Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bob Pekelnicky
Starting Point
Inconsistencies
ASCE 31 vs. ASCE 41
ASCE 41 evaluation reveals more deficiencies and leads to
greater upgrades
0.75 factor is hidden with the ASCE 31 m-factors
Sometimes there is no logical transition from ASCE 31 to
ASCE 41 m-factors
Simplified Procedure ASCE 41 can be used in fewer
instances than ASCE 31 Deficiency-only Tier 2
Next Issue
Inconsistencies between
ASCE 41-06 & 2009 NEHRP
> Seismic hazards do not use the same USGS maps (NGA, Max Direction, etc.)
> Determination of response spectra & time history record scaling different
> No risk targeting
> Levels of seismicity different from SDCs
> Nonstructural provisions out of sync for SDCs
> Wall out-of-plane forces
> ASCE 41 has more soil-foundation-structure interaction martial
Levels of Seismicity
ASCE 7-10
Seismic
Design
Category
ASCE 41-13
Level of
Seismicty
Very Low
Low
Moderate
D, E, & F
High
General Provisions
Consistent regardless of whether youre evaluating or upgrading
Basic Performance Objective for Existing Buildings
Preserves giving existing buildings a break, but use different seismic hazards instead of 0.75 factor
Eliminates confusion about what to do with RC III and IV buildings
Basic Performance Objective for New Building Equiv.
III
IV
Tier 1
BSE-1E
Tier 2
BSE-1E
BSE-1E
Tier 3
Life Safety
Structural
Performance
Life Safety
Structural
Performance
Life Safety
Structural
Performance
Life Safety
Nonstructural
Performance
Life Safety
Nonstructural
Performance
Life Safety
Nonstructural
Performance
(3-C)
(3-C)
(3-C)
BSE-2E
Collapse
Prevention
Structural
Performance
Nonstructural
Performance Not
Considered
(5-D)
Damage Control Damage Control Damage Control Limited Safety
Structural
Structural
Structural
Structural
Performance
Performance
Performance
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
(2-B)
Immediate
Occupancy
Structural
Performance
(2-B)
Immediate
Occupancy
Structural
Performance
(2-B)
Immediate
Occupancy
Structural
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
(1-B)
(1-B)
(1-B)
Nonstructural
Performance Not
Considered
(4-D)
Life Safety
Structural
Performance
Nonstructural
Performance Not
Considered
(3-D)
BSE-1N
Tier 3
Life Safety
Structural
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
III
Collapse
Prevention
Structural
Performance
Nonstructural
Performance Not
Considered
(3-C)
(5-D)
Damage Control Limited Safety
Structural
Structural
Performance
Performance
Position
Retention
Nonstructural
Performance
IV
BSE-2N
(2-B)
Immediate
Occupancy
Structural
Performance
Operational
Nonstructural
Performance
(1-A)
Nonstructural
Performance Not
Considered
(4-D)
Life Safety
Structural
Performance
Nonstructural
Performance Not
Considered
(3-D)
Performance Levels
No Major Changes to the Structural Performance Levels
Geotechnical Provision
Updates
Site hazards evaluated at same hazard the building is being evaluated to
Liquefaction Analysis Procedure
Analyze the structure with no Liquefaction
Analyze the structure with a liquefaction adjusted spectra and foundation properties
Analyze the structure for the lateral spreads and differential setttlements
Seismic Isolation /
Supplemental Damping
Provision Updates
Design can proceed with upper and lower bound properties instead of
waiting for isolator testing
Accidental torsion reduced
Vertical force distribution equation updated
Damper testing revised to be more stringent
Peer review requirements reduced to one independent reviewer
Recommended Part 1
Changes from ASCE 41
> Bring in ASCE 41 additional SFSI material Base Slab
Averaging and Embedment Reductions (based on FEMA
440 & ATC-83) into Chapter 19
> Bring forth changes to Chapters 17 and Chapter 18
based on the Seismic Isolation & Energy Dissipation
revisions