Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dharmendra
Assistant Professor Department of Civil Engineering Office Location: Environmental Laboratory Civil Department (Ground Floor)
Books:
1. Environmental Impact Assessment for Developing Countries: Asit K. Biswas 2. Environmental Impact Analysis Handbook : G.J. Rau and C.D. Wooten 3. Environmental Impact Assessment by C.W. Canter 4. Environmental Impact Assessment Theory and practice Peter Wathern
Course Plan
CHAPTER 1 What is EIA? Why is it important? How did EIA originate? How does it concern you? Who are the stakeholders? Why is it important to understand the EIA report? How can you intervene in the process? Comparison of public consultation in India and other countries. CHAPTER 2 Environmental clearance process in India Central level State level Function of Central and State Expert Appraisal Committees CHAPTER 3 Role of screening Current screening process in India What additional information is missing in screening forms for decision? Case studies CHAPTER 4 Why scoping is important Role of scoping Regulatory provision for scoping in India Decision criteria to undertake rapid or comprehensive EIA Scoping guidelines for defining the Term of reference for projects (TOR).
Method to assess the project impact on ecosensitive areas. Project feasibility with respect to land use pattern. Estimation of assimilative capacity of the river. Mass balance and thumb rule to estimate the resource consumption and emission potential of different industrial sector. Thumb rule to estimate the pollution potential based on fuel and raw material analysis. Thumb rule to estimate the stack height. Thumb rule to estimate the water demand, wastewater discharge, load and treatment process efficiency. Thumb rule to estimate the seismic location. Estimation of site suitability with respect meteorological parameter. Thumb rule to assess social issues
CHAPTER 8 Public consultation Introduction to public consultation. How one should prepare for the public consultation. Loopholes of public hearing in India CHAPTER 9 Post monitoring Weakness in post monitoring Structural weakness Legal weakness How to strengthen post monitoring
Environment
Our natural environment climate, soils, oceans, biological life (plants, animals, bacteria) that can both nurture us and be hazards to us. The built environment that we have created to protect and house ourselves and to provide a modified infrastructure within which we can prosper The economic environment that sustains our built environment and allows the organization of the means of production The social, cultural and legal environments within which we conduct ourselves and our interactions with others. These environments are themselves diverse, continually evolving and have strong interdependence.
Introduction
What is EIA? What are the core value of EIA?
Definitions of EIA:
A study of probable changes in various socio-economic and biophysical characteristics and the environment, which may result from a proposed or impending action (Jain, Urban, Stacey, 1977). An activity that aims at establishing quantitative values for selected parameters, which indicate the quality of environment before, during, and after the proposed activities Heer, Hagerty (1977). An instrument to identify and assess the potential environmental impacts of a proposed project, evaluate alternatives, and design appropriate mitigation, management, and monitoring measures (World Bank)
1990s
On 27 January 1994
Why is it important?
To understand the short term and long term impact of project. To identifies the likely environmental, economical and social burden of the project for decision makers. The long-term objective of EIA is to promote sustainable development by ensuring the balance between environment and development. Opportunity to the local people to understand the project so that they can participate and intervene in project development.
5. Reporting: This stage presents the result of EIA in a form of a report to the decisionmaking body and other interested parties.
6. Review of EIA: It examines the adequacy and effectiveness of the EIA report and provides information necessary for the decision-making. 7. Decision-making: It decides whether the project is rejected, approved or needs further change. 8. Post monitoring: This stage comes into play once the project is commissioned.
Types of EIA
Broadly EIA classified into two types:
Rapid EIA
This is carried out for projects that are likely to cause limited adverse impacts. In rapid EIA, data or information is collected for only one season (other than monsoon). Therefore, the time frame for undertaking rapid EIA is much shorter (3 months).
Comprehensive EIA
As the name suggests, this is conducted over a year as it involves collection of data/information for three seasons (other than monsoons). It is usually conducted for projects that are likely to cause more or a series of adverse impacts. However, in India, there are no clear guidelines on the type of projects for which comprehensive EIA should be conducted. As per the new EIA notification, the authority in charge of issuing environmental clearances (either the Union ministry for environment and forests (MoEF) or the state level body) decides whether the project proponent has to conduct a rapid or a comprehensive EIA.
India
CHAPTER 2
Environmental clearance process in India Central level State level Function of Central and State Expert Appraisal Committees The union Ministry of environment and forests brought out the new EIA notification in 2006. In the new notification (dated 14th September 2006), the process of screening and scoping has been made mandatory.
EIA at project
Old notification
Six stages: (1) Project concept (2) Pre-feasibility (3) Feasibility (4) Design and engineering (5) Implementation and (6) Monitoring and evaluation.
New notification Four Stage Stage first - screening (only for category B projects and activities), Stage second - scoping (applicable for A and B1 type project), Stage third - public consultation, Stage fourth project appraisal.
Proposal of project
Project MOEF
A,
Get
clearance
from
Submission of Form & relevant information to Expert Appraisal Committee (Both for project A &B)
EIA required
(called B1 project)
Not approved
Approved
Post monitoring
Strategic EIA
Strategic environment assessment (SEA) refers to systematic analysis of the environmental effects of: development policies, plans, programmes and other proposed strategic actions. This process extends the aims and principles of EIA upstream in the decision-making process, beyond the project level , major alternatives are still open. SEA represents a proactive approach to integrating environmental considerations into the higher levels of decision-making.
Takes place at earlier stages of decision making cycle Pro-active approach to development Reactive approach to development proposal proposals Identifies specific impacts on the Identifies environmental implications, issues of sustainable development environment Considers broad range of potential Considers limited number of feasible alternatives Alternatives Early warning of cumulative effects Limited review of cumulative effects Emphasis on meeting environmental Emphasis on mitigating and minimizing objectives, maintaining natural systems impacts Broad perspective, lower level of detail to Narrow perspective, high level of detail provide a vision and overall framework Well-defined process, clear beginning and Multi-stage process, overlapping components, end policy level is continuing, iterative Focuses on standard agenda, treats Focuses on sustainability agenda, gets at symptoms of environmental deterioration sources of environmental deterioration
4.
5.
6.
4. 5.
CHAPTER 3
Screening
Role of screening Current screening process in India What information is missing in screening forms? Case studies
Screening
It is the first step of the environmental impact assessment, which helps to assess the environmental impacts of an industrial, or development project and decides whether an environmental impact assessment is required for the project or not.
Proposal of project
Project MOEF
A,
Get
clearance
from
Submission of Form & relevant information to Expert Appraisal Committee (Both for project A &B)
EIA required
(called B1 project)
Not approved
Approved
Post monitoring
CHAPTER 4
Why scoping is important Role of scoping Regulatory provision for scoping in India Decision criteria to undertake rapid or comprehensive EIA Scoping guidelines for defining the Term of reference for projects (TOR).
Role of scoping
Ideally, the role of scoping is to determine three key issues, namely, Justification of the project (both scenarios with and without the project, extent of benefit to the local communities due to the project) Site alternatives (assessment of different sites with respect to stress on biophysical environment and its cumulative effects) Design alternatives (type of technology, structural and non-structural mitigation measures to reduce significant impacts).
Scoping guidelines for defining the Term of reference for projects (TOR).
Issues to be considered Site alternative Description Extent of investigation/best practice in scoping
The provision of site alternatives is never considered in the EIA process because site selection is driven by availability of raw materials and other economic factors. There are hardly any considerations of environmental and social impacts while locating a project. In order to locate a project, the siting guideline should be properly followed (see annexure 1.2 for siting guidelines).
Final decision on the site should be made based on the detailed investigation of environmental, social and economic issues related with each sites. Environmental issues: Type of land use pattern, water potential and competitive users, pollution potential with respect to assimilation capacity of the area/medium, and proximity to sensitive areas. Social issues: Population density, impact on local resources, impact on public amenities and infrastructure, scenario with and without the project, proximity of human habitation. Cont
Areas to be avoided
Ministry of environment and forests, government of india has notified the following areas for prohibiting and restricting specified industrial activites in the country:
Murud Jangira Disst. Maharashtra , (Notification,189) Doon Valley in uttar Pradesh. (Notification, 1989) Antop Hill in Bombay (Notification, 1980) Dahanu Taluka in Maharashtra (Notification, 1996) Namaligarh East of Kaziranga (Notification, 1996) Specified Areas of Aravali Range. (Notification, 1992) Matheran and surrounding region in the state of Maharashtra declared as the Matheran Eco-sensitive Zone (Notification Dt. 4th Feb 03) Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ)-500 meters from the high tide line (HTL) towards the landward side. (Section 9 for details on CRZ Rules, 1991 & Amendments).
Guidelines for defining the Term of reference for projects (TOR). Contd..
Issues to be considered
Technology
Description The technology used for manufacturing has a huge impact on the environment. Therefore it should be selected after considering all possible alternatives. For instance in , most of the industries still use outdated technologies when compared to global trends.
This impact is very high in case the project is located close to a sensitive area. In case of industrial, irrigation and mining projects, there are several examples of how the impacts on biodiversity were ignored for setting up a project. An excellent example is of the Himachal-based cement plant of Gujarat Ambuja Cements Limited (GACL). The production unit and the mines are located in extremely ecosensitive areas there are 19 protected forest blocks in the region. The production unit is close to the Darlaghat Wildlife Sanctuary, the mines are close to the Majathal Sanctuary. However, for setting this plant, the Darlaghat sanctuary was denotified by the government. Similarly, the construction work of Durgawati water resource project continues on the forestland. Expert committee in their report mentioned that the state government had denotified 160 acres of forestland including 5.44 acres in the Kaimur Wildlife Sanctuary through a notification on November 5, 2004 for setting up this project.
Impact on sensitive locations (forests, wildlife sanctuaries, national parks, archaeological sites etc.)
Issues to be considered
Impact of change in land use patterns Cumulative load Impact on water resources Impact during preconstruction stage. Impact on biodiversity Impact on air by point source emissions Toxic emissions Impact of water pollution Sediment impact Impact of solid/hazardous wastes generation and handling Impact of noise Blasting Transportation issues Risk Assessment team and monitoring infrastructure
CHAPTER 5
Introduction to data collection. What data to be collected and its significance such as Air environment Water environment Land environment Biodiversity How data should be collected, interpreted and presented?
Data collection
Data collection is done basically with two intentions:
To get an idea of the existing social, environmental and economic scenario in and around the proposed plants location, To get an idea of possible implications of setting up the plant in the region
Infrastructure projects
This includes highways/ airports/ bridges/ pipelines/ ports/ railway networks
In the case of pipelines, railway networks, roads and highways, the study area is usually taken as a 2 km corridor (1 km on each side) along the entire length of the project. In addition, the study area includes a 5-km radius area surrounding key areas in the network like large towns, cities etc. In the case of airports/ports, the study area is a 10-km radius
Location
Topography (flat/hilly) Existence of other industries/development projects within the study area (Number of projects/distance of these projects from the proposed project) Details of population in the area distance of the nearest human habitation, villages in the study area and their population. In the case of selected key areas, data corresponding to a 1-km radius, 2-km radius and a 5-km radius should be collected
Location Contd...
Existence of eco-sensitive areas in the study area and their distance from the proposed project
wildlife sanctuaries national parks forests/wetlands and mangroves archaeological sites/sites of historical importance habitats for migratory birds estuary or sea lakes and reservoirs or dams)
Existing land use patterns in the land for which Right of Use/ownership has to be acquired for setting up the project
Soil
Type of soil within the study area (composition/ characteristics). Characteristics such as pH, nitrogen/ phosphorous/ potassium/ calcium/ magnesium/ sodium, sodium absorption ratio (SAR), electrical conductivity, available water storage capacity, infiltration rate, porosity, texture, permeability, percentage of sand, silt and clay in the soil etc. should be collected Availability and characteristics of topsoil in the study area (depth of topsoil, composition)
Soil Contd...
Soil and slope stability reports on studies done in the area. This is particularly important in case of projects located in hilly and mountainous terrains, where risks of landslides can be high. It is also important in case of large-scale projects located in seismically active zones
(Note: This might be substantial for instance in the case of construction of tunnels etc.)
Data on the approximate quantity of the material that might be used for landfilling (for instance silt from nearby areas) low-lying areas
Air
Ambient air quality data on suspended particulate matter (SPM), respirable suspended particulate matter (RSPM), sulphur dioxide (SO2), and different oxides of nitrogen (NOX), dust fall, carbon monoxide and hydrocarbons Data should be calculated on a 24-hour basis number of vehicles passing/hour should be noted, along with information on the type of vehicle (heavy motor vehicles/light motor vehicles/twothree wheelers)
Noise
Information on the possible sources of noise from the proposed project noise levels, duration of noise Data on the ambient noise levels collected near residential areas, commercial areas and silent zones. 24-hour data is to be collected
Biodiversity
Vegetation
If there are forests in the study area, a detailed study of what kinds of forests exist (teak/sal/mixed etc.) has to be done. Usually, this data is available with the Forest Department.
Fauna
Detailed inventorisation of fauna found in the study area data on wildlife/ butterflies/ mammals/ birds/ reptiles/ amphibians/ migratory birds and animals/ phytoplankton/ zooplankton should be collected Presence of nesting/breeding grounds/ watering holes Classification of animals under various schedules of the Wildlife Act (1972) Physiochemical characteristics of all the local water bodies temperature, light penetration, turbidity, pH, dissolved oxygen, phosphates, nitrates and sulphates
I. II.
This refers to particulate matter less than 10 micrometers in size. These are more harmful than SPM emissions, since they can penetrate the lungs.
This is a heavy, pungent and colourless gas. Industrial sources include burning of coal (particularly imported coal), pet coke and oil as well as other industrial processes like smelting and petroleum refining. These emissions can cause pulmonary damage. They can injure the bronchial tubes leading to the lungs, as well as the delicate tissue of the lungs themselves. They can cause irritation to the eyes, nose and throat. They can also damage leaves and stems of plants. SO2 emissions can also affect the pH balance of water. These emissions form sulphuric acid with water. This acid attacks metal, concrete, granite and other structural materials.
3.
SO2:
I. II.
III. IV. V. VI. VII.
When n is greater than 1.4 (super adiabatic condition), When n lies between 1 and 1.4 (sub adiabatic condition) it leads to instability. When n is lesser than 1, the atmospheric conditions are highly stable. In all such cases, the rate at which temperature changes with height is referred to as Environmental Lapse Rate (ELR) When the rate of change of temperature with height is positive (n<1), the condition is called inversion. There are two types of inversion
radiation inversion (also known as ground based inversions) and subsidence inversion (also known as elevated inversions)
Radiation inversion
Subsidence inversion
Double inversion
Mixing depths
The vertical extent to which the mixing takes place varies diurnally, from season to season, and is also affected by topographical features. The greater the vertical extent, the larger the volume of atmosphere available for dispersion of the pollutants. The depth of the mixing layer is known as the Mean Mixing Depth. Atmospheric conditions influence the way thermal plumes behave. Behaviour of plumes under different conditions Case 1- Looping: This occurs when n > 1.4 and atmospheric conditions are unstable Case 2 Coning: This occurs when n is between 1 and 1.4 and atmospheric conditions are unstable Case 3 Fanning: This occurs when n < 1, and inversion takes place Case 4 Lofting: This occurs when the inversion layer lies below the stack height Case 5 Fumigation: This occurs when the inversion layer lies above the stack height Case 6 Trapping: This occurs when double inversion layers occur Case 7: Neutral: This occurs when n = 1, and atmospheric conditions are stable
Representation of data
When many samples are taken (say over a period of a month), ambient air quality is typically represented by the following figures:
Maximum value: This is the maximum emission value recorded Minimum value: This is the minimum emission value recorded Average value: This is the average emission value recorded 98 percentile: This is a value such that at most 2 per cent of the observations are higher than this value.
Meteorological Data
Climatology Data Indian Bureau of Mines (IBM) and the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) Rainfall: Rainfall (in mm) = Volume of rainfall collected (in mm3) / (Area of the aperture of the gauge in mm2) Index of wetness = Actual rainfall in a given year at a given place / Normal annual rainfall of that place Arithmetical mean method: P = (P1 + P2 + P3 + . Pn)/ n Thiessens mean method: P = (A1P1 + A2P2 + A3P3 + . An Pn)/ A Isohyetal method: P = (A1P1 + A2P2 + A3P3 + . An Pn)/ (A1 + A2 + A3 + .An)
Groundwater
Porosity = Total volume of voids in the aggregate (Vs)/Total volume of the aggregate (V) x 100
Type of rock formation Granite, Quartzite Slate, Shale Limestone Sandstone Sand and Gravel Only Gravel Only Sand Clay and Soil Porosity 1.5% 4% 5-10% 10-15% 20-30% 25% 35% 45%
Permeability: This is defined as the ability of a rock to let water pass though it. It is measured in terms of coefficient of permeability.
Type of rock formation Average value of permeability coefficient in cm/sec 0.6 x 10 -5 4 x 10 -5 4 x 10 -5 0.004 0.4 4.0 0.04 0.04 x 10 -5
Granite, Quartzite Slate, Shale Limestone Sandstone Sand and Gravel Only Gravel Only Sand Clay and Soil
Velocity of groundwater
Slichters formula: Groundwater velocity va (in m/day) is given by: va = KID102/
where K is a constant (approximately 400) I is the slope of the hydraulic gradient line D10 is the effective size of the particles in the aquifer in mm and is the viscosity of water depending on the temperature
Velocity of groundwater
Hazens formula: Groundwater velocity va (in m/day) is given by: va = KID102/60 x (1.8T + 42)
where K (approximately 1,000) is a constant I andD10 is same as and T is the temperature of water in degrees celsius
To assess biodiversity in flora, the following data collection methods can be used:
Belt transect studies: This is done to determine the distribution pattern of the dominant species in the region. Girth, height and canopy of the dominant species with 25 m on each side of every nodal point are measured and tabulated. Plot quadrate method: This technique is used only when a part of a large area is sampled. Relative Basal Area: Basal area is a term commonly used for woody trees it refers to the cross-sectional area of all trees of a certain species. Bt = (D12 + D22 + D32 + .. Dn2)/4 /10 cm2/hectare
Fauna