Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Qualitative
methodology and
analysis
Session 1
Introduction
Dr. Frances Michie, C.Psychol.
Associate Lecturer
Plymouth University
SESSION 2
OUTLINE
Practical:
Discussion around your chosen published
qualitative research paper
PRACTICAL
PUBLISHED RESEARCH: CRITIQUE
OBSERVATIONAL
RESEARCH METHODS
DEFINITIONS & PROCEDURES
ETHNOGRAPHY:
DATA COLLECTION & RESEARCHER ROLE
Field observations recorded via:
Voice recordings, Computers, Video, Semistructured interviews, Group discussion (focus
groups), Life histories, Personal documents (inc.
photos)
Researcher role:
ETHNOGRAPHY:
METHODOLOGY
1. Formulate the research question
2. Does the question lend itself to participant
observation
3. Define what is to be addressed in the observation
process
4. Define the researchers role
5. Entry/access to the community to be observed
6. Continuing access
7. The use of key informants
8. Field notes/data logging
9. How to sample
10.When to stop the fieldwork
ETHNOGRAPHY:
DATA ANALYSIS
No cookbook approach
Link different analytic techniques (complex
& varied data)
Researcher adds interpretative/analytic
notes similar to grounded theory,
discourse analysis, thematic analysis etc.
ETHNOGRAPHY:
WHEN TO USE
ETHNOGRAPHY:
EVALUATION
Resource hungry
Data collection method no clear association
with particular methods of analysis
Mainstream Psychology questions objectivity
Field note-taking problematic often draws on
memory
Reliance on interpretation as a situation unfolds
Where participation is emphasised may
change some of the social action being
observed (Hawthorne effect)
Interpersonal skills
GROUNDED THEORY
DEFINITIONS & PROCEDURES
GROUNDED THEORY
GLASER & STRAUSS 1960S
Natural setting
Participant perspective
Flexible design
To question:
What is occuring?
How is it occuring?
GROUNDED THEORY:
RATIONALE
Build rather than test theory
Give the research process the rigour
necessary to make the theory good science
Break through the assumptions and biases
brought to (and possibly developed) through
the research process (subjectivity)
Provide grounding:
Build density
Develop sensitivity & integration
Generate a rich, tightly woven & explanatory theory
which closely approximates the reality it represents
GROUNDED THEORY:
KEY ELEMENTS
Open Coding
Breaking down, examining, comparing, conceptualising & categorizing data
Axial Coding
Procedures where data are put back together in new ways after open
coding by making connections between categories
Selective Coding
Process of selecting the core category
Systematically relating it to other categories, validating those relationships
and filling in categories that need further refinement and development
Story:
a descriptive narrative about the central phenomenon of the study
Storyline:
the conceptualisation of the story (core category)
Core category:
The central phenomenon around which all the other categories are
integrated
GROUNDED THEORY:
RAW DATA & OPEN CODINGS
GROUNDED THEORY:
AXIAL CODINGS
Self esteem
Motivation
GROUNDED THEORY:
SELECTIVE CODING
The Story: descriptive narrative about the
central phenomenon
Self-esteem
Motivatio
CONTENT ANALYSIS
DEFINITION & PROCEDURES
CONTENT/THEMATIC ANALYSIS
Content Analysis:
A very general term to refer to ways of
categorising textual data to allow
comparisons to be made between aspects of
the data and to describe the contents of the
data
Analysis can involve quantification of
concepts
CONTENT ANALYSIS:
TYPES OF DATA & PROCEDURE
Used to determine the presence of certain words or
concepts within texts or sets of texts
Researchers quantify and analyse the presence, meanings
and relationships of such words and concepts - then make
inferences about the messages within the texts, the
writer(s), the audience, and even the culture and time of
which these are a part
Texts = books, book chapters, essays, interviews,
discussions, newspaper headlines and articles, historical
documents, speeches, conversations, advertising, informal
conversation - any occurrence of communicative language
Text is coded, or broken down, into manageable categories
on a variety of levels--word, word sense, phrase, sentence,
or theme--and then examined using one of content analysis'
basic methods: conceptual analysis
ANALYSIS
Conceptual analysis:
identifying research questions and choosing a
sample(s)
EXAMPLE:
THE EXPERIENCE OF STUDENTS IN HIGHER EDUCATION
Interviews with students
The research question might involve examining the
number of words used to describe the number of
negative/positive experiences used to describe the
experience
The researcher would be interested only in
quantifying these words, not in examining how they
are related, which is a function of relational analysis
In conceptual analysis, the researcher simply wants
to examine presence with respect to his/her research
question, i.e. is there a stronger presence of positive
or negative words used with respect to the quality of
experience for students in Higher Education
REPRESENTATION
CONCLUSIONS
Depending on the methodology adopted the data
& analysis will reveal different types of
information
Observational research is a method of data
collection and the types of analysis used can
vary Grounded theory lends itself well for this
type of data
Grounded theory data rather than hypothesis
driven theory emerges from the data
Highly systematic procedures
Content Analysis relatively simple as it describes
frequency of themes/concepts in the data