Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Quality assurance
Introduction
In accordance with The Planning Inspectorate Advice note fourteen: Compiling the consultation report we have undertaken safeguards to ensure that feedback comments are grouped appropriately. This appendix sets out the process followed.
N.2
N.2.1
Thematic grouping, eg transport, noise and vibration, air quality and odour
Thematic sub-grouping of feedback: - splitting feedback between supportive and neutral comments, objections, issues and concerns and suggestions - within a theme grouping detailed comments, for example within transport effect on parking provision or concerns about access route
Checking
N.2.3
the feedback form, respondents were asked to state their view on certain questions by means of tick boxes. For these questions, views were only assigned where the respondents view point was clear from their feedback. Where the respondents point of view was not clear, this part of the question was left blank. Where no feedback was received in relation to a particular question, it was left blank. Where feedback was received that did not respond to any of the questions in the feedback form, it was entered into a separate part of the feedback form for other comments.
For feedback received in relation to part 1 of the feedback, we undertook an additional categorisation of comments which reflected the content of the site information papers. Feedback was therefore sorted in relation to whether it related to: Site selection Management of construction works Permanent design and appearance Management of operational effects
N.2.7
Part of feedback form Part 1: Permanent design and appearance Part 1: Management of operational effects
High level themes Land quality and contamination Lighting Natural environment (aquatic) Natural environment (terrestrial) Noise and vibration Open space and recreation Planning and development Socio-economic Structures and utilities Townscape and visual Transport and access Water and flood risk
Permanent design and appearance General feedback comments on the key issues General feedback comments on measures to address the key issues Air quality and odour Historic environment Land quality and contamination Lighting Natural environment (aquatic) Natural environment (terrestrial) Noise and vibration Open space and recreation Planning and development Socio-economic Structures and utilities Townscape and visual Transport and access Water and flood risk Need for the project Solution including the tunnel and alternative
Part 2
High level themes Tunnel route including alternative tunnel routes Tunnel alignment including alternative tunnel alignments and feedback on drive strategy Previous consultation activities Attendance at exhibitions Project information Consultation process
N.2.9
Checking
N.2.10 A sample of the feedback assignments were reviewed to check for consistency of theme and sub-theme assignment and to review the need for additional or revised sub-themes. This process was undertaken by a team member who was not directly involved in the analysis process. Additionally, a selection of correspondence received and details of the themes and sub-themes that were assigned was reviewed by the project team to confirm that it agreed with the approach that had been adopted. This process did not identify any changes to the assignment of themes or sub-themes.
N.2.11