Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chinese Wind Technology A Smarter Way to Develop Large Scale Onshore Wind? A Summary Paper
By Frank MacCullaich
29 November 2011
FMAC Ltd
Page 1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
FMAC Ltd
Page 2
Table of Contents
1.0 Executive Summary 2.0 Introduction 3.0 NZ Electricity Market Background 4.0 Financial Model NZ Onshore Wind Farm 2 4 4 5
Figure 1 - European TSA .............................................................................................................................................. 6 Figure 2 - Chinese TSA ................................................................................................................................................. 7 Figure 3 - TSA Comparative Costs ................................................................................................................................ 8
8 9
FMAC Ltd
Page 3
2.0 Introduction
2.1 The overall aim of this summary paper is to provide an indication of the signals to invest in the NZ onshore wind market using Chinese (Asian) commercial scale onshore wind technology. There is a case study on comparing the costs of a top Chinese wind turbine supplier to that of the leading European manufacturers. In addition, there is a preliminary review of the warranties for operational availability and power curve performance that the case study Chinese supplier could offer. The report begins with an overview of the present NZ electricity market regulatory structure and subsequently presents a financial model of a 62 MW onshore wind farm, comparing the financials of wind turbines supplied from Europe to that of China. The information supplying the comparative financial models was sourced from an actual project (62 MW) based in Scotland. The report does not detail the merits of New Zealands wind regime, planning system or the nuances involved in obtaining a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA), as this would be subject to a more detailed and broader scope study on the investment signals of the NZ wind market. Nonetheless, it is suffice for the purposes of this report to add that resource (planning) consent applications for commercial scale onshore in New Zealand have a greater than 90% approval rate and that it is one of the windiest countries in the world with many potential development sites enjoying 10m/s average wind speed and over 40% capacity factor .
2.2
2.3
2.4
3.2
3.3
3.4
FMAC Ltd
Page 4
NZ Wind Development Plan Proposal (DRAFT) 3.5 All electricity generated is required to be traded through the central pool, with the exception of small generating stations of less than 10MW. Bilateral and other hedge arrangements (PPA) are possible, and function as separate financial contracts. Industry knowledge indicates that Power Purchase Agreements (PPA) obtained today would be circa $80 per MWh, for a typical period of 5 years.
3.6
4.2
4.3
4.4 4.5
Figure 1 is modelled on a contracted Siemens Turbine Supply Agreement (TSA) price. Figure 2 is modelled on a received Sinovel Tender Price Band (representative Chinese TSA price). Yield prediction was 13.5% more than Siemens at 4.09 GWh/yr per MW installed; however, both the financial models use the Siemens yield figure as the benchmark. Sinovel is close to 36% cheaper than Siemens, which is the only variance used in the financial model comparative. The full spreadsheet versions of the financial models are provided seperate to this report, and shown in summary below.
4.6
4.7
FMAC Ltd
Page 5
4.9
4.10
Based on the above worst case model scenario and the current strong NZD exchange rate being likely short-term, it is easy to appreciate the high investment risk and the reason, therefore, that NZ GenTailers are nervous to advance resource consented projects in the multiple 100s MW capacity range.
FMAC Ltd
Page 6
4.12
FMAC Ltd
Page 7
4.14
Figure 3. Wind Turbine Supply Agreement Costs () A Comparison (2010). 4.15 From the above Figures 1-3 it is clear that Chinese suppliers, such as Sinovel, could enable a strong business case based on financial terms to develop onshore wind farms in New Zealand.
5.3
Sinovel Preliminary Due Diligence Case Study 5.4 From discussions held with the author to date, Sinovel offered the following information in regards to existing operational records, warranty of performance and availability: Operational Availability Guarantee. Sinovel is able to provide an availability guarantee of 97%. Warranty Period Provide 10 years warranty period, first 2 years free. During the warranty period the operational availability, noise levels, and power curve performance are all guaranteed. A liquid damage would apply if any aspect fails the contractual level; Financial Bond. Held by independent legal third party to pay the liquid damage in the event that Sinovel does not comply with warranty conditions and/or compensation for loss of opportunity costs (downtime);
FMAC Ltd
Page 8
Detailed Due Diligence. Sinovel are willing to assist any detailed analytical process of recorded site data, engineering analysis and contract legal review, including a site visit to China to look at existing wind farms and manufacturing plant; Operational Records. Due diligence parties will obtain access to data and operational plant to assess performance and maintenance records obtained from existing wind farms operating in China. The 5 year operational site records for both the 1.5MW and 3MW models are available for inspection and will show 94-98% availability; Bank Finance. Sinovel as supplier would be able to access Chinese bank finance for constructing consented projects; and Miscellaneous. Sinovel are willing to consider any proposals to enable a breakthrough into the western market.
5.6
5.7
5.8
FMAC Ltd
Page 9
FMAC Ltd
Page 10