Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1872
UNLAWFUL
OBJECT
AGREEMENTS AGREEMENTS
AGREEMENTS
THAT THAT
THAT
ARE AGAINST ARE ILLEGAL
ARE UNLAWFUL
PUBLIC POLICY IN NATURE
Unlawful Object / Consideration
It is forbidden by law; or
It is of such nature that, if permitted, it would
defeat the provisions of any law; or
Is fraudulent; or
Involves or implies injury to the person or
property of another; or
The Court regards it as immoral or opposed
to public policy.
Agreements against Public Policy
1. Trading with an enemy
2. Marriage brokerage agreements
3. Agreements interfering with administration of
justice:
1. Interference with the course of justice
2. Champerty and maintenance contracts
3. Stifling prosecutions
4. Agreements tending to create interest against duty
7. Agreements as regards sale of public offices
8. Agreements tending to create monopoly
9. Agreements in restraint of marriage
Agreements against Public Policy
Contd
11. Agreements in restraint of trade-
Exceptions-
Sale of Goodwill
Partners agreements
Trade Combinations
Service Contracts
12. Agreements in restraint of legal proceeding
13. Agreement in restraint of Parental rights
14. Agreement restricting personal liberty.
15. Agreements interfering with marital duties.
16. Agreements to defraud creditors or revenue authorities
17. Agreements not to bid
18. Non-compliance of Courts order
Illegal Agreements
ALL ILLEGAL AGREEMENTS ARE VOID
/UNLAWFUL BUT ALL VOID/UNLWFUL
AGREEMENTS ARE NOT NECESSARILY
ILLEGAL
Effects of Illegality:
1. Illegal agreements are void- no action can be taken
for recovery of money paid or for breach
2. Collateral transactions to illegal agreement to are
tainted with illegality
3. In cases of equal guilt in an illegal agreement, the
position of defendant is better than that of the plaintiff.
CAPACITY TO CONTRACT
Who are Competent to Contract ?
UNSOUND DISQUALIFIED
MINORS
MINDS BY LAW
Position of a Minor in Contract
1. Minors contract is absolutely void
2. No specific performance of a minors contract
3. Ratification of a minors contract
4. If he has received any benefit under a void
agreement, he cannot be asked to compensate or
pay for it.
5. He can always plead minority.
6. His parents/guardian are/is not liable for the
contract entered into by him.
7. He cannot be adjusted insolvent.
Minors contracts are void-
Exceptions
Promisee or Transferee
Agency
Partnership
Necessaries (goods supplied or services
rendered)
CONTRACTS BY PERSONS OF
UNSOUND MIND
Contracts by lunatics
Contracts by idiots
Contracts by drunkards
Parties Disqualified By Law
Contracts by Corporations.
Contracts by convicts.
Contracts by insolvents.
Contracts by foreign Sovereigns, their diplomatic
staff and accredited representatives of foreign
States.
Aliens.
Contracts by Married Women & Pardanashin
Women.
FREE CONSENT
Free Consent
It is a voidable contract.
Money paid or anything delivered must be
returned.
Aggrieved party may rescind within a
reasonable time.
Undue Influence
FRAUDULENT OR INNOCENT OR
MISTAKE OF LAW MISTAKE OF FACT
WILFUL UNINTENTIONAL
MISTAKE OF
BILATERAL UNILATERAL
THE COUNTRY
EXISTENCE PHYSICAL
IDENTITY LEGAL
QUALITY
QUANTITY
TITLE
PRICE
DISCHARGE OF CONTRACT
DISCHARGE
BY
BY IMPOSSIBILITY PROMISEE
BY REFUSING BY
BY BREACH OF FAILING BY BY BY
BY TENDER OF AGREEMENT
BY DEATH OF PERFORMANCE TO OFFER OPERACION MATERIAL LAPSE OF
PERFORMANCE PERFORMANCE OR BY
CONTRACT (SUPERVENING FACILITIES OF LAW ALTERATION TIME
CONSENT
IMPOSSIBILITY) FOR
PERFORMANCE
DESTRUCTION
CHANGE
OF LAW
DEATH OR
PERSONALBY NOVATION
INCAPACITY
BY REMITTANCE
ACTUAL BY INSOLVENCY
ANTICIPATORY OUT-BREAK
BY WAIVER
BREACH BYMERGER
OF WAR BY RESCION
NON-EXISTENCE
OF
PARTICULAR
STATE OF
THINGS
How is the contract discharged?
By performance
By death
By refusing tender of performance
By breach of contract
By impossibility of performance
By agreement or by consent
By promisee failing to offer facilities for
performance
By operation of law
By unauthorized material alteration of a contract
By lapse of time.
By performance:
If both the parties to the contract have performed
what they have agreed to do, the contract is
discharged.
By death:
Where a contract is personal in character, or where
personal skill or ability is involved, death of promisor
discharges the contract.
By refusing tender of performance
If a party offers to perform his promise and the offer
has not been accepted by the other party, the
promisor is not responsible for non-performance.
By breach of contract:
If a party to a contract has refused to perform his part of the
promise, it is breach of contract.
It can be Actual breach or Anticipatory breach
By impossibility of performance:
When the performance of a contract becomes subsequently,
it becomes void & discharged.
Cases of impossibility:
Destruction of the object necessary for performance of
the contract.
Change of law.
Death or personal incapacity.
Out-break of war.
Non-existence of particular state of things which forms
the basis of the contract.
By agreement or by consent:
Contract can be terminated by mutual express or implied
agreement between the parties.
Novation: If the parties to a contract agree to substitute a
new contract for it, or to rescind or alter it.
Accord & satisfaction: Where a lesser sum is actually paid
than what is due under an existing contract, the new
contract is called accord and the actual payment is called
satisfaction.
Remission and waiver: When a party to the contract
abandons or waives his rights, contract is discharged
Rescission: When a person at whose option a contract is
voidable rescinds it, the other party thereto need not
perform his promise.
By promisee failing to offer facilities for
performance: If the promisee refuses to afford
the promisor reasonable facilities for the
performance of his promise, the contract is
dischared.
By operation of law:
By insolvency: On a person being adjudicated
insolvent, he is realised from all his debts and
liabilities.
By Merger: Merger of superior right into an inferior
right.
By unauthorized material alteration of a
contract: In case of material alteration by one
party to the contract without the consent of
the other party, the contract is discharged.
By lapse of time.
PERFORMANCE OF
CONTRACT
WHO MUST PERFORM:
The parties to a contract must either perform, or offer to perform their respective promises.
promisor or joint promisors, agent, third person, legal representative.
Essentials :
1. IT MUST BE UNCONDITIONAL
2. MADE BY PROMISSOR OR HIS REPRESENTATIVE
3. IT MUST BE AT A REASONABLE TIME & PLACE
4. IT MUST HAVE REASONABLE OPPORTUNITY TO PROMISEE OF ASCERTAINING
5. IT MUST BE FOR THE WHOLE OF THE PROMISE
6. IN CASE OF JOINT PROMISES, AN OFFER TO ONE IS OFFER TO ALL OF THEM
7. IT MUST BE MADE TO THE PROMISEE OR HIS DULY AUTHORISED AGENT
Reciprocal Promises
Promises which form the consideration or
part of the consideration for each other are
called reciprocal promises
Classifications:
Mutual and independent each party must perform
his/her promise independently and irrespective of the fact whether
the other party has performed or is willing to perform his promise
or not, the promises are mutual and independent.
Conditional and dependent where the performance of
promise by one party depends on the prior performance of the
promise by other party.
Mutual and concurrent where the promises of both the
parties are to be performed simultaneously.
Rules regarding performance
of reciprocal promises
To be simultaneously performed
Order in which reciprocal promises are to be
performed
In case of dependent promises where one
cannot be performed till the other is
performed
Effects, where a party prevents performance
To do certain things legal and also other
things illegal.
APPROPRIATION OF
PAYMENT
Where payment of debt to be discharged
indicated.
Where payment of debt to be discharged is
not indicated.
Where debtor does not intimate & the creditor
fails to appropriate.
BREACH OF
CONTRACT
TYPES:
1. SUPPLY OF NECESSARIES
5. COERCION OR MISTAKE
Quantum Meruit
Means as much as earned or deserved or as
much as is merited.
A person can under certain circumstances claim
payment for the work done or goods supplied
without any contract or under a contract which is
discharged by the breach of the other party.
It is for work done or services rendered.
The claim for quantum merit arises when:
An agreement is discovered to be void
Something is done without any intention to do so
gratuitously
There is an express or implied contract to render
services but there is no agreement as to
remuneration
The completion of the contract has been
prevented by the act of the other party to contract
A contract is divisible
An indivisible contract is completely performed but
badly
Wagering Agreement and
Contingent Contract
A wager is an agreement between two parties
by which one promises to pay money or
moneys worth on the happening of some
uncertain event in consideration of the other
partys promise to pay if the event does not
happen.
Contingent contract is a contract to do or not
to do something, if some event, collateral to
such contract, does or does not happen.
Difference: Wagering
Agreement and Contingent
Contract
WA consists of reciprocal promises whereas a
contingent contract may not contain reciprocal
promises.
WA is essentially of a contingent nature whereas a
contingent contract my not be of a wagering nature.
WA is void whereas contingent contract is valid.
WA is a game of chance. This is not so case of a
contingent contract.
In a WA the future event is the sole determining factor
while in a contingent contract the future event is only
collateral.
Earnest Money: It is treated as part payment of the price when the
contract is completed.
It can be forfeited in the case the party neglected to perform his part
of contract.
Advance Money: It is made merely as per payment of the purchase
price agreed upon between the parties.