Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Deficit Projections
(Percent of GDP)
12% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% -2% -4%
1992-2012 Average Deficit: 2.9% 2012-2022 Average Current Policy Deficit: 4.7%
Current Policy
Current Law
14% 12% 10% 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 Current Law Spending CRFB Realistic Spending 2012 2014 2016 2018 Current Law Revenues CRFB Realistic Revenues 2020
Non-Defense 17%
2011
Defense 19% Social Security 21%
Corporate Tax 5%
Debt Projections
(Percent of GDP)
500% 450% 400% 350% 300% 250% 200% 150% 100% 50% 0%
Realistic Projections 2010: 62% 2025: 94% 2040: 154% 2080: 430%
Current Law
Actual
Projected
Historical Average
Consequences of Debt
Crowding Out of private sector
investment, leading to slower economic growth
One way or another, fiscal adjustments to stabilize the federal budget must occur [if we don t act in advance] the needed fiscal adjustments will be a rapid and painful response to a looming or actual fiscal crisis.
-Ben Bernanke, Chairman of the Federal Reserve
Debt Drivers
Short-Term Long-Term
Economic Crisis
(lost revenue and increased spending on safety net programs like Food Stamps) (stimulus spending/tax breaks and financial sector rescue policies) (in 2001, 2003, and 2010) (in Iraq and Afghanistan)
Population Aging
What Costs Growing Interest the Debt Will Realistically Look Like
War Spending
Insufficient Revenue
Increases in Debt:
Technical & Economic Changes: 27% Tax Cuts: 27% Spending Increases: 41% Other Means of Financing: 6%
Note: Estimates from The Pew Charitable Trusts based on CBO data.
9
Projected
Interest
Aging
44%
Americans Are Wealthy and Willing to Pay More Fragmentation and Complexity among insurers,
providers, and consumers make normal market competition difficult
36% 64%
Public
Private
Source: 2008 Data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
13
36%
16:1
5:1
64%
3:1
2:1
64%
Interest 6%
Interest 19%
Interest 28%
Insufficient Revenue
Unpaid for Tax Cuts in 2001, 2003, and
2010 lowered revenue collection without making corresponding spending cuts or tax increases to offset the budgetary effect
18
401(k)s and IRAs Earned Income Tax Credit Special Rates for Capital Gains and Dividends
Non-Defense Discretionary 15% Health Spending 18% Social Secutity 16% Other Mandatory 12%
State & Local Tax Deduction Charitable Deduction Child Tax Credit
$1.7 Trillion
$5.1 Trillion
$6.4 Trillion
$0.4 Trillion
$3.8 Trillion
$5.2 Trillion
-$0.8 Trillion
$2.6 Trillion
$4.0 Trillion
So even if lawmakers were to stabilize debt at 70% of the economy in 2021 a level higher than the internationally recognized threshold of 60% they would have to enact at least $2.8 trillion in savings beyond the $920 billion enacted in the Budget Control Act, compared to realistic assumptions of future debt. That calls for a Go Big approach to debt reduction.
23
Growth
Strong economic growth is a necessary
but not sufficient condition for debt reduction
4.0% 3.5% 3.0% 2.5% 2.0% 1.5% 1.0% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 CBO Baseline Growth Medium Output Effect Small Output Effect Large Output Effect
CBO studied the economic impact of an illustrative $2.4 trillion debt reduction plan and found that real output would be between 0.6% and 1.4% higher, depending on the magnitude of the effects.
*Estimates from CBO, The Macroeconomic and Budgetary Effects of an Illustrative Policy for Reducing the Federal Budget Deficit.
25
26
27
Possible Policy Changes Government-Wide Discretionary Health Care Other Mandatory Social Security Revenues Net Interest Total
Savings $250 billion from chained CPI $100-200 billion from modestly slower growth in BCA caps Negligible savings $150-250 billion from farm subsidies, federal civilian and military retirement and benefits, Fannie and Freddie, and others Negligible savings Negligible savings $100 billion $600-800 billion
Without addressing
health care reforms or revenues, it will be very difficult to achieve significant savings
28
Adding Serious Entitlement Reforms and Revenues Pushes You into Go Big
Democrats will only agree to serious entitlement reforms if there are revenues Republicans will only agree to revenues in the context of comprehensive tax reform Democrats will only agree to a comprehensive tax reform that replaces the Bush tax cuts if it raises at least the $800 billion they would get if President Obama vetoes extension of upper income tax cuts Republicans will not agree to revenues anywhere near that amount without health savings that go beyond the amount proposed by the President
29
Advantages of Go Big
Debt stabilized and falling as a share of
the economy later in the decade, and all the benefits associated with a declining debt burden:
Less crowding out of private sector
investment Stronger confidence in businesses and markets Greater certainty and stability Stronger economy over the long-term Lower interest payments and increased fiscal space Intergenerational equity Reduced or eliminated risk of fiscal crisis
30
31
32
Note: For more information on the announcement effect, see CRFB at http://crfb.org/blogs/announcing-announcement-effect-club
An incremental approach would allow advocates for parts of the budget to argue
that they are bearing an unfair burden. A Go Big approach which achieves savings in all parts of the budget neutralizes that argument.
33
34
Note: $4 trillion plan is a more ambitious version of the types of reforms in the $2.8 trillion plan.
Social Security
Progressive benefit changes, retirement
age increase, tax increase for high earners totaling $300 billion.
Bottom Rates Current Rates for 2012 Scheduled Rates for 2013 Eliminate All Tax Expenditures Keep Child Tax Credit and EITC Fiscal Commission s Illustrative Tax Plan 10% 15% 8% 9% 12% 15%
Fiscal Commission s illustrative tax plan would reduce or eliminate most tax expenditures and use the savings to reduce tax rates and reduce the deficit.
36
37
Bowles-Simpson Recommendations
Savings Enacted
Allows for gradual phase in Improves generational fairness Gives taxpayers businesses,
and entitlement beneficiaries time to plan
201 2
4.9%
201 5
5.9%
Creates announcement
effect to improve growth
202 0
8.1%
202 5
12.5%
Every month and year that passes, the debt grows larger and larger and
the solutions become more difficult
Elections can take policy options off the table and back candidates into
positions that make bipartisan solutions more difficult
40
60+ former government officials, business leaders, and experts Editorial boards and other outside experts Countless concerned citizens
41
Make Deficit Reduction a Top Priority Propose Specific Fiscal Targets Recommend Specific Policies to Achieve the Targets Do No Harm Use Honest Numbers and Avoid Budget Gimmicks Do Not Perpetuate Budget Myths Do Not Attack Someone Else s Plan Without Putting Forward an Alternative Refrain from Pledges That Take Policies Off the Table Propose Specific Solution for Social Security, Health Programs, and the Tax Code Offer Solutions for Temporary and Expiring Policies Encourage Congress to Come Up with a Budget Plan as Quickly as Possible Remain Open to Bipartisan Compromise
If not addressed, burgeoning deficits will eventually lead to a fiscal crisis, at which point the bond markets will force decisions upon us. If we do not act soon to reassure the markets, the risk of a crisis will increase, and the options available to avert or remedy the crisis will both narrow and become more stringent.
-Erskine Bowles and Sen. Alan Simpson, Former co-chairs of the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform
43