You are on page 1of 49

Cash Management and Forecasting

Outline:
Cash Management Process Considerations
Liquidity Management
Cash Concentration and Pooling Systems
Cash Forecasting
Projected Closing Cash Position
Cash Management Risks and Controls
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 1

Cash Management Framework


Collection , Disbursement & Concentration ( Speed up
Inflows, control outflows and minimize costs)
Determinants :

Organisations industry,
legal and regulatory environment,
payments system and
available payment instruments

Collections
Collection system which minimizes cost of collection
and collection float while maintaining desired level and
quality of information regarding customer remittances
and other sources
Costs include:
Float costs
Expenditures associated with managing the collections system
(banking fees, 3rd party collection etc)
Opportunity costs until funds are available for use

Collections
Collection Float : time interval or delay between when a
payment is initiated and when a company receives good
funds (primarily to paper based instruments)
Mail Float (delay b/w when cheque is mailed and day it is
received)
Processing Float ( delay b/w when payee receieves the check
and the day check is deposited into payees account)
Availability Float ( delay b/w the day a check is deposited and
the day a companys account is credited with collected funds)

Collection Float Components


Sending Party
Disbursement Float
Processing Float

Mail Float

Check is
drawn and
mailed out

Lockbox
receives
check

Field office
receives
check

Check encoded
and processed
through clearing
system

Clearing Float
Depositor
receives
collected
funds

Check
processed
and deposited

Receiving Party
Mail Float
2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 5

Collection Float
Processing Float

Availability Float

Check clears
back to
drawee bank
account

Float Calculation
Measured in dollar-days; e.g., annual sales of
$50,000,000 (5% in cash), 4 days avg. float,
8% opportunity cost
Average Daily Float = Average Daily Receivables Collected
Average Days of Float
$50,000,000 0.95
=
4 days

365

= $520,548 Dollar - days


Annual Cost of Float = Average Daily Float Opportunity
Cost of Funds
= $520,548 0.08 = $41,644
2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 6

Collection points
Company Processing Centre
Check processing and Deposit preparation are performed inhouse

Using Banking Channels / concentration

Collections : Company Processing


Center
Advantages
Control

Disadvantages

investment and
ongoing expenses
Flexibility
Increased mail float
Facilitation of updating
Increased processing
Customization
float
Customer service quality
Increased availability
Access information
float
Update A/R
Harder to establish
With volume comes
contingency and disaster
lower cost
recovery plans
2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 8

Capital

Collections Banking Channels


Setting collection banks - based on geographical location of
customers
Paper based cheque deposits in local branches
Float issue
Same Day

Electronic methods of payments


Predictability of settlement timing and availability of funds
Flexibility of directing payments to any account of FI without manual
intervention
Ease of transmitting customer remittance information to facilitate A/R
processing
Eliminates float costs

Collections Banking Channels


Electronic methods of payments Examples

- Customer payments via online transfers using IBFT


- Payment via RTGS
- Direct Debits (Standing instructions)
- Mobile payments

Major payment mechanisms in


Pakistan
Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) (2009)
Initially banks were using PRISM (RTGS) to transfer and settle
inter-bank transactions. This has enabled banks to transfer interbank transactions into beneficiaries accounts on the same day.
Inter Bank Fund Transfer (IBFT) (2012)
Apart from RTGS, through ATM Switch, instant A/C credit facility is
also available for beneficiaries through Inter Bank Fund Transfer
(IBFT). Now the turnaround time for account credit has
considerably reduced to maximum 30 minutes provided correct
beneficiary account number (IBAN) is mentioned in the payment
instructions.
Cheques

Major payment mechanisms in


Pakistan-RTGS
PRISM systems operated by State Bank of Pakistan
offers a powerful mechanism for limiting settlement and
systemic risks in the interbank settlement process by
providing settlement on Gross Basis and in Real Time.
Real Time Gross Settlement Systems (RTGS) are
mechanisms that enable banks to make large-value
payments to one another in real-time using online
telecommunication facilities as well as state-of-the-art
computer systems. The payments are settled on gross
basis in real time thus minimizing the systemic risks
that are inherent in large-value net settlement systems.

Major payment mechanisms in


Pakistan-RTGS
SBP took the decision to implement the RTGS primarily with
assistance from the World Bank.
Using this system, the banks holding accounts at SBP are
able to operate their accounts in real time from their own
premises via computerized network between SBP and the
participating Banks.
The 3rd Party transfer through PRISM/RTGS fall into one of
two categories
a)Big Value 3rd Party Transfers (Rs 1.000M and above)
b)Small Value 3rd Party Transfers (Rs 0.100M to Rs
0.999M)

Major payment mechanisms in


Pakistan-IBFT
Inter Bank Funds Transfer enables customers to transfer the funds in or
out of their account instantly between banks without the hassle of
making pay orders, writing cheques etc.
The service allows customers of 1LINK member banks to transfer funds
from their account to any of the millions of accounts of other
participating member banks on 1LINK network across the country.
The IBFT service is real-time and instantaneous which can be performed
from any Alternate Delivery Channels (Such as ATM, IVR, Call Center,
Internet, Mobile, etc) of 1LINK Member Banks.
Real-time and instantaneous funds transfer
Send up to Rs. 250,000 per day
IBFT enabled on all delivery channels (ATM, Internet, Call Center, Mobile)

Major payment mechanisms in


Pakistan- - Cheques
Clearing Services Offered by NIFT
Overnight clearing Including Return Cheque Processing
(24 hour Clearing Cycle)
Same Day/High Value Clearing including return cheque
Processing (3 hour Clearing Cycle)
Inter City clearing including Return Cheque Processing
(48 hour Clearing Cycle)
Countrywide Local US Dollar Clearing (5 day Clearing
Cycle)

Cash Concentration
Transfer funds from outlying depository locations to a
central bank account Concentration Account
OBJECTIVES

Minimize bank balances


Pool funds
Facilitate daily liquidity management
Invest more funds to increase income
Pay debt faster and reduce interest expense
Take advantage of vendor discount terms

Cash Concentration System Configuration


Considerations:
Size and geographic
distribution
Transfer alternatives
Branch footprint of
banks

Most large retail


chains transmit
information from
POS terminals to
EDTs and wire transfers
headquarters.
are most frequent.

Usually head quarters


initiate transfers
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Multiple branches of
single bank
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 17

Bank Services that Facilitate Deposit or


Automatic Concentration

Both
require
using
multiple
branches
of single
bank.

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

Zero balance
account
(ZBA)

Separate units deposit in distinct


depository accounts
Balances transferred automatically at
end of day to master concentration
account (balance is zero)

Deposit
reconciliation

Deposits from many locations credited


to one corporate bank account
Auxiliary on-us field carries unique
identifier for each company location for
location-specific deposit reports

Concentration costs : a)Excess


Balances
Average collected balance is greater than bank
compensation needs or chosen target.
Causes
Deposit reporting delays by field units
Clearing delays of one day when using ACH for cash
concentration
Transfer initiation delays if concentration entries are
submitted to the originating bank late or contain
reporting errors
Receipts posted or received subsequent to investment
cutoff times
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 19

Concentration costs : b)Bank Charges

Deposit and concentration banks may assess fees


for each deposit, deposited items, inbound and
outbound wires, ACH
clearings, deposit reports, overdrafts, negative
collected balances, and account maintenance.

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 20

Concentration costs : C)Admin Costs

Answer:
Managing deposit reportingreceiving and monitoring
daily reports from local managers and concentration banks
Scheduling cash transfersdeciding when
and what amounts to transfer
Preparing debit files
Reconciling deposit reports
Monitoring transfers to prevent internal
fraud
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 21

Reducing Concentration System


Costs
Enhance concentration system efficiency.
Improve transfer schedule timing.
Reduce excess balances.
Anticipate availability.
Anticipate deposits.
Use faster transfer mechanism.

Reduce transfer costs.


Use less expensive transfer mechanisms.
Transfer funds less frequently.
Threshold and target concentration.
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 22

Disbursements
Main goal of managing an Accounts Payable (A/P) and
disbursement system is to disburse funds in a timely,
accurate and cost effective manner
A/P and Payroll responsible for initiating vendor and
employee payments
Treasury directly responsible for debt and dividend
payments in addition to the funding of disbursement
accounts

Disbursements
Opportunity Costs
Excess borrowing or lost investment income
Paying bills late such as lost discounts or late fees
Paying bills early such as short-term investment interest income lost
or extra short term borrowing interest incurred

Administrative Cost
Overhead Costs of A/P dept
Fixed costs of disbursement system Account maintenance and balance reporting
Variable costs costs of issuing cheques, account reconciliation, stop payments &
fraud prevention
Overdraft costs

Disbursement Products
Paper Based Cheques etc
Direct Deposits
Electronic Transfers
Prepaid Cards
Corporate Credit Cards
Integrated or Comprehensive A/P
Outsource all or part of A/P or disbursement
Co. sends data file to provider containing list of all payments
to be made (to whom, instuctions on payment method etc)
2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 25

Controlled Disbursement
A bank service
providing notification of
the dollar amount of
checks that will clear
against a controlled
disbursement account
that day
Daily clearings usually
available by early or
mid-morning

2008 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Adequate funds must


then be provided to the
account to cover the
value of the checks
presented

Review 2 - 26

Positive Pay
Used to combat check fraud
Company transmits file of check information to the
disbursement bank
Bank matches numbers and amounts and only pays
matches

2008 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 27

Cost/Benefit of Funds Acceleration


Example:
Assume the following based on the fact that
a wire transfer accelerates funds one day
faster than an EDT.
EDT costs

$1.10

Total wire transfer costs$17.50


Total transfer amount

$110,000

Opportunity cost of funds 5%


2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 28

Cost/Benefit of Funds Acceleration


Formula and calculation
Funds Value
Opportunity

= Available Funds Days Accelerated Daily


Cost

Funds Value

= $110,000 1 (0.05/365)

= $110,000 1 0.0001369
= $110,000 0.0001369
= $15.06

Because the funds value ($15.06) is less than the incremental


costs of a wire transfer ($17.50 $1.10 = $16.40), it is more
advantageous
for the company to use an EDT rather than a
2008 Association
for Financial
Professionals. All
rightstransfer.
reserved.
wire
Review 2 - 29

Minimum Wire Transfer Amount


Example:
Assume the following based on the fact that a wire transfer
accelerates funds one day faster than an EDT.
EDT costs $1.25
Total wire transfer costs $14.00
Opportunity cost of funds

4.5%

What is the minimum amount that would justify using a wire


transfer vs. an EDT?
2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 30

Minimum Wire Transfer Amount


Formula and
calculation

Minimum Transfer

Wire Cost EDT Cost


Days Accelerated

Opportunity
365Cost
Days

$14.00 $1.25
1 Day

$12.75
0.0001232
2008 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Review 2 - 31

0.045
365
Days
=
$103,490.25

Cash Forecasting
Minimum
liquidity
Estimate
future cash
inflows and
outflows.

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

Generate a
pro forma
cash position.

Identify how
to cover cash
deficits/
surpluses.
Target
balances

Objectives of Cash Forecasting


Liquidity management
Schedule investment decisions.
Anticipate borrowing requirements.

Financial control
Meeting strategic objectives
Capital budgeting
Managing costs
Managing currency exposure

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 33

Forecasting Horizons
Short-term

Daily, weekly
or monthly
basis

Predict cash receipts and


disbursements and the
resulting balances.

Mediumterm

One to 12
months

Project the inflows


(collections from sales and
other sources of funds) and
outflows (expenses and
other uses of funds) on a
monthly basis.

Long-term

Any period
beyond one
year

Consider projections of longterm sales, expenditures,


and market factors; of
strategic importance.

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 34

Discussion Question
Identify the following forecasting horizons.
Answers:
Shortterm

1. Used to establish and manage target


balances for bank compensation purposes

Mediumterm

2. Used to determine the companys need for


short-term credit or availability of funds
for short-term investing

Mediumterm

3. Used as a performance
benchmark to compare actual
cash flows to projected cash
flows based on the cash budget

Long-term

4. Used by financial institutions and


rating agencies for credit analysis

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 35

Degrees of Certainty
Certain

Known in advance (e.g., interest, debt


principal repayments, dividends,
royalties, tax payments)

Predictable

Can be predicted with reasonable


accuracy; prediction of future cash
flows can be made based on past
observations (e.g., cash collections
from credit sales, payroll, clearing of
vendor checks)

Less
predictable

Difficult to forecast; involves experience


and judgment (e.g., new product sales,
unexpected repairs, claims, strike
settlements)

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 36

Forecasting Methods
A/R balance pattern
Receipts and
disbursements
forecast
Receipts schedule
Disbursements
schedule
Completed forecast
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 37

Distribution forecast

Simple average
Regression analysis

Pro forma financial statements

Statistical forecasting

Forecasting Methods: Receipts and


Disbursements Forecast

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 38

Forecasting Methods: Forecasting


Using the Distribution Method
Company used
regression
analysis to
estimate
proportion of
dollars that will
clear on a given
business day. It
has determined
the proportion
depends on the
number of days
since distribution.

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 39

Discussion Question
What are the three steps in percentage-of-sales
pro forma statement forecasting?
Answer:
Forecast income statement and balance sheet.
Calculate projected ending cash balance by determining
how forecasted income statement and balance sheet
values impact cash.
Compare projected ending cash
balance with target cash balance and
adjust pro forma statement to show
funding source for cash shortfall or
investment of cash surplus.
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 40

Current Income Statement and Balance


Sheet (Percentage-of-Sales)

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

To generate percentage-of-sales
forecast, following assumptions are
made (numbers in thousands):
Sales will increase by 10% to
$2,200 in 2011.
COGS, selling and administrative
expenses, current assets (cash,
receivables, inventory), and
payables are constant percentage
of sales.
Cash balance is derived from cash
flow statement.
Additional fixed assets of $100 will
be purchased.
Depreciation will be $50.
Notes will be reduced to $100 at
beginning of year.
Dividends will be $24.

Pro-Forma Income Statement and


Balance Sheet (Percentage-of-Sales)
All projected account
balances except cash are
calculated based upon
given assumptions.
Ending cash balance is
determined by evaluating
impact on cash of income
statement activity and
balance sheet changes
and adjusting beginning
cash balance accordingly.
v3.0 2011 Association for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

Discussion Question
Given the following two pro forma statements, what
is the projected ending cash balance?
Answer:

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 43

Statistical Forecasting
Extrapolation

Identifies past trends to predict pattern of


future cash flows.

Time series

Identifies repetitive patterns in a historical


series to predict future values of the series.
Simple moving average bases a forecast on a
rolling average of past values.
Exponential smoothing produces a forecasted
value based on the most recent actual value,
the most recent forecasted value, and a
number between zero and one that is used to
weight these two values.

Correlation

Statistically identifies degree of association


between a cash flow and another variable.

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 44

Simple Moving Average


Forecast

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

Exponential Smoothing
Forecast

Ft+1 = X t + 1 Ft
Where:
t = Time period subscript (t = current period, t+1 = next period, etc.)
Ft+1 = Cash flow forecast for the next period (t+1)
Ft = Cash flow forecast for the current period (t)
= Smoothing constant (0 < < 1)
Xt = Actual
cash flow for the current period (t)
v3.0 2011 Association
for Financial
Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

Discussion Question
How does a cash manager arrive at the projected
closing cash position?
Answer:
A cash manager adjusts opening bank
available balance by:
Adding the expected settlements in
collection and concentration accounts
Deducting the projected disbursement
totals

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 47

Cash Management Risks and


Controls: Internal Control Issues
System of checks and balances
Monitoring of transactions, cash flows and
information
Controls
Matching for errors, invoices, deposit amounts
Verification against bank reports
Segregation of duties at each step of a
transaction or outsourcing for smaller
companies

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.

Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

External Fraud
Disbursement
fraud

ACH fraud

Wire fraud

Technology:
color copiers,
printers,
scanners

Non-recurring
transaction
frequency

Highly
automated
system

Fraudulent
endorsements
and alterations

Payroll fraud
and ACH kiting

Target small or
medium firms
< $10,000

Positive pay
and payee
verification

Debit blocks
and filters,
controlled
disbursement

v3.0 2011 Association for Financial


Professionals. All rights reserved.
Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 -

You might also like