozart/dice/

A Musical game for composing minuets and trios from dice rolls

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1857 E. Leon Scotts Phonautograph

Sound can now be made permanent, with one slight problem.

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1861 Philip Reis Telephone

Sound can now be transmitted across distances rapidly

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1863 Helmholtz publishes On the Sensation of Tone as a Physiological Basis for the Theory of Music

Basis of additive synthesis Any sound can - in theory - be constructed

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1874 Elisha Grays Musical Telegraph

Transmission of electronic polyphonic music

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1876 Thomas Edisons Phonograph

Sound can be recorded and reproduced

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music

Solidied sound wave

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1889 Claude Debussy at LExposition Universelle

Ocean of Sound and the birth of Ambient music

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1895 Thaddeus Cahills Telharmonium

The rst synthesiser

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1907 Busonis Sketch of a New Aesthetic of Music

The promise of electronic music

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1913 Russolos The Art of Noises

The democratising of all sound and the destruction of musical elitism

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1913 Russolos The Art of Noises

Wicked noise-makers

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1915 Varse moves to New York in search of a new music

I dream of instruments obedient to my thoughts and which with their contribution of a whole new world of unsuspected sounds, will lend themselves to the exigencies of my inner rhythm

Our musical alphabet must be enriched, I refuse to limit myself to sounds that have already been heard...What I am looking for is new mechanical mediums which will lend themselves to every expression of thought and keep up with thought

An organiser of sound

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1915 Lee De Forest patents vacuum tube

Miniaturisation of electronics

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1929 RCA releases the Theremin

Commercialisation of electronic instrument and in the 1930s the Terpsitone and Rhythmicon

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1924 Respighis The Pines of Rome

Blending of live and pre-recorded music

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1930 Hindemith and Tochs Grammophonmusik

Audio manipulation

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1948 Schaeffers Etude aux Chemin de Fer Musique Concrte

Found sound, sampling, looping, ltering reverb and the sound object

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1948 Nancarrows Studies for Player Piano

Bionic virtuosity

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1952 Cages 433

All sound considered

433 live version

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1952 Luening and Ussachevsky

Live effects

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1956 Louis & Bebe Barrons Forbidden Planet score

A working electronic music studio

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1957 The IIliac Suite The Birth of Computer Music

Live effects

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1958 Varses Pome Electronique

Major display of electronic work a graphic score with a familiar look

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1958 Dissevelts Whirling

Birth of pop electronic music

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1959 Cindy Electronium

Raymond Scott (1908-94) was a Jazz musician, jingle writer, electronic artist and inventor, and one of the earliest to fully adopt the music technology as a useful -and protable-part of the composer toolkit rather than esoteric experimentalism - similarly Stevie Wonder in the early 70s embraced the studio to make more efcient the compositional process

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1964 The Moog

The development of synthesis

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1971 NHK rst digital recording

The extraordinary rate of development of processors allows sound to be manipulated beyond physical constraints. And what used to be housed in 200 tons of hardware can be emulated while checking email. If cars developed like computers they would travel at 470,000 mph, get 100,000 miles to the litre, cost 2p, and could balance on a matchstick.

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music 1983 MIDI patented

A musical language for computers

Key Historical Events in Contemporary Computer Music

Now

Applied vs. Pure Music

How does computer composing differ from composing?

Additional Reading

Holmes, T., (2008) Electronic and Experimental Music, revised 3rd edition. New York: Routledge. Manning, P. (2004) Electronic and Computer Music .Oxford: Clarendon Press. Toop, D. (2001) Ocean of Sound. Serpents Tail.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Pulse, Tempo & Metre

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/17tSOtdKr1SWxaHx6gLmIV

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/35NLay3D8FdSFU45xYYjcv

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

Pulse Musical events in time

All music has some duration, and the occurrence of musical events over timerhythm. When there appears to be some underlying regularity of events this is the pulse or beat. Generally ranging from 20-330bpm

Pulse Tempo
Larghissimo very, very slow (20 bpm and below) Grave slow and solemn (2040 bpm) Lento slowly (4060 bpm) Largo broadly (4060 bpm) Larghetto rather broadly (6066 bpm) Adagio slow and stately (literally, "at ease") (6676 bpm) Adagietto rather slow (7080 bpm) Andante Moderato a bit slower than andante Andante at a walking pace (76108 bpm) Andantino slightly faster than andante Moderato moderately (101110 bpm) Allegretto moderately fast (but less so than allegro) Allegro moderato moderately quick (112124 bpm) Allegro fast, quickly and bright (120139 bpm) Vivace lively and fast (140 bpm) (quicker than allegro) Vivacissimo very fast and lively Allegrissimo very fast Presto very fast (168200 bpm) Prestissimo extremely fast (more than 200bpm)

Pulse Musical events in time

Some pieces or musical moments has no, little or an ambiguous sense of pulse. This will occur when there is insufcient regularity and/or if note events are illdened
Exercise 1: Compose an introduction to a piece where no pulse gives way to ambiguous and then clear pulse

Zero gravitation, John Adams

Pulse Tempo feel Even when pulse exists, it may be experienced at more than one level. This can be exploited as half-time or double-time feel. Where the music moves at the same rate, but the sense of pulse can alter.
Exercise 2: Compose a musical section and arrange it with normal, half and double-time feel.

Ray Charles, Wynton Marsalis

Pulse Tempo Changes


Boulezs conveyor belt

Fixed

Small Natural Fluctuations


During performance, unconscious or not.

Gradual Changes
Direction, shape, extent duration. rubato rallentando ritardendo ritenuto accelerando precipitando etc.

Sudden Shifts

Metronomic

Adjacent tempi can exist in simple rational relationships (double-time, half-time) more complex rational (e.g. 3:4, 5:4) or irrational

Pulse Tempo

Natural uctuations in James Brown, I Got You Millyard SOS

Pulse Tempo Curves


Accelerando speeding up (abbreviation: accel.) Allargando growing broader; decreasing tempo, usually near the end of a piece Calando going slower (and usually also softer) Doppio movimento double speed Meno mosso less movement or slower Mosso movement, more lively, or quicker, much like pi mosso, but not as extreme Pi mosso more movement or faster Precipitando hurrying, going faster/forward Rallentando gradual slowing down (abbreviation: rall.) Ritardando less gradual slowing down (more sudden decrease in tempo than rallentando)(abbreviation: specically, ritard.) Ritenuto slightly slower; temporarily holding back. (Note that the abbreviation for ritenuto can also be rit. specic abbreviation is riten. Also sometimes ritenuto does not reect a tempo change but a character chan Rubato free adjustment of tempo for expressive purposes Stretto in faster tempo, often near the conclusion of a section. Stringendo pressing on faster (literally "tightening")

(From wiki) what curves in terms of shape, duration, extent and direction might be associated with these terms?

Pulse Metric modulation


A shift from one tempo (or meter) to another via a pivotal note value For example

200bpm 100 bpm 2:1 q=e

Pulse Metric modulation

100bpm 150 bpm 2:3 q=q.

Pulse Metric modulation

100bpm 150 bpm 2:3 q=q.

Pulse Metric modulation

100bpm 80 bpm 5:4 qx=q (

Pulse Metric modulation

Tempo III Tempo I Tempo II


Exercise 3: Construct this tempo map in a short piece. Tempo I,II,III should exist in rational relationships of your choosing, and modulations should be pivotal. Complete with melodic and harmonic elements.

Tempo I

Pulse Metric modulation Exercise 2&3


from String Quartet No.1 Elliot Carter

Exercise 4a: Sequence this metric modulation passage, using melodic and harmonic elements. 4b: Design, notate as above and sequence your own metric modulation sequence

Pulse Polytempo and Xenochrony

It is possible for two or more tempi to exist at once, even if they have a very complex relationship. Charles Ives introduced the idea of polytempo and Zappa coined the term Xenochrony to describe the studio equivalent of superimposing different tempi.

Exercise 5: Create a sequence with two superimposed tempi

Meter
An introduction

Pulses or beats almost always exist in logical groups and in a hierarchy of strengths. This meter or time signature indicates how many beats - and what type of beat exist in each measure. Listening examples. Grouping in 2s and 3s

Exercise 6:Write a 4-bar groove in 4/4 and reinterpret in 5/8 or 5/4 and 7/8 and 7/4 Be fully aware of 2 and 3 groupings

Lecture 1 Compositional Exercises


Exercise 1: Compose an introduction to a piece where no pulse gives way to ambiguous and then clear pulse Exercise 2: Compose a musical section and arrange it with normal, half and double-time feel.

Tempo III Tempo I

Tempo I Tempo II

Exercise 3: Construct this tempo map in a short piece. Tempo I,II,III should exist in rational relationships of your choosing, and modulations should be pivotal. Complete with melodic and harmonic elements.

Exercise 4a: Sequence this metric modulation passage, using melodic and harmonic elements. 4b: Design, notate as above and sequence your own metric modulation sequence Exercise 5: Create a sequence with two superimposed tempi Exercise 6:Write a 4-bar groove in 4/4 and reinterpret in 5/8 or 5/4 and 7/8 and 7/4 Be fully aware of 2 and 3 groupings

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Meters, Patterns & Polymeter

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/2PUE08bmuKp9l7RL95NtSz

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/35NLay3D8FdSFU45xYYjcv

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

The Music There Is

@miltonline

The Music The

The Music Youve Heard

Make it a mission to expand this

Your best moves The Music You Like and Understand The Music You Like but Dont Understand

Educational

Inspiring

The Music You Dont Like But Understand

The Music You Dont Like and Dont Understand

Ideal

Understand = anything from being virtuosic in the idiom to appreciating the mechanics, skill and artistry within it

NB. this circle is a continuum not 4 distinct spaces Theres always more to learn and dont take your musical taste too seriously

.
So make this bigger, and move left and up within it.

@miltonline

Meter A Hierarchy of Pulse

The concept of pulse - an underlying unit of rhythmic regularity - has been established in Lecture 1. This regularity may occur at different levels, a concept that can be exploited in, for example half-time or doubletime feel, but there is usually one predominant tapalong pulse. However, this string of pulses - beats - are rarely entirely equal. There is a hierarchy.

Meter Types of Meters, Beats and Bars


Pulses or beats almost always exist in logical groups and in a hierarchy of strengths. This meter or time signature indicates how many beats - and what type of beat exist in each measure. For example 4/4 120bpm The crotchet is the predominant common pulse and they are grouped in 4 beats. 7/8 would imply that quavers are the common beats and are grouped in 7s

Meter Types of Meters, Beats and Bars


What determines the groups? Dynamic emphasis Rhythmic repetition Harmonic and melodic implications

Meter Listening and transcribing


What determines a bar? What repetition, harmonic and melodic exist? Can the rhythm be broken logically into 2-beat and 3-beat division. Clave 16 examples

Meter Son Clave

Meter Rumba Clave

Meter Bossa Clave

3-2

2-3 ( )

Meter Bulgarian Folk Dance


The exploration of meter in folk music is hugely extensive. In Bulgaria folk music alone, a rich history of dance forms has amassed many metric forms. Many may be considered additive, formed by an extension of beats. Here are 5 to transcribe

Paydushko horo Chetvorno horo Rachenitsa Petrunino horo Yovino Horo

Meter Bulgarian Folk Dance


The exploration of meter in folk music is hugely extensive. In Bulgaria folk music alone, a rich history of dance forms has amassed many metric forms. Here are 5: Transcribe your own.

Paydushko horo (2+3; 5/16 or 5/8) Chetvorno horo 3+2+2 or 3+4; 7/16) Rachenitsa (2+2+3 or 4+3; 7/16) Petrunino horo (3+3+2+3=11/16) Yovino Horo (3+3+ 2+2+3+ 2+2+3+ 2+2+2+2+3+2+2=35/16)

Meter Playing with beat divisions: Hemiola


A meter can stay constant while groupings change. A hemiola is a musical gure where 2 groups of 3 notes are followed or replaced with 3 groups of 2, implying-for example - a 6/8 to 3/4 change

Meter Comps
Here we look at a more complex rhythmic interaction from the Flamenco style

The Flamenco comps is a metric structure There are several types- many of them containing 12 beats. They are fully absorbed by the performers and this anchored, mutually felt rhythmic pattern allows for a high degree of rhythmic sophistication

Meter Comps Soleares

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Start This is the basic pattern but there is a huge repertoire of counter-rhythm hand claps, endings and rhythmic devices

Meter Comps Siguriyas

8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Long Start Short Long Short Short

A rhythmic mode of Soleares

Meter Comps Alegrias

12 + 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9 + 10 + 11 +
Start

Exercise 1: Clave/Compas. Select or better still, research/transcribe a metric template (from Bulgarian, South-American, Flamenco or other sources) and construct a groove/piece using the rhythmic structure.

Meter Changing Meter

Meters can change, sometimes this is quite natural and can go unnoticed simply adapting to accommodate a melody. Beatles All you Need is Love. 7/4 (or 4 + 3) bars are used very naturally

Meter Changing Meter

An example from the classical repertoire is Mussorgskys Pictures at an Exhibition (Promenade) Notice how a simple melodic motif is developed perfectly accessibly using changing meters.

Exercise 2: Compose or select a clear melodic phrase, and use meters of different lengths to develop and reinterpret the melody into a longer piece.

Meter Changing Meter


Meter changes can be extreme lurching the pulse and messing with your musical brain. Dream Theater Erotomania From guitar entry

2x 6x

5/4 (3 bars) + 9/8 (1 bar) 5/4 (3 bars) + 9/8 (1 bar) 5/4 (3 bars) + 3/4 (2 bars) + 2/4 (1 bar) 5/4 (3 bars) + 3/4 (2 bars) + 2/4 (1 bar) repeats 11/8 (3+3+3+2) 10/8 (3+3+2+2) 4/4 (2 bars) Solo in 5/4 etc.

Meter Changing Meter


Complex changing meters has a long history, lets look at the Sacricial Dance from Stravinskys seminal 1913 ballet The Rite of Spring

Exercise 3: Using the Sacricial Dance (pick at least 2 consecutive pages) as a metric template, compose meter-specic material, and then compose material that occurs less dependently on the structure. The overall metric implication may well be-for example 4/4 -with Stravinskys meter pattern embedded in some layer, or the meter pattern may be overt.

Polymeter (not polyrhythm)


Multiple meters may be implied at the same time. SImple examples may be a delay set to a triplet or dotted quaver. Often, during solos, a soloist can use phrase that imply different meters over an underlying groove, or rhythmic hits (Hancock -Hang Up Your Hang Ups 5:30 onwards) However many compositional examples exist even from pop music: The Cars Touch and Go has in the verse a 5/4 bass and drum pattern and a simultaneous 4/4 in the vocals and keys. The use of polymeter in 20th Century classical and contemporary metal is wide-spread. For example, Ligetis Arc-en-ciel implies different and changing meters (as well as polyrhythms) in each hand. Here are some more examples.

Polymeter
Hindemith - String Quartet no.3-II (0:05-0:19) analysis by Timothy Daust

Polymeter
Messiaen - La Verbe (2:18-2:23) analysis by Timothy Daust

Polymeter
Meshuggah - Rational Gaze (0:00-0:29) all Meshuggah analyses by Jonathan Pieslak

PolyMeter
Meshuggah - Stengah (0:16-0:48)

PolyMeter
Meshuggah - Humiliative (3:50-4:04)

PolyMeter
Meshuggah - New Millenium Cyanide Christ (0:00-0:25)

Benjamin Britten, Peter Grimes -Interlude IV


All Britten analyses 2008 Timothy Daoust

4+4+3 ostinato

Benjamim Britten, Peter Grimes Interlude IV (1:16)

Benjamim Britten, Peter Grimes Interlude IV (1:16)

Same passage re-scored

Exercise 4: Compose a piece with at least 2 simultaneous metric implications, make sure you understand how it interlocks.

Lecture 2 Compositional Exercises


Exercise 1: Clave/Compas. Select or better still, research/transcribe a metric template (from Bulgarian, South-American, Flamenco or other sources) and construct a groove/piece using the rhythmic structure.

Exercise 2: Compose or select a clear melodic phrase, and use meters of different lengths to develop and reinterpret the melody into a longer piece. Exercise 3: Using the Sacricial Dance (pick at least 2 consecutive pages) as a metric template, compose meter-specic material, and then compose material that occurs less dependently on the structure. The overall metric implication may well be-for example 4/4 -with Stravinskys meter pattern embedded in some layer, or the meter pattern may be overt. Exercise 4: Compose a piece with at least 2 simultaneous metric implications, make sure you understand how it interlocks.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Elements of Groove

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list:

http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7El79d9SdfBxnSwNruyAeD

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

Elements of Groove Ensemble and feel

Another enormous topic, but we will focus attention on two extraordinary rhythmic ensemble disciplines: Rhythmic patterns of Ashanti people of Ghana Hartigan (1995) and an analysis of several drum/bass/guitar grooves of the James Brown Rhythm Sections (1968-1973) Slutsky & Silverman (1997)

Elements of Groove Swing

Swing will be dened here as the difference in length between an on-beat and off-beat quaver (and on-beat and off-beat semiquaver). Rather than just a straight vs. triplet swung concept of swing.

Elements of Groove Swing

Elements of Groove Latency

Elements of Groove Time-feel

Elements of Groove Syncopation


Syncopation is the emphasis of weaker beats. By weaker beats we generally mean off-beat quavers and semiquavers. Although stressing beats 2 & 4 over 1 & 2 also falls into this category. How can off-beats be relatively more emphasised than an on-beat? No on-beat, or tied on-beat. Louder more articulated offbeat Melodic/Harmonic emphasis

Elements of Groove Identify the syncopated features

Elements of Groove Rhythmic Repetition


An addition to feel, interesting rhythmic/melodic components can sense a groove through repetition. Repeating phrase present a time-feel, and also create a sense of expectation allowing for musical variation.

Notice the repeated and slightly varied rhythmic device

Elements of Groove Rhythmic Displacement


Repeating rhythmic gures tend to occur at 1, 2 or 4 bar intervals. However a rhythmic gure can be repeated on a different beat of the bar. A simple displacement maybe 2 beats, where the beats strength is similar. Three beat displacements also occur as well as at other subdivisions, and create a subtle infectious polymetric feel.

Elements of Groove Rhythmic Displacement

3 - beat (dotted minim) displacement

dotted semi-quaver displacement - disrupting any swing/weighting that may exist

Rhythmic/melodic gures can also be repeated and displaced between instruments

Elements of Groove Elements of Ensemble Groove

Repetition/displacement of gures between instruments Time-feel: What is the overall feel of the ensemble, Is feel (swing etc.) the same between instruments? Are there any moments when a rhythmic gap in some instruments allows another instrument to feature? Is there a rhythmic interplay? Are there moments when more than one instrument synchronise material and play a similar rhythmic/ melodic gure (a sort of tutti)? What are the roles of each instrument? Time-keeping, feel, texture, rhyhmic interest. Do these roles change?

West African Drumming Ashanti People of Ghana

A richly syncopated drum tradition whose inuence may be heard in Cuban Son and Rumba, Haitian Vodun, Merengue of Dominican Republic, Brazilian samba and American Jazz.

West African Drumming Sikyi (Si-chee) Ashanti People of Ghana 1

Sikyi : Ashanti People of Ghana 2

Adowa : Ashanti People of Ghana 1

Adowa : Ashanti People of Ghana 2

Gahu : Ashanti People of Ghana 1

Gahu : Ashanti People of Ghana 2

Akom Style 1: Ashanti People of Ghana

Akom Style 2 (3/4) Metric Illusions

Akom Style 2 (6/8) Metric Illusions

Groove James Brown Rhythm Section (1960-1973) Identify the elements of time-feel, syncopation, repetition, displacement and ensemble techniques in these seminal grooves. Imitate, assimilate, innovate.

Think (1960)

Think (1960)

I Dont Mind (1962)

I Dont Mind (1962)

Out Of Sight (1964)

I Got You (1965)

Dont Be A Dropout (1966)

Cold Sweat Pt. 1 (1967)

Cold Sweat Pt. 1 (1967)

I Cant Stand Myself Pt. 1 (1967)

I Got The Feelin (1968) - Verse

I Got The Feelin (1968) - Bridge

Licking Stick (1968)

Give It Up or Turnit A Loose (1968) - Verse

Give It Up or Turnit A Loose (1968) - Bridge

Mother Popcorn (1969) - Verse

Mother Popcorn (1969) - Bridge

Funky Drummer (1969) - Pattern 1

Funky Drummer (1969) - Pattern 2

Get Up (1970) - Verse

Get Up (1970) - Bridge

Got To Getcha (1970) - Verse

Got To Getcha (1970) - Bridge

Funky Women (1970)

Super Bad Pts. 1 & 2 (1970) - Verse (1/2)

Super Bad Pts. 1 & 2 (1970) - Verse (2/2)

Super Bad Pts. 1 & 2 (1970) - Bridge

Talkin Loud & Sayin Nothing (1970) - Verse

Talkin Loud & Sayin Nothing (1970) - Bridge (1/2)

Talkin Loud & Sayin Nothing (1970) - Bridge (2/2)

Give It Up or Turnit A Loose Live (1970) - Verse

Give It Up or Turnit A Loose Live (1970) - Bridge

Hot Pants Pt. 1 (1971)

Make It Funky Pt. 1 (1971)

Papa Dont Take No Mess Pt. 1 (1973)

The Payback (1973) - Intro

The Payback (1973) - Verse

Lecture 3 Compositional Exercises

Exercise 1: Sequence the elements of an Ashanti Time-line of your choice. Make sure you can identify and have absorbed every part. Exercise 2: Create a piece using some (not necessarily all) of the elements from Exercise 1. You may wish to turn one pattern into a bass-line and bind some of the others to other melodic, harmonic and rhythmic instruments. Exercise 3: Recreate as accurately as possible with MIDI one of the sample James Brown grooves, paying particular attention to articulation and swing values. Exercise 4: Using features which you have absorbed from the James Brown templates, create your own 2, 4 or 8 bar groove, paying particular attention to time-feel. syncopation, repetition, displacement and ensemble mechanics.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Melodic Structures

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/1vWvLOvDYElkzQkuZr7Fp7

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7El79d9SdfBxnSwNruyAeD

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

Quick intermission before our scheduled Episode

Conceptualise (or fully compose) pieces based on each of the following images

This species of ant survive oods by hugging each other. The cluster oats but they would drown as individuals

Review
All episodes interlink, so frequent reviewing and re-contextualising of information is highly benecial

Polymeter Use Alignments

When a polymeter appears there will be a point in time when the barlines coincide. The effect of this event may be used musically.

Polymeter Use Break out Clauses


A polymetric phrase may be held indenitely, but often the implications is broken by added or subtracted beats to realign the measures.

Polymeter Use Melodic/Harmonic Adjustments

As polymetric phrases fall out of sync, some phrase can be adjusted at some point in their cycle to accommodate their new harmonic/ melodic environment

Polymeter Use Lateral thinking of polymeter

A single line may embody several musical features subject to meter, and hence polymeter: Note phrasing, dynamic emphasis, melodic emphasis, delay rate, pan rate, lter rate, trem rate and so on.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Melodic Structures

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Here we look deeply into the construction of melodies from a classical perspective although its implications run beyond stylistic constraints

Arnold Schoenberg (1874-51)

A radical traditionalist
2nd Viennese School, Fundamentals of Composition Harmonielehre

Melodic Structures
The Phrase

The smallest structural unit is the phrase, a kind of musical molecule consisting a number of integrated musical events possessing a certain completeness and well adapted to combination with other similar units. ...a unit approximating what one could sing in a single breath. Its ending suggests a form of punctuation such as a comma. Often some features appear more than once in a phrase. Such motivic characteristics will be discussed [later]

Melodic Structures
The Phrase

Concentrated in one voice, implies an inherent harmony

Melodic Structures
The Phrase

Even with elaborate melodies, harmony (usually I and V) is clear.

Melodic Structures
The Phrase

Length of phrases can vary widely, depending on metre and tempo

Melodic Structures
The Phrase from Chords

Phrases are often derived from skeletal chord forms

Melodic Structures
The Phrase from Chords

Simple elaborations of skeletal chord forms

Melodic Structures
The Phrase from Chords

Passing notes to chord forms

Melodic Structures
The Phrase from Chords, Elaborated

Passing notes and note repetitions to elaborated chord forms

Melodic Structures
The Phrase from Chords, Elaborated

Phrase embellishment

Melodic Structures
The Phrase from Chords, Elaborated

Appoggiaturas and changing tones.

Exercise 1a-f Compose 2 different simple phrases using chord tones of 1-3 chords in a major key(1a,1b), a minor key (1c,1d) and the dorian mode (1e,1f). Keep them very simple, clear and memorable. Exercise 2a-c Pick one phrase from each of the major, minor and dorian sets and elaborate using appoggiaturas, upbeats and other available devices.

Melodic Structures
The Motive (Motif)

Melodic Structures
The Motive (Motif)
If a phrase is a molecule, the motif is the atom, the smallest common multiple and greatest common factor providing unity, and through repetition, variation and recombination can form higher structures in the phrase and piece

Melodic Structures
The Motive (Motif)

Often the use of the motif is intuitive, though it neednt be. It forms the invisible musical glue that can unies and forms higher level structures

Melodic Structures
The Motive (Motif)

Usually dened by a simple rhythmic and intervallic structure, a motif is maintained by repetition of which there is: Exact and Modied Variations. Variations preserve some musical features and alter others

Melodic Structures
The Motive (Motif)

Note the simplicity of the motif, and how variations are slight but in different features

Melodic Structures
Motivic Transformations

Melodic Structures
Motivic Transformations

Melodic Structures
Motivic Transformations

Melodic Structures
Motivic Transformations

Melodic Structures
Motivic Transformations

Exercise 3 Write a simple motif, and create 12 variants (using for example, transpositions, elaborations, inversions, retrogrades, retrograde inversions, rhythmic changes, omissions and so on). Exercise 4 Construct a phrase (or 2 or 3) using combined variant forms of your motif from Exercise 3. Try and outline a harmonic sequence.

Melodic Structures
Melodic Structures from Phrases and Motifs

Although it may pain Schoenberg, lets look at phrase and motif construction over the course of a whole piece in the work of the French composer of stunningly progressive minimal work, Erik Satie (1866-1925)

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P1

2 scales, 3 chords, 1 piece

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P2

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P3

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P4

Exercise 5 Listen to, and examine the score of, Gnossienne I (or any Satie piece) See if you can identify key motifs (and variations) through phrases, as well as phrases and their repetitions and variations are put together to make the whole piece. Exercise 6 From the techniques observed in Exercise 4, choose a scale or 2, 3 or so chords, simple rhythms and limited motivic material, and a series of phrases. Create a short piece with a series of melodic phrases.

Exercise 1a-f Compose 2 different simple phrases using chord tones of 1-3 chords in a major key(1a,1b), a minor key (1c,1d) and the dorian mode (1e,1f). Keep them very simple, clear and memorable. Exercise 2a-c Pick one phrase from each of the major, minor and dorian sets and elaborate using appoggiaturas, upbeats and other available devices. Exercise 3 Write a simple motif, and create 12 variants (using for example, transpositions, elaborations, inversions, retrogrades, retrograde inversions, rhythmic changes, omissions and so on). Exercise 4 Construct a phrase (or 2 or 3) using combined variant forms of your motif from Exercise 3. Try and outline a harmonic sequence Exercise 5 Listen to, and examine the score of, Gnossienne I (or any Satie piece) See if you can identify key motifs (and variations) through phrases, as well as phrases and their repetitions and variations are put together to make the whole piece. Exercise 6 From the techniques observed in Exercise 4, choose a scale or 2, 3 or so chords, simple rhythms and limited motivic material, and a series of phrases. Create a short piece with a series of melodic phrases.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Phrase, Contour & Melodic Forms

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/0IIbAhOvRgGeKhtqc8NXaZ

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7El79d9SdfBxnSwNruyAeD

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

The concepts of motif and phrase have been dened, as well as principles behind their construction and transformation. Lets see how these manifest to form successful melodies in the real world and how we might use these ideas in composition. Key terms: Motif, Phrase, Endings, Intervals, Phrase Hierarchy, CTs, NCTs, Devices, Range, Contour, Diatonicism, Parallelism, Leaps & Lines, Accel/decceleration, Melodic forms.

Endings
Similar

How a phrase ends is often of particular melodic importance. You may notice that different phrases often have similar endings.
Phrase 1

Phrase 2 has unequal length, different starting material but similar motifs and an identical ending, forming a link with Phrase 1

Endings
Modied

Conversely, a phrase may be repeated with small modications to the ending, to create different degrees of resolution even with similar harmony
Phrase A1.1 Phrase A1.2 Phrase A1.1 Phrase A1.3

Phrase A1

Phrase A2

This introduces the concept of phrase hierarchy Phrases made up of smaller phrases which can be modied and recombined

Endings Major
Degrees of Resolution

Minor

Heres an impression of resolution level of diatonic notes in a major scale devoid of harmony (the same categories work for minor also) Its very dependent on content but is a reasonable starting point. Note that the idea of resolution here is independent from consonance/ dissonance - the sound of a note against the underlying harmony.

Chromaticism
Degrees of Resolution

Major

Minor

These are highly context dependent and not hard rules - there are also other settings other than major or minor that can be established, but the idea of varying degrees of melodic resolution is fundamental. Again, this about melodic resolution not consonance/dissonance - the latter being controlled by harmonic context.

Phrase Construction
Degrees of Resolution
We can now see how a sense of resolution (from stable to unstable) can be established between phrases giving a longer arc to melodic construction. This is a fundamental concept in 1000s of melodies.

Resolution Unstable #4 Stable Root

Phrase A1

Phrase A2

from Gnossienne 1 - Satie

Endings
Degrees of Resolution

Exercise 1 Write two different phrases that share identical resolving endings Exercise 2 Write two phrases with the same (or no) harmony, but with a different note choices at the ending, creating different degrees of resolution.

Phrase Endings & Harmony


Linking phrases with similar or modied endings

Sub-divide into 2 levels of phrases noting areas of stability/instability and how harmony accommodates the melody

Phrase Endings & Harmony


Linking phrases with similar or modied endings

from Across the Universe - Beatles

Note that melody notes, melodic rhythm and harmony all combine to create a multi-layer musical experience

Phrase Endings & Harmony


Linking phrases with similar or modied endings

from Angel Eyes - Matt Dennis

Note the use of varied phrase endings, motivic editing and transformation with harmony

Phrase Endings & Harmony


Linking phrases with similar or modied endings

Note the use of varied phrase endings, motivic editing and transformation with harmony

Phrase Endings & Rhythm


Strength of ending
Rhythm contributes to the sense of nality of a phrase (not that a phrase always needs it). The strength of the beat on which the phrase ends contributes to a sense of continuity or nality.

1 Strong

&

&

&

&

Weak

&

&

&

&

Phrases & Rhythm

Exercise 2a Write 3 similar phrases with different strengths of ending Exercise 2b Write 3 similar phrases but starting on different beats

Melody Contour & Range


Melodic Typology
Although there are millions of possible melodies, analysts have proposed systems to categorise them into various groups. We wont favour one but at least look at the various identifying features. Range (Highest to lowest notes) Contour (Position of highest and lowest notes) Leap & Line (Stepwise motion or intervallic leaps) Long Term Goals (A journey between 2 notes) Chopin Motivic Material (Identifying motifs or articulations) Scale/Diatonicism/Chromaticism (Set of notes used) Consonance/Dissonance (How the melody interacts with harmony)

Melody Contour & Range


Melodic Typology

Exercise 3a-b Write a melody with specic ideas for the features identied previously. Write another melody from the previous by changing. 2 of the features

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

In addition, to melodic resolution, there is another important musical layer: The consonance and dissonance of a melody against the harmony. The most consonant melodic approach is to use only chord tones (CTs)

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

NCTs of course can be used, and there are techniques for resolving dissonances. Here Passing Tones (PTs), Diatonic Sequences and Chord Tones Pivots.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody from a chord sequence. A Theme and Variations concept (Paganini Caprice 24) This allows the creation of certain canonic forms where material that functions of the same harmony can be superimposed

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Exercise 4 Write a 4-bar chord sequence, and an accompanying melody using CTs, create 3 subsequent phrases on the chord sequence

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

NCTs can be left unresolved as part of a melody and will produce a varying amount of dissonance against the underlying harmony, for which the next page give a general impression of this continuum.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance
This schematic shows the continuum of consonance and dissonance with reference to the chordal context (ie if we are looking at a ii or a iii chord, a I or a IV etc. There are some exceptions to this, for example the use of the b3(aka #9) in a major context, which is a stylistically perfectly accepted dissonance in many AfricanAmerican sourced music forms (Jazz, Blues and by assoiciation Rock, pop, funk etc.)

CTs

Diatonic Non-Clash NCTs

Non-Diatonic Non-Clash NCTs

Diatonic Clash NCTs

Non-Diatonic Clash NCTs

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

From another perspective we can look at common dissonances - also known as tensions or extensions and have a quick look at what contexts they are accepted, other than a passing tone or other melodic device.

b9 (aka b2)

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

b9 (aka b2)
This can be sometimes found unresolved when it is a diatonic. Eg. an F against an Eminor in the key of C, or against an E major in A harmonic minor. It is common against the one chord scales with a b2 eg. Phyrgian (F against E minor in E phrygian) or in Spanish Phrygian (F against E major) and the like. (Caravan, Miserlou for example) It also appears on a major or dominant chord that is acting as a primary or secondary dominant, particularly (but not exclusively) when resolving to a minor chord. Other than this it is rare when non-diatonic.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

9
This is the most common dissonant non chord tone, and appears freely on a major, minor, dominant, major 7 chord etc. It is only rare when non diatonic e.g. on a iii chord in a major key, but non diatonic examples are found particularly in a parallel context. Every Breath You Take,(Police) or Twin Peaks Theme shows its diatonic usage, while Castles Made of Sand, Come On Pt.1 (1:16) and Little Wing (Hendrix) has parallel non-diatonic examples.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

#9
Acting as a blue note on a major or dominant chord is a commonly accepted melodic dissonance on any resolving dominant chord or over any I major or I dominant chord or general tonality. Its use on the IV or IV7 chord is actually quite rare due to the peculiarity of a b6 over b3. Examples of a b3 in major/dominant context abound.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

11(4)
Although traditionally a dissonance that requires resolution, the 11th (or 4) is often left unresolved on a I chord a major or dominant context (being diatonic), and is common on minor chord as there is no clash with the 3rd. It is a little more rare, but still heard, in a non-diatonic form (e.g. on the IV chord in major, the IV chord in blues however tolerates it easily due to the pentatonic context). All minor chords (and half-diminished chords) happily accept the 4th melodically although non-diatonic uses are a bit more rare.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

#11(#4)

The #11 is a common NCT on major, major7 and dominant chords. The least dissonan use is diatonic e.g. Chord IV in major, Chord I in Lydian or bVImaj in a minor (or borrowed minor) context. It is also often used on tritone-substituted dominant chords. However it is common particular in jazz-tinged styles to include on major, major7 and dominant chords and on minor chords in a Satie-esque exotic moments. (Blue 7 dominant, Satie minor, Blue in Green Major)

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

b6(b13)
The b6 or b13 with the presence of the 5th is quite a strong dissonance often quickly resolved The exception being on resolving dominant chords (particularly to minor chords) where it is often supported.

Melody & Harmony


Consonance & Dissonance

6(13)
The 6 or 13 in the melody, unless non-diatonic is readily supported by major, minor and dominant chords alike.

Giant Steps - John Coltrane Notice how accepted NCTs are used alongside to marry a memorable melody and a complex chord sequence

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic Features

Exercise 5 Write a melody devoid of harmony. Harmonise it in 3 ways so that all notes are in example a) All chord tones b) Resolved dissonances c) Accepted NCTs

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic features

Traditional melodies usually have a few leaps using chord tones and devices, and the rest of the material step wise. However it is possible to use less traditional intervals as important melodic motifs.

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic features

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic features

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic features

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic features

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic Features

Exercise 6 Write a melody based on extended intervals (4th,5ths and 7ths) or interval structures ( for example +2,+7,-1) using accepted NCTs

Melody & Harmony


Pedal Tone/Pitch Axis
Youll notice that the more angular examples of intervallic tunes had less (or no chords) Since harmony dictates consonance and dissonance, we can open up melodic possibilities by simplifying the harmonic context. For example a drone permits a wide array of scales to be implied compositionally (or through improvisation). Indian classical music (discussed later) is monophonic and allows an enormous amounts of expressive melodies unconstrained by even temperament. Even limiting ourselves to a 7 note system, even temperament, only one type of degree and no b4, Saties F-minor chord (on which he uses Dorian #4 and Melodic Minor #4) actually has 16 logically accompanying modes and scales.

b2 4 b6 or b3 or 5 or 2 #4 6

b7 or 7

Melody & Harmony


Pedal Tone/Pitch Axis

b2 4 b6 or b3 or 5 or 2 #4 6
Phrygian #4 Aeolian #4 Dorian #4

b7 or 7
Dorian b2/#4 Mel. Min b2/#4

Phrygian Aeolian Dorian

Dorian b2 Mel. Min b2

Melodic Minor Harmonic Minor Harmonic Minor b2

Melodic Minor #4 Harmonic Minor #4 Harmonic Minor b2/#4

Melody & Harmony


Pedal Tone/Pitch Axis
Ravels Bolero (1928) is an orchestral work based almost exclusively on a bass ostinato (bass loop) which includes only a C and G. This allows the insistent melody to be transformed into several parallel beautiful scales while maintaining musical interest.

French composer Maurice Ravel (1875-1937)

Melody & Harmony


Pedal Tone/Pitch Axis
Bolero Modes C Major (R,2,3,4,5,6,7) C Mixolydian b6 (Aeolian Major/Hindustani/Mode 5 of MM) (R,2,3,4,5,b6,b7) C Phrygian (R,b2,b3,4,5,b6,b7) C Phrygian Dominant (R,b2,3,4,5,b6,b7) E Mixolydian b6 E Phrygian

Melody & Harmony


Pedal Tone/Pitch Axis
. Take the bridge of Satch Boogie - Joe Satriani for example The A acts as a pivot to a menagerie of exotic scales/harmonies.

Melody & No Harmony

Or no harmony whatsoever as in Debussys Syrinx unpublished in his life time.

my favorite music is those few notes an Egyptian shepherd plays on his ute: he is a part of the landscape around him, and he knows harmonies that arent in our books.

The opening phrase elaborates the notes of a whole-tone scale (Bb, Ab, Gb, E). The whole-tone scale is incompatible with common-practice harmony, because it contains no 5ths and no half steps, making traditional cadences impossible and eliminating tonic-dominant polarity. Debussy used whole-tone scales in many works as a way to confound his listeners tonal expectations and to explore new harmonic possibilities. Here, though, he does not limit himself to the whole-tone scale. He decorates it with chromatic neighbors and passing tones in the first two measures (A,B,G, F). In measure 4 he exchanges it for an ascending chromatic scale (Bb, B, C, Db).

In measure 11 he turns to a pentatonic scale (Gb, Ab, Bb, Db, Eb) with an added note (F). In measure 15, which begins the middle section of the piece, he uses a fully chromatic scale.

At measure 26 (the recapitulation) he returns to the initial whole- tone scale. Then in the very last measure he switches to the other possible whole-tone scale (B, A, G, F, Eb, Db), which is how the piece ends. In this very short piece Debussy exchanges pitch materials almost compulsively, but he steadfastly avoids the major- minor diatonic scale.

Melody & Harmony


Intervallic Features

Exercise 7 Write a melody over a 2, 1 or 0 note ostinato, exploring scales which the harmony allows.

Exercise 1 Write two different phrases that share identical resolving endings Exercise 2 Write two phrases with the same (or no) harmony, but with a different note choices at the ending, creating different degrees of resolution. Exercise 3a-b Write a melody with specic ideas for the features identied previously. Write another melody from the previous by changing. 2 of the features Exercise 4 Write a 4-bar chord sequence, and an accompanying melody using CTs, create 3 subsequent phrases on the chord sequence Exercise 5 Write a melody devoid of harmony. Harmonise it in 3 ways so that all notes are in example a) All chord tones b) Resolved dissonances c) Accepted NCTs Exercise 6 Write a melody based on extended intervals (4th,5ths and 7ths) or interval structures ( for example +2,+7,-1) using accepted NCTs Exercise 7 Write a melody over a 2, 1 or 0 note ostinato, exploring scales which the harmony allows.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Chance & Translation

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/4XZkQfATo0nIycKYL91QTH

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7El79d9SdfBxnSwNruyAeD

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

This episode we look at approaches to composition, that in some way have delegated decisions to outside inuences such as the use of chance and indeterminacy in composition, cryptograms and the sonication of nonmusical data and physical processes.

Why?

Indeterminacy (like improvisation) and chance could be a component (big of small) of composition. From making a series of randomised chords, or predetermined motif work or the effective use of a noise wave-form LFO.

The transfer of non-musical data (for example someones initials converted to a motif, or a key from another piece) can act as a form of tribute, signature or aesthetic link. It can also act as a compositional challenge and selfimposed to enhance creativity and encourage new musical ideas.

The delegation of compositional control, has a philosophical implication. Can a composer create a piece that includes elements out of her control? At what degree of uncertainty, white noise LFO or level of improvisation does it no longer become the piece? Can we just point at a sound (like 433) and claim it as a piece? Which parts are important? Cadenza to Jazz to Electronica

Chance and Aleatoric Music

Chance

The use of chance in composition has a varied and long heritage. Dening chance or aleatoric music as music in which some element of the composition is left to chance would imply many types and degrees of chance music.

Chance

Types of randomness Range Step Dotted or Drunk

Chance

Ockeghems Missa Culuvsis Toni


A composition by Johannes Ockeghem (1410-97) which allows a choice of modal interpretations. One composition: multiple realisations.

Chance

Determined

Left to chance/ Indeterminant

Using this very simple system allows a more nuanced and useful understanding of chance music

Chance

Determined
Melodic contour, rhythms, structure, text etc.

Indeterminate
Which 1 of 4 Modes

Chance

Mozarts Dice Game (1787)


http://sunsite.univie.ac.at/Mozart/dice/

A Musical game for composing minuets and trios from dice rolls

Chance

Mozarts Dice Game Determined


Harmonic structure Form Set of motifs

Left to chance
Which of the set of motifs are selected

Chance

DuChamps Erratum Musical (1913)


Composition by the dadaist artist Marcel DuChamp. A xed number of pre-determined notes (and words in the vocal version) from a set of possibilities are randomly selected to form the work.

Chance

Duchamps Erratum Musical Determined


Prepared materials Number of events

Left to chance
The order and which of the musical fragments are selected

Chance

Cages Williams Mix (1952)


Environmental sounds collected over 9 months by the Barrons, then tape-spliced according to a set of rules determined by coin tosses.

Chance

Cages Williams Mix Determined


Prepared environmental materials Length of piece Operations

Left to chance
Which operations on which tracks

Chance

Cages 433 (1952)


Measured Silence Focusing attention on unintended sound

Chance

Cages 433 Determined


Duration(s) Time Place

Left to chance
Everything else

Chance

The Use of Randomness in Synthesis


Noise wave as tone Noise wave as LFO (with continuous and step values)

Chance

1 Layer of Randomness

Chance

2 Layers of Randomness

Chance

3 Layers of Randomness

Chance

Randomness and Creativity


The forcing of new ideas

Random Word Generator

Chance

Exercise 1 Write a musical passage which divides various musical features into determined, and randomly generated. Render some versions. Exercise 2 Alter which of the features in Exercise 1 are determined or random and render some versions. Exercise 3 Create a synth line (or several layers) experimenting with controlling LFOs with step and/or continuous noise functions. Exercise 4 Randomly generate an adjective and noun, and create the opening (or all) of a work based on the phrase. Repeat with a different randomly generated phrase.

So compositions can allow areas and degrees of randomness and indeterminacy. From interpretation, cadenzas, jazz to extremely random. Pockets of chaos But they can also include pre-determined material, (overt or hidden).

Translation Cryptogram

The BACH motif


(B = Bb H=B S= Eb)

Acting as a tribute, or a test of compositional skill, the Bach motif has appeared in 100s of works since the 17th century.

Translation Cryptogram

The BACH motif

Contrapunctus V (2:20)

Contrapunctus IV

Translation Cryptogram

The BACH motif

The unnished Contrapunctus XIV, C.P.E. Bachs


("At the point where the composer introduces the name BACH [for which the English notation would be B-A-C-B ] in the countersubject to this fugue, the composer died."

Translation Cryptogram

The BACH motif

Schumann: Sechs Fugen ber den Namen: Bach No. 4 & 5 (1845)

Translation Cryptogram

The BACH motif

Webern Tone Row String Quartet Op. 28

Translation Cryptogram

The BACH motif


1845 Robert Schumann: Sechs Fugen ber den Namen: Bach, for organ, pedal piano, or harmonium, Op. 60 1855 Franz Liszt: Fantasy and Fugue on the Theme B-A-C-H, for organ (later revised, 1870, and arranged, 1871, for piano) 1878 Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov: Variations on BACH, for piano 1900 Max Reger: Fantasia and Fugue on B-A-C-H for organ 1910 Ferruccio Busoni: Fantasia contrappuntistica for piano (rst version; later versions 1912 and 1922) 192628 Arnold Schoenberg: Variations for Orchestra, Op. 31 193738 Anton Webern: String Quartet (the tone row is based on the BACH motif) 1968 - Alfred Schnittke: Quasi Una Sonata 1981 - Schnittke: Symphony No. 3 - used alongside the monograms of several other composers. 1856 - Johannes Brahms: Fugue in A-at minor for organ, WoO 8 1930 - Marios Varvoglis: Canon, Chorale and Fugue on BACH 1932 - Alfredo Casella: Due Ricercari sul nome B-A-C-H, Op. 52 1932 - Francis Poulenc: Valse-improvisation sur le nom Bach for piano 1934 - Hanns Eisler: Prelude and Fugue on B-A-C-H, Op. 46 for string trio 1937 - Marios Varvoglis: Prelude, Chorale and Fugue on BACH 1942-46 - Charles Koechlin: Offrande musicale sur le nom de B-A-C-H, Op. 187 1952 - Jean Coulthard: Variations on BACH for piano 1952 - Luigi Dallapiccola: Quaderno musicale di Annalibera for piano 1954 - Dallapiccola: Variazioni ("Variations", orchestral version of Quaderno musicale di Annalibera) 1951-55 - Dallapiccola: "Canti di liberazione" 1964 - Arvo Prt: Collage over B-A-C-H for strings, oboe, harpsichord and piano 1974 - Rudolf Brucci: Metamorfosis B-A-C-H for strings 1993 - Ron Nelson: Passacaglia (Homage on B-A-C-H) for concert band

Translation Cryptogram

What about other letters/notes?

Translation Cryptogram

German System
A=A B = Bb C=C D=D E=E F=F G=G H=B M=E L=A R(e) = D S (Es) = Eb T(i) = B As = Ab Ignore the rest

Translation Cryptogram

French System A H (or B) O V B


(or Bb)

C J Q X

D K R Y

E L S Z

F M T

G N U

I P W

Translation Cryptogram

Alban Berg/Hanna Fuchs-Robettin

A, Bb, B, F

Bergs Lyric Suite

Translation Cryptogram

Arnold Schoenberg

A, Eb, C, B, Bb, E, G

Schoenbergs Seraphita

Translation Cryptogram

Brahms

Bb, A, B, Eb

Schnittkes Quasi Una Sonata

Translation Cryptogram

Haydn

B, A, D, D, G

Ravels Menuet sur le nom dHaydn

Translation Cryptogram

Bla Brtok

Bb, E, B, A

Translation Cryptogram

Cage

C, A, G, E

Pauline Oliveros and Simon Jeffes of PCO in Cage Dead

Translation Cryptogram

Dimitri Schostakovich

D, Eb, C, B
In many of Schostakovichs work, and tributes to him. String Quartet No. 8

Translation Cryptogram

Sacher Hexachord

Eb, A, C, B, E, D
Swiss conductor and patron Paul Sacher, used by Babbitt and Boulez (Messagequisses)

Translation Cryptogram

Robert Schumann

Eb, C, B, A

Used in Schumanns Carnaval (in SCHA, ASCH and AsCH forms)

Translation Cryptogram

Niels Gade

G, A, D, E
The monogram for Danish composer Niels Gade (1817-1890) is used in Schumanns Nordische Lied No.41, Op.68

Translation Cryptogram

Cross Motif Symbol from Gregorian Melodies

Franz Lizst (1811-86)

Translation Cryptogram

Cross Motive Crucixion and star-crossed lovers

Tchaikovsky (1840-93) mm1-2 of Pathtique Symphony

Translation Cryptogram

Exercise 5 Create your own monogram using the German or French system. Compose a phrase/passage/piece of your signature. Experiment with motivic transformations (R, I, RI), phrase constructions, harmonisations etc. Exercise 6 Generate another cryptogram for someone (or something) else. Compose a phrase/passage/piece interweaving this, and your monogram.

Translation Other Mappings

Amusical

Musical

Letters in a name

Note names

Translation Other Mappings

Amusical

Musical

Letters from anywhere

Any pitch

Translation Other Mappings

ASCII to midi note conversion

Translation Other Mappings

DNA ASCII MIDI

A 65 F3

C 67 G3

T 84 C5

G 71 B3

DNA to midi note conversion

Translation Other Mappings


AAA AAC AAT AAG ACA ACC ACT ACG ATA ATC ATT ATG AGA AGC AGT AGG CAA CAC CAT CAG CCA CCC CCT CCG CTA CTC CTT CTG CGA CGC CGT CGG TAA TAC TAT TAG TCA TCC TCT TCG TTA TTC TTT TTG TGA TGC TGT TGG GAA GAC GAT GAG GCA GCC GCT GCG GTA GTC GTT GTG GGA GGC GGT GGG

Codon permutations

Translation Other Mappings

Amusical

Musical

Letters from anywhere

Rhythm

Translation Other Mappings

ee

xxe xex exx

xx x

.x

A L W

B M X

C N Y

D O Z

E P

F Q

G R

H S

I T

J U

K V

One of countless letter to rhythm mapping templates Letter frequency and rhythmic sets will play a compositional role

Translation Rhythmic Mapping

Exercise 7 Create a rhythmic pattern from the given - or your own - mapping template using your name, initials or somesuch.

Exercise 8 Combine a rhythmic with a melodic mapping template, you may want to use two source names so that for example all As arent the same length.

Translation Types of Mappings

Discrete/Continuous One to One One to Many Many to One Parallel

Translation Villa-Lobos (1857-1959)

Brazilian Composer

Translation Villa-Lobos millimetrization

New York Skyline

Translation Villa-Lobos millimetrization

New York Skyline Melody (1939) and more

Translation Mapping

Exercise 9 Create a melody from an image. Harmonise.

Translation Other Mappings

Amusical

Musical

Vertical Horizontal

Pitch Time/Rhythm

Translation Data Soniciation

Why stop at 2 discrete dimensions? How much can be extracted? What data can be used?

Translation Data Soniciation

Primal Sound (2004,2007)


The coronal suture of the skull (which should now be chiey investigated) has let us assume a certain similarity to the closely wound line that the needle of a phonograph cuts into the receptive, revolving cylinder of the machine. Suppose, for instance, one played a trick on this needle and caused it to retrace a path not made by the graphic translation of a sound, but selfsufcing and existing in nature good, let us say it boldly, if it were (e.g.) even the coronal suture what would happen? A sound must come into being, a sequence of sounds, musicFeelings of what sort? Incredulity, awe, fear, reverence yes, which of all these feelings prevents me from proposing a name for the primal sound that would then come to birth? Ur-Gerusch (Rilke 1919, p 1087)

Primal Sound (2004,2007)

Image 2004 Palmer

Primal Sound (2004,2007)

Image 2005 Supranowitz

Primal Sound (2004,2007)

Primal Sound (2004,2007)

Primal Sound (2004,2007)

Angela Palmers Inside Out exhibition ! Ruskin Gallery, Oxford University, UK. 2 February 2004. ! Royal College of Surgeons, Hunterian Museum, UK. 29 January 19 May 2007. Music of the Body exhibition !Science Circus, Guildford, Surrey, UK. 20 September 2008.

Translation Data Soniciation

Head Music (2004)

Translation Data Soniciation

Microcosmos (2007)

Generative Composition Emergent Music

Translation Data Soniciation

Translation Mapping

Exercise 10 Create your own mapping system from a data source and realise it compositionally.

Exercise 1 Write a musical passage which divides various musical features into determined, and randomly generated. Render some versions. Exercise 2 Alter which of the features in Exercise 1 are determined or random and render some versions. Exercise 3 Create a synth line (or several layers) experimenting with controlling LFOs with step and/or continuous noise functions. Exercise 4 Randomly generate an adjective and noun, and create the opening (or all) of a work based on the phrase. Repeat with a different randomly generated phrase. Exercise 5 Create your own monogram using the German or French system. Compose a phrase/passage/piece of your signature. Experiment with motivic transformations (R, I, RI), phrase constructions, harmonisations etc. Exercise 6 Generate another cryptogram for someone (or something) else. Compose a phrase/passage/piece interweaving this, and your monogram. Exercise 7 Create a rhythmic pattern from the given - or your own - mapping template using your name, initials or somesuch. Exercise 8 Combine a rhythmic with a melodic mapping template, you may want to use two source names so that for example all As arent the same length. Exercise 9 Create a melody from an image. Harmonise. Exercise 10 Create your own mapping system from a data source and realise it compositionally.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Process

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/4YtsVORmc2f7BDYJGBBrNG

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7El79d9SdfBxnSwNruyAeD

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

Process

This episode deals with the use of compositional systems from the simple to highly complex, and using physical and algorithmic processes. Compositional systems may be used quite freely to introduce creative options, or at the furthest extreme as a hands-off process that might be heard clearly by the listener.

Process

Joseph Schillenger System of Musical Composition (1946)

Comprehensive system on many musical aspects beyond prevailing tutor books - an attempt at scientic unication

Process

Schillinger System: Permutations in melody and pitch scales

Process

Schillinger System: Permutations in scales, modulation and harmony

Process

Schillinger System: Rhythmic permutation (3+1)+(2+2)+(1+3)

Process

4:3 (3+1)+(2+2)+(1+3) 6:5 (5+1)+(4+2)+(3+3)+(2+4)+(1+5)

Realise in terms of rhythm, melody, harmony etc.

Process
Exercises

Exercise 1 Write a passage of music using the Schillinger system on rhythm, melody and/or harmony.

Process

Score for Metastasis (1953-54) Iannis Xenakis (1922-2001) deep mathematical and music connection.

Process

La Monte Young - Poem (1960)

Avant-Garde composer. Predetermined dragging of chairs and benches as well as drone music and minimalism

Process

Ligetis Poeme Mechanique (1962)


Simultaneous tempi and wind down.

Process
Exercises

Exercise 2 Simulate musically a physical process (e.g. metronomes, drips, popcorn, tides, orbits etc.

Process

Terry Rileys In C (1964)

Superimposition of 53 randomly started musical fragments First minimal piece.

Process

Steve Reich - Its Going to Rain (1965)

Tape piece for phased vocal phrase. Slow technological phasing. Aural examination of a preachers voice and pigeon. South Bank Show documentary (Rain) http://www.youtube.com/watch? v=q0DQRfm0uL8 or start watching entire documentary here (recommended): http:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_pR1sHHeQU&feature=related Complete piece http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x90h1r_steve-reich-its-gonna-rainpart-1_music

Process

Ligetis Lux Aeterna (1966)

Canonic structures and superimpositions that dont t traditional harmony, but form powerful compelling textures

Process

Ligetis Lux Aeterna (1966)

analysis Jarviepp

Process

Process

Process

Steve Reich - Piano Phase (1967) Violin Phase (1967) Phase Patterns (1970)

Algorithmic cyclical process whereby motifs are micro-rhythmically transformed to rhythmic displacements. 12-note, 8-note, 4-note phase
"I am interested in perceptible processes. I want to be able to hear the process happening throughout the sounding music. What I'm interested in is a compositional process and a sounding music that are one and the same thing" - Steve Reich

Process

Steve Reich - Pendulum Music (1968)

Piece formed by the gravitational pull of swinging microphones and feedback responses

Process

Frederic Rzewski - Les Moutons des Panurge

(1968)

Carter & Rzewski Written for any number of musicians playing melody instruments, plus any number of nonmusicians playing anything, contains a 65-note melody in F played in a cumulative sequence (1, 1-2, 1-2-3, and so on) by the entire ensemble in unison; once the entire melody is played, the sequence is reversed with the melody continued, but with notes from the beginning shed with each repetition (2-3-...65, 3-4-...65, and so on), until only one note remains. That nal note is held until all the players have reached it, at which point all begin improvising. Rzewskis instructions are: Always play loud, never stop or falter, stay together as long as you can, but if you get lost, stay lost. Do not try to nd your way back into the fold. Continue to follow the rules strictly.

Process

Karlheinz Stockhausen - Spiral (1968)

A composition as a series of xed transformations rather than a xed structure.

Process

James Tenney - For Ann (Rising) (1969)

Shepperd Tone piece http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqRd555v0Hg

Process

Steve Reich - Clapping Music (1972)

Piece for 2 performers formed by 12-point displacement of rhythmic motif.

Process

Alvin Lucier - I Am Sitting In a Room (1974)

Degradation through room resonance

Process

Brian Eno - Discreet Music (1975)

With delay and varying EQ a motivic phrase automatically generates an ambient soundworld. Album also includes pieces derived from fragments of Pachelbels Canon in D

Process

Alvin Lucier - Music on a Long Thin Wire (1979)

Oscillations and interferences on a wire

Process

James Tenney - Chromatic Canon (1980)

Tone Row slowly unfolded then collapsed

Process

Steve Reich - Electric Counterpoint (1987)

Process Principles attached to longer scale harmonic form (See New York, and Cello Counterpoint)

Process
Exercises

Exercise 3 Write a piece of music based on an overt Reichian process.

Process

Algorithmic Construction

Thomas Tallis (1505-1585) Spem in Alium

Process

Algorithmic Construction

Process

Algorithmic Construction

5,8 OMNIA558

Process

Algorithmic Construction

Process

Algorithmic Construction

Process

Algorithmic Construction

Process

Algorithmic Construction

Process

Process

Digital Technology and Process

Computer processing has been harnessed since the 50s in order to provide composers with new ideas as well as algorithmically generated pieces. Even creating millions of version of the same piece.

Process

Digital Technology and Process


Computer processing has been harnessed since the 50s in order to provide composers with new ideas as well as algorithmically generated pieces. Even creating millions of version of the same piece.

Process

http://vimeo.com/25041544

Process

Iannix - software that harnesses computer processing to musical algorithms

Process
Exercises

Exercise 4 Construct an algorithm for a piece (with or without computer assistance) operating on more than one musical layer

Process
Exercises
Exercise 1 Write a passage of music using the Schillinger system on rhythm, melody and/or harmony Exercise 2 Simulate musically a physical process (e.g. metronomes, drips, popcorn, tides, orbits etc.). Exercise 3 Write a piece of music based on an overt Reichian process. Exercise 4 Construct an algorithm for a piece (with or without computer assistance) operating on more than one musical layer

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Tuning

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/1vWvLOvDYElkzQkuZr7Fp7

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/35NLay3D8FdSFU45xYYjcv

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

Tuning

This episode deals with the scientic principles and creative possibilities of tuning from concepts of just intervals, expressive intonation and electronic realisation of microtones.

Tuning

Wavelength & Frequency Hz. The Frequency of Human Hearing The Law of Octave Equivalence Harmonic Series

Tuning

How many octaves from 20Hz-20,000Hz?

Tuning

A reference pitch

Pitch ination and variation for centuries. In 1939 a standardised system of 440Hz was agreed although some European schoolhs go up to 442Hz or 443Hz

Tuning Harmonic Series

Wavelength:
What division of the string?

!2/3

1/2

1/4

1/1

How much faster does the string oscillate?

Frequency:

!3/2

2/1

4/1

1/1

Note that frets (and pitch steps) are based on division rather than absolute length of a string. Hence, pitch is a logarithmic function with the perception of steps based on multiplications (and divisions). We can however use the handy cent with using a logarithmic function turns the octave into 1200 equal steps, with 100 cents equalling a 12th of the octave (equal semitone).

Tuning Harmonic Series

Note that frets (and pitch steps) are based on division rather than absolute length of a string (e.g. Frets are !5.61% of the remaining string). Hence, pitch is a logarithmic function with the perception of steps based on multiplications (and divisions) of frequency (or wavelength). We can however use the handy cent with using a logarithmic function turns the octave into 1200 equal steps, with 100 cents equalling a 12th of the octave (equal semitone), and 600 cents dividing the octave.

Tuning
Harmonic

1/1 1/2 1/3 1/4 1/5 1/6 1/7 1/8 1/9

Nearest Pitch

Harmonic Series

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

1/1 C 2/1 C 3/1 G

4/1 C 5/1 E 6/1 G

7/1 Bb 8/1 C

9/1 D

1/10 10/1 E

String players can touch the string at any of these nodes to reveal the harmonic.

Tuning Harmonic Series

Cent deviation from Equal temperament

+2

-14

+2

-32

+4

-14

-49

+2

+41

-32

-12

Memorise this pattern up to the 11th harmonic including cent discrepancies. Observe the narrowing of the intervals. Chord voicings respond well to a similar pattern which will be looked at in more detail in Voicings.

Tuning Harmonic Series


If we imagine that the harmonic series tells us something about the nature of music - although one doesnt have to believe that - then we can propose some natural outcomes.

Cent deviation from Equal temperament

+2

-14

+2

-32

+4

-14

-49

+2

+41

-32

-12

Tuning Harmonic Series


The rst triad to emerge is a major triad. (With a major 3rd 14c atter and a 5th 2c sharper than ET (Equal Temperament). The rst seventh chord to emerge is a dominant 7th (with a signicantly atter 7th (-32c) than ET) Natural voicings are large in the bass register and progressively closer at higher registers The rst heptatonic scale is Lydian Dominant (aka Lydian b7, Mixolydian #11, or the Overtone or Harmonic scale). The 3rd, b7 and especially the #11 (-49c) signically atter than ET The rst common pentatonic scale to emerge is the major pentatonic

Tuning Exercise

Exercise 1 Electronically realise the rst 16 notes of the harmonic series. You can create these with cent deviations from Equal temperament or by generating tones as multiples of a fundamental frequency. Listen to each harmonic against a drone to appreciate its sonority. Sketch an opening of a piece that is somehow linked to the harmonic series.

Tuning Acoustic Purity

The Pythagorean concept of Acoustic Purity: Intervals from simple ratios Selecting notes and constructing scales from the Harmonic Series

Tuning The Just 5th

1/1

3/2

2/1

3/1

Struck

Tuning The 3-Limit Scale

1/1 C Root

9/8 81/64 4/3 D E F Maj 2nd Maj 3rd 4th 2 4 -1

3/2 27/16 G A 5th Maj 6th 1 3

2/1 C 8ve

Tuning The Pure 5th vs. Even Tempered

700 E.T. 5th


2 cents

3/2 G 5th 702

Tuning The Pure 5th vs. Even Tempered

200 E.T. 2nd


4 cents

400 E.T. 2nd


8 cents

500 E.T. 2nd


-2 cents

700 E.T. 5th


2 cents

900 E.T. 5th


6 cents

9/8 81/64 D E Maj 2nd Maj 3rd 204 408

4/3 F 4th 498

3/2 G 5th 702

27/16 A Maj 6th 906

Tuning 3-Limit Concept

Cent deviation from Equal temperament

+2

-14

Tuning The 3-Limit Major Scale (Pythagorean)

Pitch C D E F G A B C

Ratio 1/1 9/8 81/64 4/3 3/2 27/16 243/128 2/1

Cent 0 204 408 498 702 906 1110 1200

+/0 +4 +8 -2 +2 +6 +10 0

Ascending Pure 5ths (except F)

Tuning The 3-Limit Locrian Scale (going down pure 5ths)

Pitch C Db Eb F Gb Ab Bb C

Ratio 1/1 256/243 32/27 4/3 1024/729 128/81 16/9 2/1

Cent 0 90 294 498 588 792 996 1200

+/0 -10 -6 -2 -12 -8 -4 0

Tuning The Pure 5th From the 5th Harmonic

5/4

Tuning The Pure 5th vs. Even Tempered vs. Pythagorean

400 E.T. 5th


-14 cents +8 cents

5/4 81/64 G E 5th Maj 3rd 386 408


22 cents ! 81/80 Syntonic Comma ! 22 cents

Tuning The Pure Major Triad

3/2 5/4 1/1

ET + 2 cents

ET - 14 cents

Tuning Exercise

Exercise 2 Construct a major triad with a clear electronic tone and using cent discrepancies (-14 cents on major third) (+2 cents on fth)

Tuning 5-Limit Concept

Cent deviation from Equal temperament

+2

-14

Tuning 5-limit chromatic scale

1/3
-2c

1
+0c

3
+2c

9
+4c

3rds from 5th Harm.

5
-14c

A 5/3 884c F 4/3 498c Db 16/15 112c

E 5/4 386c C 1/1 0c Ab 8/5 814c

B 15/8 1088c G 3/2 702c Eb 6/5 316c

F# 45/32 590c D 9/8 204c Bb 9/5 1018c

1 1/5
+14c

5ths from 3rd Harm.

Tuning 5-limit chromatic scale

1/3
-2c

1
+0c

3
+2c

9
+4c

Pure major triad

5
-14c

A 5/3 884c F 4/3 498c Db 16/15 112c

E 5/4 386c C 1/1 0c Ab 8/5 814c

B 15/8 1088c G 3/2 702c Eb 6/5 316c

F# 45/32 590c D 9/8 204c Bb 9/5 1018c

Pure minor triad

1 1/5
+14c

Pure major 7th

Pure minor 7th

Tuning Exercise
Exercise 3 Alongside the major triad, construct a minor triad, and other triads, 7ths and other chords using just intonation using cent discrepancies from the previous page. Create a chord sequence using carefully tuned chords. Compare to an even-tempered rendition. Consider if the moving bass line skips to even tempered or just intonated scale degrees.

Pure major triad

Pure minor triad

Pure major 7th

Pure minor 7th

Tuning Types of Degrees

As we saw with the major 3rd, different routes are available to get to closely related scale degrees, and so there are different types of pitches depending on which harmonics are used. Even limiting to the the 5th harmonic a large array of scale degrees emerge.

5-Limit Chromatic Palette

1/27
-6c

1/9
-4c Bb-125/72 954c

1/3
-2c F-125/96 458c Db-25/24 884c A 5/3 884c F 4/3 498c Db 16/15 112c A++ 128/75 924c F++ 512/375 540c

1
+0c C-125/64 1158c Ab25/16 772c E 5/4 386c C 1/1 0c Ab+ 8/5 814c E++ 32/25 428c C++ 128/125 42c

3
+2c G-375/128 640c Eb75/64 274c B 15/8 1088c G 3/2 702c Eb+ 6/5 316c B++ 48/25 1130c G++ 192/125 744c

9
+4c

27
+6c

81
+8c

125
-42c

25
-28c

B50/27 1066c G40/27 280c Eb 32/27 294c

F#-25/18 182c D10/9 182c Bb 16/9 996c F# 64/45 610c D+ 256/225 224c

Bb45/32 590c F#45/32 590c D 9/8 204c Bb+ 9/5 1018c F#+ 36/25 632c

F135/128 82c C#135/128 92c A+ 27/16 906c F+ 27/20 520c Db+ 27/25 134c

C405/256 794c

5
-14c

1 1/5
+14c

E+ 81/64 408c C+ 81/80 82c

1/25
+28c

1/125
+42c

A fraction of the scale degrees which emerge from harmonics 3 & 5, the yellow block are the most common. Warmer & cooler colours represent sharper & atter groups. The cream colour is the most common just intonated scale.

Tuning 5-Limit Chromatic Palette

Even limiting to the rst 5 harmonics, an indenite number of degrees may be generated.

1/729 -12c 625 -55c 125 -41c 25 -27c 5 -14c 1 1/5 +14c 1/25 +27c 1/125 +41c 1/625 +55c
Bb. 1250/729 934c F#. 1000/729 547c D--800/729 161c Bb1280/729 974c F#< 512/729 588c D-/
4096/3645

1/243 -10c
F. 625/485 435c Db. 250/243 49c A400/243 863c F320/243 476c Db< 256/243 90c A+<
2048/1215

1/81 1/27 -8c -6c


C. 625/324 1137c Ab-125/81 751c E100/81 365c C160/81 1118c Ab 128/81 792c E+< 512/405 406c C+< G. 625/432 639c Eb-125/108 253c B50/27 1067c G40/27 640c Eb 32/27 294c B+< 256/135 1108c

1/9 -4c
D. 625/576 141c Bb-125/72 955c F#-25/18 569c D10/9 182c Bb 16/9 996c F# 64/45 610c D+ 256/225 223c
Bb++ 2048/1125 1037c Bb++ 2048/1875 651c

1/3 -2c
A-625/384 843c F-125/96 456c Db-25/24 71c A 5/3 884c F 4/3 498c Db 16/15 112c A++ 128/75 925c F++ 512/375 539c Db++ 16/15 153c

1 +0c
E-625/512 345c C-125/64 1159c Ab25/16 773c E 5/4 386c C 1/1 0c Ab+ 8/5 814c E++ 32/25 427c C++ 128/125 41c Ab+> 1024/625 855c

3 +2c
B-1875/1024

9 +4c
F#+
5625/4096

27 +6c
Db+
16875/16384

81 243 729 +8c +10c +12c


Ab>
50625/32768

Eb>
youdontwant

Bb>
toknowsrsly

1047c

549c D--

51c A
3375/2048

753c E
10125/8192

255c B 135/128 1069c


G 6075/4096 682c Eb> 1215/1024

957c F#> 729/512 571c


D

G-375/256 661c Eb75/64 275c B 15/8 1088c G 3/2 702c Eb+ 6/5 316c B++ 48/25 1129c G++ 192/125 743c Eb+> 768/625 357c

1125/1024

163c Bb225/128 977c F#45/32 590c D 9/8 204c Bb+ 9/5 1018c F#+ 36/25 631c D++ 144/125 245c Bb+> 1152/625 1059c

865c F675/512 478c C#135/128 92c A+ 27/16 906c F+ 27/20 520c Db+ 27/25 133c A+> 216/125 947c F+> 864/625 561c

367c
C2025/1024 1180c

18225/26384

184c

Ab> 405/64 792c E+ 81/64 408c C+ 81/80 22c Ab> 81/50 835c E+> 162/125 449c C+> 648/625 63c

294c B+ 243/128 1110 G+ 243/160 723c Eb> 243/200 337c B+> 243/125 1151c G+> 972/625 765c

Bb> 3645/256 998c F#> 729/512 612 D+> 729/640 225c Bb> 729/400 1039c F#> 729/500 653c D+> 729/625 266c

202c Bb+<
32768/18225

904c F+<

1016c F#+<
silliness

G+< 8192/6075 2048/2025 1024/675 518c 20c 722c Db+<


32768/30375

Ab++
16384/1125

629c D/
dont ask 243c

131c A++<
long

833c

Eb++ 4096/3375 335c

E++<
65536/50625

B++<
32768/16875 1149c

945c

447c

Shrutis
C
1/1

Db-25/24

Db256/243

Db
16/15

Db+
27/25

D10/9

D
9/8

D+
256/225

Eb75/64

Eb
32/27

Eb+
6/5

E100/81

E
5/4

Pitch Name

Ratio

70

90

112

133

182

204

223

275

294

316

365

386

Cents (rounded)

E+
81/64

F320/243

F
4/3

F+
27/20

F#45/32

F#
64/65

F#+
36/25

G40/27

G
3/2

G+
243/160

Ab25/16

Ab
128/81

Ab+
8/5

408

477

498

520

590

610

631

680

702

723

773

792

814

A400/243

A
5/3

A+
27/16

Bb225/128

Bb
16/9

Bb+
9/5

B50/27

B
15/8

B+
243/128

B++
48/25

C
2/1

863

884

906

977

996

1018

1067

1088

1110

1129

1200

Tuning Shrutis and Ragas A Raga is a an Indian Classical Music form that includes specic rhythms, feels, motifs and microtonal scale forms. Well concentrate on the latter here. Since they occur over a drone and are essentially monophonic this allows for very specic and expressive tuning

Tuning Suha Raga Second quarter of the night Expression: Graceful, loving, night
Descending only

C 1/1 0
Tonic

D 9/8 204
Condent, joyful

Eb+ 9/5 316


Tender, loving

F 4/3 498
Moonlight, peace

G 3/2 702
Joy

Bb+ 9/5 1018


Desire

C 2/1 1200
Octave

(Tonic Bb on recording)

Tuning Bhairav Raga Late Morning Raga Expression: Calm and Loving

C 1/1 0
Tonic

Db256/243

90
Tender

E 5/4 316
Calm

F 4/3 498
Peace

G 3/2 702
Sun

Ab
128/81

792
Desire

B 15/8 1088
Pleasure

C 2/1 1200
Octave

(Tonic E on recording)

Tuning Sohini Raga

Deep into the night before dawn Expression: Effort to remain


Descending Only Descending Only

C 1/1 0
Tonic

Db256/243

90
Tender

E 5/4 316
Conscious, effort to stay awake

F 4/3 498
Moonlight, peace

F# 64/45 498
Intense, mysterious

A 5/3 1018
Soft, Callm

B+
243/128

1110
Active, sensuous

C 2/1 1200
Octave

Tuning Exercise

Exercise 4 Render one of these ragas (or research and invent one), carefully tune the shrutis - building a virtual instrument or set of instruments to achieve this. Play to a drone and compare to ET counterparts. Compose an opening of a piece in an alap style, slowly introducing and enjoying each of the shrutis and revealing the character of the raga.

Tuning 11-Limit What of the other harmonics? We can reach other divisions by using the 7th and 11th Harmonic, again from ET.

Cent deviation from Equal temperament

+2

-14

+2

-32

+4

-14

-49

Tuning 11-Limit

Harry Partchs (1901-74) 43-note universe

Tuning 11-Limit

Harry Partchs microtonal dissonance

Tuning Polyphonic Tuning Systems

Tuning The Spiral of Fifths

(3/2)12=129.746 27=128
Pythagorean Comma 129.746/128

!23.5 cents

Tuning Temperament

Temper, temper

Tuning
C Db D Eb E F F# G Ab A Bb B C 0 90 192 294 390 496 588 696 792 888 996 1092 1200

Quarter Comma purer 3rd


696c -6c -6c -6c

!24cents over 4 5ths 4 quarter commas Pure 5th= 702c Tempered= 696c

purer 3rd
-6c 702c

Tuning
C Db D Eb 0 94 196 298 392 502 592 698 796 894 1000 1090 1200 -4c -4c -4c -4c -4c

Sixth Comma 3rd


698c

3rd

E F F# G Ab

!24cents over 6 5ths 6 1/6 commas


More 3rds tempered, to a lesser degree than 1/4 comma

3rd

A Bb B C

3rd
702c

-4c

Tuning Bachs Well Tempered Clavier

Tuning Bachs Well Tempered Clavier

Tuning
C Db D Eb E F F# G Ab A Bb B C 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 700c 700c 700c -2c -2c -2c -2c 700c -2c 700c 700c -2c -2c -2c -2c -2c -2c 700c -2c 700c 700c 700c 700c 700c

Equal Temperament (ET) 12-TET


!24cents over 12 5ths 12 twelfth commas -2c

Tuning Equal Temperament makes Cents

Cents = 1200 * log(ratio) log(2)

Ratio = 2

(Cents/1200)

Tuning Another Solution

Tuning Mozarts semitones

Tuning Splitting Accidentals

Clockwise from left: Campagnolis ngerboard diagram (1797) Woldermars Violin Method (1803) and Split key harpsichord 1715

Tuning 55-division tuning

111.1cents

88.8cents

100cents

1/9=22.2cents

Tuning 55-division tuning


C C# D D# E F F# G G# A A# B C 0 88.9 Db 200 288.9 Eb 311.1 400 500 588.9 Gb 700 788.9 Ab 900 988.9 Bb 1100 1200 1011.1 811.1 611.1 111.1

E-G# 388.9c 3rd (Pure is 386c)

Ab-C 388.9c 3rd (Pure is 386c)

Tuning Exercise

Exercise 5 Recreate or invent a 7-note (or split accidental) tuning system using cent discrepancies. Write a passage of music that exploits the vertical possibilities.

Tuning Where did it go?

Complexity of Instrument Design Challenges of pedagogy and wider interest in performing music, owning a piano The drive through romantic harmony into 12-tone serialism Filtered out of the system

Tuning Vertical vs. Horizontal

Consideration of the vertical and the horizontal. A time for harmonic sonority, and a time for expressive intonation. Microtonal infection, bends, glides, dips, portamento, vibrato etc. are hugely expressive devices but their extensive discussion will be saved for another episode. Here we concentrate on the destinations of such motions, but here is a brief overview of ideas.

Tuning Expressive intonation: Bends

Direction Contour & Pattern Duration Start/End/Stopping Points

Tuning Expressive intonation: Vibrato

Shape Width Frequency

Tuning Expressive intonation: Vibrato

Tuning Other divisions

+50c

+100c

+150c

-50c

-100c

-150c

or

-150c

24-TET 24 quarter-tones 50 cents each

Tuning Other divisions

48-TET 48 eighth-tones 25 cents each

Tuning Other divisions

7-TET 14-TET n-TET Each 1200/n cents

Tuning Other Divisions

Tuning Exercise

Exercise 6 Recreate or invent an atypical ET system, and compose a passage of music exploiting the intonation possibilities. Experiment with expressive intonation.

Tuning Blues microtones

C7

F7

G7

C7

Tuning Blues microtones

Tuning Blues microtones

Tuning Technology and Microtones

Tuning Technology and Microtones

Busoni (1866-1924) In response to Cahills Telharmonium "Let us take thought," he exulted, "how music may be restored to its primitive, natural essence; [...] let it follow the line of the rainbow and vie with the clouds in breaking sunbeams.

Tuning Technology and Microtones

Tuning Technology and Microtones

Corrective technology (Pristine vs. sterile) Timbral expression Non equal-tempered auto-tuning?

Tuning Exercise

Exercise 7 Compose a passage of music using autoned vocals to a non 12-TET system.

Tuning Compositional Exercises


Exercise 1 Electronically realise the rst 16 notes of the harmonic series. You can create these with cent deviations from Equal temperament or by generating tones as multiples of a fundamental frequency. Listen to each harmonic against a drone to appreciate its sonority. Sketch an opening of a piece that is somehow linked to the harmonic series. Exercise 2 Construct a major triad with a clear electronic tone and using cent discrepancies (-14 cents on major third) Exercise 3 Alongside the major triad, construct a minor triad, and other triads, 7ths and other chords using just intonation using cent discrepancies from the previous page. Create a chord sequence using carefully tuned chords. Compare to an even-tempered rendition. Consider if the moving bass line skips to even tempered or just intonated scale degrees. Exercise 4 Render one of these ragas (or research and invent one), carefully tune the shrutis - building a virtual instrument or set of instruments to achieve this. Play to a drone and compare to ET counterparts. Compose an opening of a piece in an alap style, slowly introducing and enjoying each of the shrutis and revealing the character of the raga. Exercise 5 Recreate or invent a 7-note (or split accidental) tuning system using cent discrepancies. Write a passage of music that exploits the vertical possibilities. Exercise 6 Recreate or invent an atypical ET system, and compose a passage of music exploiting the intonation possibilities. Exercise 7 Compose a passage of music using autoned vocals to a non 12-TET system.

MILTONOTES
An open-eared exploration of composition in theory & practice.

Structure

Milton Mermikides m.mermikides@surrey.ac.uk

Listening list: This episode


http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7EsGc9soCKgCZJqCcdk1GX

Entire series
http://open.spotify.com/user/miltonline/playlist/7El79d9SdfBxnSwNruyAeD

or subscribe to miltonline on spotify follow me on twitter @miltonline for music and more

This episode looks at concepts of structure (and form) in composition. By looking at examples of folk and popular songs, jazz charts, classical forms, electronic pieces and indeterminate and process works, well build a catalogue of structures and structural concepts for analysis and compositional application.

Structure
Levels Firstly we need to address what factors contribute to our perception of structure. In fact as we saw in Pulse and Meter, Melodic Structures and Phrase, Contour and Melodic forms there are several levels on which structure is based. On the following simple example you can see the different levels of motif/phrase/section/piece

Structure
Levels

Structure is achieved by the repetition of similar events, as well as the disruption of repeated events.

Structure
Levels

Structure
Meter Level

Structure
Motif Level

Structure
Phrase Level

Structure
Passage (Higher Phrase) Level

Structure
Section Level

Structure
Levels

In this episode we will look at the higher level structure of sections, but we should always be aware that structure is achieved by the repetition of similar events, as well as the disruption of repeated events.

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P1
A

2 scales, 3 chords, 1 piece

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P2
B C

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P3
A

Melodic Analysis
Gnossienne I - P4
B

Structure
Form
A B Three sections, the most famous A only occuring at two points. The ending is given an effective poignancy by omitting the last bar. B has three versions (B is quieter, and B is quieter and shortened). C B A B C B A B C B A B C B 8x2 4x2 6x2 4x2 8x2 4x2 6x2 4+3

Structure
Levels of Organisation

Pulse Accented Beats Meter Motif/Figure Phrase Passage Section Piece Cycle/Album/Set/ Symphony

Structure
Forms

Charles Keil divides all musical forms into 3 types Sectional Developmental Variational

Structure
Form

Well look at some specic forms but will open up the idea that sections can be created not just by traditional melodic structures but by timbre, texture and feel

Structure

Sectional Clear cut sectional units (A, B, C, Verse, Middle 8, coda etc.)

Structure
Sectional Strophic Form Unrelieved repetition, chain, medley. AAAAAAAA

Unrelieved repetition

ABCDEFG(A)
Unrelieved variation Medley e.g. Blue Danube - Strauss

Unrelieved variation with repeats

AABBCCDDEE

Structure
Sectional Binary Form
A piece made up 2 sections A & B complementary and of roughly similar lengths. Traditionally major binary forms have A in the tonic key B in dominant key, ending in tonic Traditionally minor binary forms have A in the tonic key B in relative major key, ending in tonic

AB or AABB

Structure
Sectional Ternary Form

ABA
De Capo operatic aria form

or AABA
e.g. 32-bar form with middle eight

Structure
Sectional Rondo form
A recurring theme with contrasting episodes

ABACABAC
Symettrical

ABACADAE
Asymettrical

ABCBA
Arch form Special case of symettrical rondo without intermediate themes See Mozart examples

Structure
Sectional Palindromic
Rondo forms can be palindromic on a sectional level

ABACABA
But palindromes neednt be rondo forms

ABCADEDACBA
Palindromes can even exist on the note level...

Structure
Sectional Palindromic

Haydn Symphony No. 47

Structure
Sectional Palindromic rhythms

The Afro-Cuban rhythm Cscara x0xx 0x0x x0x0 xx0x


2-3 Cuban Son

Structure
Sectional Crab/Table Canon

Structure
Dammit Im mad. Evil is a deed as I live. God, am I reviled? I rise, my bed on a sun, I melt. To be not one man emanating is sad. I piss. Alas, it is so late. Who stops to help? Man, it is hot. Im in it. I tell. I am not a devil. I level Mad Dog. Ah, say burning is, as a deied gulp, !In my halo of a mired rum tin. I erase many men. Oh, to be man, a sin. Is evil in a clam? In a trap? No. It is open. On it I was stuck. Rats peed on hope. Elsewhere dips a web. Be still if I ll its ebb. Ew, a spider eh? We sleep. Oh no! Deep, stark cuts saw it in one position. Part animal, can I live? Sin is a name. Both, one my names are in it. Murder? Im a fool. A hymn I plug, deied as a sign in ruby ash. A Goddam level I lived at. On mail let it in. Im it. Oh, sit in ample hot spots. Oh wet! A loss it is alas (sip). Id assign it a name.N ame not one bottle minus an ode by me: Sir, I deliver. Im a dog Evil is a deed as I live. Dammit Im mad.

Structure
Variational Theme and Variations
A theme with related variations traditionally based on the harmonic progression and motivic material

A A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6
e.g. Theme and Variations on a Theme by Mozart - Sor Note that each section may itself have an internal structure (AABB) and the whole form may have an intro/outro and/or elaborated outro/coda. See also Paganini - Caprice 24 and many others. The Rondo may also include intermediate variations:

A B A1 C A2 D A3

Structure
Variational Theme and Variations further ideas
Brittens Young Persons Guide to the Orchestra has each variation showcasing a different section of the orchestra, and his Nocturnal for Solo Guitar, starts with the variations, only revealing the Dowlands underlying theme in the last section. Elgars Enigma Variations is a set of 14 variations on an original theme - each a musical portrait, capturing the personality of his close circle of friends. Variations include rhythmic, harmonic & melodic references and even a Dorabellas stutter, W.N.s laugh and particular experiences they shared. Elgar claimed all a based on a hidden theme that is not played and took the secret to the grave.

Structure

Variational

The Enigma theme - note the motivic variants. Pi?

Structure
Stylistic Variational
The common Blues and Jazz forms involving improvisation may be considered a special type of theme and variation. Typically a melody is played over a specic harmonic structure (A, AB, ABAC, AABA etc.) and then that harmonic form (and perhaps some motivic and rhythmic material from the melody are used for improvised solos, and another realisation of the melody is used to end the piece. The whole form may be topped and tailed by an intro, outro or intermediate sections (see All Blues). The stylistic forms you need to know are a 12-bar blues (sometimes interpreted as a 24-bar blues), an 8, 16-bar blues (Need Your Love So Bad) or other (Come On Pt. 1), and a rhythm changes (many examples)

Structure
12-Bar Blues (major)

I7 IV7 V7

IV7 IV7 IV7

I7 I7 I7

I7 I7 V7

Note this form wasnt decided a priori it evolved, and still many structures have an indenite length on the I chord, moving to the IV on cue

Structure
12-Bar Blues (minor)

i7 iv7(IV7) bVImaj7 V7 i7 i7 V7

Structure
8-Bar Blues (major)

I7 V7

IV7 I7 IV7

#IV7 I7 V7

I V7/II ii7

Rhythm Changes

Structure I V7/II ii7 A A B A I I7 IV V7 iv V7 iv iii V7/II ii7 iii V7/II ii7 iii V7/II ii7 V7 V7 V7

I V7/II ii7 I I7 IV

iii V7/II ii7V7 I V7/II V7

V7/VI V7/V I V7/II ii7 I I7 IV V7 iv

iii V7/II ii7

V7

iii V7/II ii7V7 I

Structure
Developmental

Built directly from smaller units - the most established in Western Art music being the Sonata form. This is beyond the scope of this episode. However the idea of a structure that is through-composed an unfurling stream of consciousness with no clear sectional delineations is well established in ambient electronic music

Structure
Structural Components
Here are some of the devices that through repetition and variation starting with the most common Melody Lyrics Key Harmony Orchestration/Instrumentation Meter Rhythmic Subdivision/Groove/Feel Dynamics Timbre/Texture

Structure
Popular Song Form - Building Blocks Intro Verse Prechorus Chorus Bridge Collision Solo Interlude Vamp Outro
Note that features may be shared - an intro can use the choruss chords for example

Structure
Wind Cries Mary Hendrix Intro Verse Prechorus
ends with material and similar to

Solo Verse Prechorus Chorus


Cries

Verse Prechorus Chorus


Screams

Verse Prechorus Chorus


Cries

Chorus
Whispers

Outro
based on intro

Structure
Better Be Home Soon Crowded House

Verse Prechorus Chorus


(short)

Verse Prechorus Chorus Bridge Solo Interlude

Verse Prechorus Chorus Chorus

Structure
Grow Your Own Intro Bridge Vamp Interlude Collision Solo Outro Chorus Prechorus

Verse

Structure
Electronic Structural Components
In the absence of traditional key areas, melodic and harmonic expectations, lyrics and forms, electronic dance music and IDM has developed structural components and forms based more directly on instrumentation, rhythmic components and feel, dynamic changes and timbre

Intro Hook Break Mid-8 Key Sample Build Arhythmic Outro Drop Solo

Structure
Introductions Sectional
A unique section that only appears once such as the original jazz form arrangements. Starting directly on a section that features throughout the track. Or an adapted (usually thinned and/or shortened) variation of a later important section or components

Fade
Duration, curve

or...

Structure
Endings Sectional (New)
A modied section breaking expectation, new material or a logical conclusion
e.g. Syrinx ends with the other whole tone scale

Sectional (Recap)
A repeat of an earlier section with minimal alteration

Fade
Duration, curve

or...

Exercise 1 Take an existing piece/section of yours (or write a new one) and rewrite in 7 different structures (including at least one from each of the 3 categories of sectional, variational and developmental).

You might also like